Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - An Accident Just Waiting To Happen?

An Accident Just Waiting To Happen?

Lax security and flagrant disregard of safety mea-sures-coupled with a recent increase

in air traffic that is taxing rudimentary navigational equipment and inadequately-trained

staff-makes Pochentong International Airport one of the most dangerous in the region,

according to sources involved in Cambodia's aviation.

The main fault for the deterioration in safety seems to lie with UNTAC, which has

not compensated for the additional traffic pressure it has put on the Pochentong

facility and for flaunting basic safety precautions.

The situation has been compounded by a doubling of commercial traffic, an increase

from an average of five flights daily to ten flights a day.

"The place is a flight safety officer's nightmare-it is an accident waiting

to happen, and it is only by the grace of God that we have not had a major accident

yet," says a senior UNTAC official in aviation.

Commercial aircraft landing in Phnom Penh have had to abruptly pull out of their

descent on at least three occasions during November alone because of UNTAC vehicles,

motorbikes and pedestrians on the runway, say sources.

Two of the incidents involved Vietnam Airlines planes; the most recent occurred Nov.

23 as a regularly-scheduled Bangkok Airways plane was about to touch down.

A Kampuchea Airlines helicopter had landed a few minutes before and moved to the

western taxiway, which connects the runway with the aircraft parking space adjacent

to the airport terminal building.

The helicopter stopped on the taxiway for some reason. Meanwhile, a private vehicle

temporarily hired by UNTAC, ignored a red light and tried to cross the runway from

the military side of the airport to the civilian side.

Only when the vehicle was smack in the middle of the runway did the driver realize

that the helicopter blocked its way. There the vehicle sat oblivious to the Bangkok

Airways Boeing 737 only several hundred feet above the ground and descending rapidly.

The airplane's pilot was instructed by the control tower to pull up.

"The security at the airport is lousy; there are UNTAC vehicles running all

over the place, and they never seem to think that their vehicles might stall while

they are crossing the runway," said a senior UNTAC officer who happened to be

on the Bangkok Airways' Nov. 23 flight.

After pulling up again, which is not an especially dangerous maneuver (but it will

consume roughly U.S. $500 of additional fuel), the Bangkok Airways pilot told his

Nov. 23 passengers that he probably could have landed safely. Controllers confirm

this assumption but say the pilot would have had to brake hard to land safely.

"It was not a collision hazard, but it should not happen at all," said

a controller on duty at the time. "Once is too much for an airport of this size."

As with previous incidents, a report was filed with the State of Cambodia's Department

of Civil Aviation (DCA), but there appears to have been little follow-up if any.

"We are not turning a blind eye to this problem and we have had several discussions

with UNTAC military [officials]," says former State of Cambodia Air Force Colonel

Soeung Samnang, who currently serves as DCA's chief of flight operations.

But, he adds, "We need closer cooperation and understanding, otherwise the traffic

on the ground could pose a threat to air safety."

In other recent incidents, the control tower directed pilots to pull up when a pair

of motorbikes were spotted cruising the runway and another time when an UNTAC employee

was walking over to the military side of the airport after having been dropped off

on the civilian side.

Cambodia recently became a member of the International Civil Aviation Organization

(ICAO) which requires runways to be empty for any landings. In most international

airports no non-aircraft traffic is allowed on the runways.

On this account, some negligence can be attributed to the DCA which has 20 airport

police, but they appear to spend most of their time keeping cool in the VIP lounge,

according to workers at the airport.

In effect though, UNTAC has considerable sway at the airport. With the facility's

only radar, the military has effective operational control. And those working in

the aviation sector say that some confusion arises from a split of objectives between

the civilian and military side of UNTAC.

The civilians have been pushing for control of the airport to revert back to DCA,

apparently out of concern over liability issues. The military, on the other hand,

insist that they need operational control and that they are willing to handle the

civilian needs as part of their overall control.

The matter seems to revolve around whether UNTAC Force Commander, Lt. General John

Sanderson has withdrawn from an agreement he signed with the DCA to assume control

of commercial and military air traffic at the airport.

ICAO officials who are up-grading the training of Khmer traffic controllers are in

favor of the current arrangement because without the military assistance the control

tower would have to resort to the more rudimentary "procedural control."

"The agreement buys us time," says an ICAO official.

He estimates the Khmer controllers will be up to international standards in four

or five months. Left to themselves without that training, the airport will probably

have to curtail its hours of operation so that international supervision can be maintained


Pol-Pot Era Airport

While UNTAC has nearly transferred all of its operations over to the military side

of Pochentong Airport, relieving what had been dangerous congestion on the apron,

they are still bringing in additional helicopters, so the military has already run

out of parking space on its side of the airport.

