Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Case made for genocide verdict

Khmer Rouge tribunal International Co-Prosecutor Nicholas Koumjian (right) and his deputy, William Smith, during closing statements in Case 002/02 on Wednesday at the ECCC.
Khmer Rouge tribunal International Co-Prosecutor Nicholas Koumjian (right) and his deputy, William Smith, during closing statements in Case 002/02 on Wednesday at the ECCC. ECCC

Case made for genocide verdict

International lead co-prosecutor Nicholas Koumjian delivered his closing statements in the trial of Khmer Rouge leaders Nuon Chea and Khieu Samphan yesterday, speaking about one of the charges that has gained the most attention throughout the trial: genocide against the Vietnamese and Cham people.

Koumjian began by speaking about crimes carried out against the Vietnamese in Cambodia, alleging that the government’s initial policy of simply deporting Vietnamese nationals eventually transformed into a policy of extermination both within Cambodia and abroad.

“In the beginning of the regime . . . it was [Khmer Rouge] policy to remove the Vietnamese . . . from Cambodia. That intent evolved over time, and we see in the latter years of the regime that the intent was to destroy, to kill, all those that remained,” Koumjian explained.

“Brother Number Two” Chea and former Democratic Kampuchea head of state Samphan were both quoted claiming that the Vietnamese were in fact engaged in genocide against Cambodians, a tactic Koumjian said is common in persuading a population to commit genocide of its own against the alleged enemies.

Chea once said the Vietnamese “will never abandon their ambition to wipe out the Cambodian race”, while Samphan said in 1977 the Vietnamese behaved “like Hitler” and wanted to “enslave our people and turn all of us into Vietnamese”.

Koumjian believed the strongest evidence that Cambodia’s ultimate goal was to destroy the Vietnamese people lies in a statement from Pol Pot broadcast on the radio in 1978. In the broadcast, Pol Pot estimated that each Cambodian soldier was capable of killing 30 Vietnamese, and therefore Cambodia could wipe out the entire population with only 2 million soldiers.

“We don’t have to engage 8 million people. We need only 2 million troops to crush the 50 million Vietnamese,” Pol Pot said.

Koumjian played clips of personal testimony recounting mass executions, including the murders of infants. Two 7-year-old Vietnamese boys were imprisoned and executed at the infamous S-21 prison for allegedly being spies.

He also recalled stories of atrocities committed in Vietnamese towns across the border by Cambodian troops that, while outside the scope of this trial, may be evidence that the Khmer Rouge’s goal was to wipe out the population as a whole.

Koumjian next moved to the topic of alleged genocide against the Muslim Cham minority, explaining that the situation for them differed in that many Cham were given the opportunity to survive by abandoning their customs. This, he argued, still constitutes genocide. He pointed to international law on the matter.

“Genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such,” the law states. Koumjian focused on the phrase “as such”, claiming that a group can be destroyed in whole or in part if it is materially changed.

“What does it mean to destroy a religious group ‘as such’?” he asked. “If you stop these people from practising their religion, the group no longer exists. The individual may exist but you have destroyed the religious group as such.”

Koumjian argued that in addition to killing Cham people simply for being Cham, they forced them to abandon their faith and dispersed populations.

The co-prosecutor closed by speaking about the role of the accused, claiming Samphan and Chea were Pol Pot’s most trusted advisers, and therefore equally responsible for the development and implementation of his policies.

“I entitled this section in my own notes: The Gang of Three,” Koumjian said.

“Khieu Samphan, along with Nuon Chea, were Pol Pot’s closest associates. And I want to be clear we are not saying they were among Pol Pot’s closest associates . . . The centre consisted of . . . this gang of three.”

Koumjian pointed out that according to surviving standing committee minutes, Chea attended 18 meetings, Pol Pot attended 17 meetings and Samphan attended 16 meetings. The next most involved member attended 12 meetings.

Samphan’s defence council in particular has argued that he had limited knowledge of the crimes carried out because, despite being the country’s head of state, he claims to have not been high ranking within the party itself.

