Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Elephants at centre of tourism tiff

An elephant, caked with mud after being bathed by visitors and volunteers near the base camp of the Elephant Valley Project in Mondulkiri province, roams the fields
An elephant, caked with mud after being bathed by visitors and volunteers near the base camp of the Elephant Valley Project in Mondulkiri province, roams the fields. The project is attracting tourists who prefer an alternative to riding elephants. LAURA MA

Elephants at centre of tourism tiff

For the ethnic Bunong people in this northeastern province, animals are an integral part of the local economy.

Pigs, chickens and water buffaloes offer a variety of sustenance and labour. But it’s the elephants that bring foreigners – and foreigners bring cash.

“When I get tours, the money is spread around the community,” said 32-year-old Mnacn Hong, who has been a mahout, or elephant trainer, since the age of 13 in Poutang village, near Mondulkiri’s capital, Sen Monorom.

Hong and other local guides say tourist dollars flowed until 2005, when a conservation initiative called the Elephant Valley Project (EVP) started offering visitors a chance to observe, as opposed to ride, elephants.

The project was lauded in the media and travel blogs as an ethical alternative to the local tours. Any cursory search on the internet will result in posts and articles describing elephants beyond the reach of the project as abused.

Hong, like other mahouts in the area, has felt the reaction financially and personally.

“My elephants work four hours a day, and we treat them like family,” he said. “If there was no EVP, there would be more people in my community. Now, the tourists go to the Elephant Valley Project because they say don’t go to the communities.”

At $60 for two people, the local trek guides tourists from the village to the waterfalls, through the jungle, then back to the village. According to Hong, business is down 50 per cent.

The Elephant Valley Project, run by an NGO called Elephant Livelihood Initiative Environment, or ELIE, gives guests an opportunity to observe animals in their natural setting, deep in the jungle. The EVP website advertises a full-day tour, including food, for $70. After a hike to one of three designated valleys that elephants are led to by their mahouts, visitors get a chance to see them roam the environment and bathe in the river. In the afternoon, tourists can help bathe the elephants from a man-made concrete platform.

No elephant riding allowed here, though.

Jemma Bullock, ELIE eco-tourism program officer and Elephant Valley Project assistant manager, insists that villages are exaggerating, and that the project doesn’t condemn elephant-riding tours. She pointed out that the project pays some local mahouts a $125 monthly wage to bring their elephants, instead of letting them out for rides, to the sanctuary to “do what elephants do best”, play with mud and eat.

“Visitors’ stay and donations directly contribute to the protection of these beautiful creatures, both captive and wild,” Bullock said.

“[Tourists] support many other programs that ELIE runs, providing benefits to the local Bunong community, including healthcare both in the community where the tourism project is based, as well as growing coverage to all elephant owners in Mondulkiri, a communal land-titling program, school support program and other small projects,” she said.

Jack Highwood, director of the project, declined to comment, but the “History” section of the EVP website explains where it stands.

“Elephants are able to generate a large income for the impoverished indigenous peoples, but in many cases the elephants are not receiving proper care,” it reads in part.

Despite the good intentions, anger is mounting over the distribution of tourism dollars that the NGO receives in comparison to local tourism businesses.

“The locals accuse us of being a business that keeps all the money,” Bullock said. “And they’re upset because they think we are taking all the tourists, but that’s not true.”

Broad statistics support some of her claim. Mondulkiri is one of four provinces, including Kratie, Ratanakkiri and Stung Treng, that the Ministry of Tourism is pushing as an eco-tourism destination. Although there are fears that the EVP is diverting funds from locals, Mondulkiri has seen a steady increase in domestic and international tourists, a 9.7 per cent rise from 2011 to 2012.

Puch Sorya, deputy director of Mondulkiri’s tourism department, believes tourists wanting to ride elephants have actually increased.

“The Elephant Valley Project has not affected overall tourism,” he said.

Talk to locals, however, and they are quick to tell a different story.

Sam Nang, the owner of the Green House, which provides lodging and schedules tours, estimates that 80 per cent of visitors ask for the Elephant Valley alternative, ignoring other options.

Amid mounting tension between the EVP and the Bunong, Nang has found himself in the middle. Locals call him “two-faced” because he is the only tour operator in town that arranges EVP visits and traditional elephant riding.

Still, he encourages tourists to visit elephants at local sites.

“The Bunong villages rely on tourism for survival and food,” he said. “It’s not a hard job for the elephants. They get more freedom and it helps the families.”

The Elephant Valley Project competes with locals for other tourism business, including treks and hotels. Tours to waterfalls, villages, coffee plantations and jungle trekking have seen less traffic, locals say.

Than Phbara Kech, a local tour guide and travel operator who has worked with the Poutang community for more than eight years, said villages with elephants have also lost out on overnights.

“When tourists do homestays, the family they stay with gets an income, but the NGO has bungalows,” he said.

In Poutang, one elephant is typically owned by five to 12 families, consisting of around 10 people, who share the profits. The village has a total of nine elephants. Another village, Poulang, has eight. The EVP mainly works with a village called Putrom.

Phbara Kech said Bunong mahouts aren’t able to go on the web and defend themselves on English-language travel sites.