With large troop rotations to begin soon UNTAC is "looking strongly into the

possibility" of moving a sizeable part of their operations to an airport at

Kompong Chhnang, which the Chinese built in the 1970s when they were the main allies

of the Khmer Rouge. Intended for military purposes, the airport was never used, although

the runway is in considerably better shape than the Pochentong air strip. Both air

strips feature 9,600-foot runways that can accommodate jumbo-size jets. The main

problem with moving to Kompong Chhnang is the 86-km. road to Phnom Penh.

One worry at Pochentong is that just to bring Kompong Chhnang up to 'tactical quality'

will probably mean UNTAC will take their radar system with them.

Ordinarily a radar system could be replaced easily enough but UNTAC's record of providing

navigational gear is not reassuring.

Initial UNTAC promises of providing a wide range of equipment-as well as additional

air traffic controllers to open a country-wide Area Control Center-have not come

to fruition.

"To this day they have not supplied one piece of gear, they have not supplied

one controller," says a source involved in rebuilding Cambodia's aviation sector.

"We talk to them, we listen to them, they are nice people and all that but we

don't rely on them or plan on anything they say they are going to do."

Budgetary realities may have tempered initial plans, as well as the sensitivities

to the charge of unduly helping out the State of Cambodia. But bureaucratic snafus

are another factor. At one time, three different entities were supposed to be in

charge of acquiring critical navigational aides: ICAO, a Texas firm and UNTAC itself,

which has no real expertise in this area.

"Sometime I think it [the inaction] is because no one can make a decision,"

says this source in frustration. "UNTAC is probably the most disorganized organization

I have ever seen. Not only do they not know what they are doing, they don't seem

to know what they should be doing."

As a result the operation is riddled with inefficiency and confusion. One example

is the lack of a direct communications link between the control tower, which comes

under the jurisdiction of the DCA and is responsible for commercial traffic, and

the military side of the airport.

A French detachment, which handles the air-port's only radar facilities, at one time

had provided a UNTAC radio handset for the civilians in the control tower but took

it back when one of theirs broke down.

A domestic telephone line run into the control tower to replace the radio handset

was never fully operational.

The result is that the control tower can only communicate with their military counterparts

by going through the French radar operators, where some delay is inevitable.

The alternative is using a satellite telephone link, recently installed at the control

tower by Aerothai, the Thai aeronautical organization. A small hitch: it is a Bangkok


Meanwhile these days there are four or five aircraft in the air at the same time

coming in for a landing at Pochentong just minutes apart, say air traffic controllers.

The airport's air traffic control equipment does not meet international standards,

though the United Nations Development Program is gradually providing new equipment

as well as training for the controllers.

The U.S. $2.3 million project also provides on site three ICAO supervisors, although

one is being sent home after his performance did not match his credentials on paper

. He will have a replacement.

As for overall safety at the airport: "It is getting better but it is still

far below ICAO standards," says an ICAO official.

Controller Brain Drain

On the horizon is another potential problem: a possible brain drain from the trained

Khmer air traffic controllers, who win high praise for their eagerness to learn,

but are still being paid only U.S. $25 per month (supervisors receive U.S. $35).

Even locally hired UNTAC secretaries sometimes earn six or seven times that amount.

After scrapping the idea of bringing in experienced controllers from Thailand or

Malaysia to work for U.S. $1,500 monthly as dispiriting for the local staff both

UNDP and UNTAC agreed to supplement the Khmer salaries. Both intentions have apparently

died bureaucratic deaths.

Ambitious plans to refurbish Cambodia's other airports have also become clogged in

UNTAC's in/out paper trays.

UNTAC officials now say they will take it upon themselves to repair a 300 meter stretch

of the runway at Battambang while they are still in the process of awarding a U.S.

$4.5 million contract to rebuild the runway at Stung Treng.



Please, login or register to post a comment

Latest Video

Turkish Embassy calls for closure of Zaman schools

With an attempted coup against the government of President Recep Erdogan quashed only days ago and more than 7,000 alleged conspirators now under arrest, the Turkish ambassador to Cambodia yesterday pressed the govern

CNRP lawmakers beaten

Two opposition lawmakers, Nhay Chamroeun and Kong Sakphea were beaten unconscious during protests in Phnom Penh, as over a thousand protesters descended upon the National Assembly.

Student authors discuss "The Cambodian Economy"

Student authors discuss "The Cambodian Economy"

Students at Phnom Penh's Liger Learning Center have written and published a new book, "The Cambodian Economy".