Koumjian, however, explained that by January 1978 Samphan was the only surviving member of Office 870, and therefore all communications sent to that office should be considered direct communications with him. Among those telegrams were messages informing the office of mass murders committed in Vietnamese territory.

National Co-Prosecutor Chea Leang closed out the final statements, requesting life in prison for the accused. “Unlike the teenage security guards that the [Khmer Rouge] forced to work at places like S-21, and who were pressured to abuse, torture and kill or be killed themselves, these accused were under no such pressure.

"It was them who developed these criminal policies to create this atmosphere of fear and terror, not they who were subject to them.”

1

Comments

Please, login or register to post a comment
khassan's picture

Dear Editors:

The Khmer Rouge hybrid court has come to the conclusion on Case 002/02, convicting and sentencing Khieu Samphan and Nuon Chea to life in prison based on what the Hanoi-backed Hun Sen government wants the result to be at the end. The outcome is a foregone conclusion.

This Khmer Rouge tribunal took off to an unfair start: first, it's set up in a country where numerous accomplices to the alleged crime of genocide and crime against humanity took place. Second, it was overseen by a deputy prime minister, the late Sok An, who himself was a former Khmer Rouge official at the ministry of industry and transport under Vorn Veth. Third, none of the ruling elite who were former Khmer Rouge civilian and military officials with ties to the "Killing Fields" has been called to testify or answer questions in the tribunal. Fourth, most if not all Cambodian judges and prosecutors owed their allegiance to Hanoi and to the Hun Sen regime for sending them to study in former East Germany and other countries in Eastern Europe. Fifth, witnesses live in an environment where former Khmer Rouge cadres run the country. Fears of reprisal and concerns for loss of benefit pre-occupy their minds. The suspects were presumed guilty or convicted by the public from media publicity; hence, no fair trial.

Between 1976-1977 Sok An aided and abetted Vorn Veth in a plot to topple the DK government by bringing in 108 Vietnamese commandos to free then Prince Norodom Sihanouk and his wife from the royal palace. All but 4 Vietnamese commandos were killed by the Khmer Rouge forces. Sok An managed successfully to hide 4 Vietnamese commandos under his sleeping bed until Hanoi established an invasion staging area on December 2, 1978.

Nowhere during the decade-long trial was there any mention of KR army division 09 based at Chhlong forest, Kratie province, that was aided by Vietnamese army to sabotage and prepare to launch a coup against Pol Pot faction. A pro-Hanoi Khmer Vietminh So Phim, leader of the Eastern Zone, and some others long died, but his underlings are still free today. The Division 09 was commanded by Comrade Kim, aka Chakri. Those who survived the Pol Pot purge and fled to Vietnam include Generals Hun Sen, Meas Sophea, Heng Samrin, Chea Mon, etc.

This KR trial may be ended with some form of conviction of some Khmer Rouge leaders, but it's never seen as a fair trial. It's an incomplete, short-changed justice for the Cambodian victims. As one of the victims and former inmates in a KR correctional center, I lost as many family members as anyone else. I personally see this tribunal just an attempt by those involved in the commission of a crime to wash their bloody hands.

Hassan A. Kasem

Latest Video

Kem Sokha talks politics, power and Hun Sen

Kem Sokha, leader of the Cambodia National Rescue Party, sat down with The Post’s Alex Willemyns and Mech Dara to discuss his supporters’ initial disappointment with this year’s

Phnom Penh eats: Dine amid green gardens at Chol Chet

Located just off National Road 1 about 9km south of central Phnom Penh, Chol Chet — which means 'like' in Khmer — is a great getaway from the bustle of the capital.

NEC officials tally votes during a recount last week in Phnom Penh.

Cambodia’s National Election Committee last week rejected 33 of 61 complaints filed over the conduct of June 4’s commune election, according to a s

People search for their names on the voter lists at a polling station in Kampong Cham’s Veal Vong commune earlier this month.

Four years ago, when the opposition snatched Kampong Cham away from the ruling party in 2013 national elections, it hinted at a deeper shift taking