“People should come to Mondulkiri and talk to people and find out themselves. Not only reading in Lonely Planet and believing these things.”

Diverting funds or not, the Elephant Valley Project is a clear hit with tourists.

Tamsin Lambert, 30, visited at the beginning of September. It was the only tour she did in Mondulkiri, before travelling to Siem Reap.

“These are not the lifestyles and actions of people who are making a profit. These are the lives and actions of people who deeply care, not just about the elephants, but also the people of Bunong and Cambodia, and the habitat that links them all.”

1

Comments

Please, login or register to post a comment
Sok's picture

Dear Phnom Penh Post readers - We to shed some light on the true reasons that have led to the organized community protest against the activities and conduct of the NGO E.L.I.E ( EVP ) :The NGO’s official ( registered ) goal is to improve the health and welfare of domestic elephants in Mondulkiri Province – but instead of supporting all communities, the NGO is focused on promoting its own tourism enterprise: the Elephant Valley project.Instead of promoting and offering support for the development of eco-tourism at multiple communities - The organization regularly de-legitimizes and actually competes with all other elephant keepers in Mondulkiri and slams them as inhumane and abusive.For the past 6 years, the NGO had informed all its visitors, on its web site and in multiple articles it had published - that Bunong and Khmer people regularly beat, misuse and abuse their elephants and that the elephants at EVP are better kept.The NGO claims that elephants are not safe anywhere in Mondulkiri (unless they are receiving "superior care" at E.V.P). The NGO fails to inform visitors that most Bunong elephants are actually in very good condition and that all elephants in Mondulkiri kept at community forests while tourists who visit the community only ride them for about an hour only.The description of tourist rides on E.L.I.E's website and much of the content is completely exaggerated and unfair towards all locals who are caring well for the elephants.Despite the fact that EVP was offering tourist rides in its early years (please see proof in lonely planet Cambodia 2006 ) - The NGO now openly campaigns against elephant riding and redeem tourists who ride elephants as cruel and ignorant.Since 2006, only 1 Bunong elephants involved in tourism had died, of old age at Patang village. While 2 elephants had died at the Elephant valley project after the organization had been providing them “superior care”.These actions have greatly impacted and damaged Bunong community tourism outside the EVP – Approximately % 80 of visitors to Mondulkiri now visit the EVP only, then leave. They aren't encouraged to see the rest of the province.Visitors are more than happy to contribute to the EVP, believing their donations go directly towards saving elephants – But funds raised by E.L.I.E have been invested only in its own growth, establishment and publicity.The “NGO slogan is “to visit us is to save them”- While visitors easily believe it when they hear it from an NGO, all residents in Mondulkiri will confirm it is simply not true! NON of the elephants currently on display at the Elephant valley project were actually “ saved or rescued” as the NGO claims – E.L.I.E. buys or rents any elephant it can get, sick or healthy. The NGO separates elephants from local keepers, gives the animals catchy English names and a heart breaking story in order to attract tourist pity and donations.According to other, bios NGOs in Mondulkiri, The EVP sees nearly 200 visitors per week.Each visitors now pay $ 70 per day, which totals nearly $ 50000 per month. That is an enormous amount by any standard - Yet NGO admins insist they do not make money...It is absurd that E.L.I.E had been blaming the locals of greed and exploitation when observing these figures, that do not include unaccountable Paypal Donations and fund raising.While E.L.I.E provides employment to some locals, it’s campaign had damaged the livelihood of hundreds of Bunong and Khmer Families in Sen Monorom and the area.Many elephant owners, who have previously worked with the NGO, have complained of unfair work contracts, preventing them from leaving the project freely as well as verbal abuse by NGO staff. They report that their elephants have not received better feeding or better care than at home village. Bunong elephant owners outside the EVP have testified the organization has never helped with infrastructure, veterinary care or better facilities for their animals as it has promised to do.The visitor center at EVP is actually registered as a public area and a nonprofit community center. Yet ELIE has been illegally running as a closed and private property. It is impossible to access EVP freely without payment or even show up without pre-arranging your visit.It is unacceptable that a registered nonprofit organization is operating a highly profitable, neo-colonial business that barely benefits one community, while avoiding taxes and intentionally destroying the livelihood of all other communities. E.L.I.E uses visitor donations to pay Western staff, run an office, big publicity teams and regular bribes the local authorities , who in return overlook and support its illegal business operations – while elephant owners and small local businesses struggle to survive.In joint community action, a complaint has been submitted to the local authorities by the people of Sen Monorom on September 10th. It represents thousands Bunong and Khmer Community members who wish to protest against the NGO. Demanding an immediate suspension of the NGO’s license and a national level inspection of the operation since 2006

Latest Video

Sebastian Strangio

Under the cover of Hun Sen's Cambodia

His book Hun Sen's Cambodia is the first truly comprehensive analysis of a man who has reigned over his country for almost 30 years.

Sambo

Sambo the elephant retires

Celebrity pachyderm to settle down in Mondulkiri elephant sanctuary after decades entertaining.

Fire rips through Psar Chas

A blaze in Phnom Penh's Psar Chas razed a section of the market and damaged up to 70 per cent of its 900 stalls.