Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Kickback claims stain the KRT

Kickback claims stain the KRT

Rumors of political interference have dogged the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts

of Cambodia (ECCC) since its inception. Now, recent allegations that Cambodian staffers

must provide a portion of their wages to government officials have highlighted the

difficulties of introducing international legal standards to a country widely considered

to be systemically corrupt.

"The kickbacks have been an open secret for months," said one person close

to the trial, who requested anonymity. "The problem with this type of corruption

is that it is woven into the fabric of society. The employees who are paying the

kickbacks are benefiting. No one is inclined to talk on the record and lose their

job. There is a very real fear of retaliation."

Reports concerning a lack of transparency in the hiring procedures of the ECCC began

surfacing late in 2006, said the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) in a statement

released on February 20. This prompted the UNDP - which has provided $5 million to

the tribunal - to commission an internal audit of the ECCC between January 29 and

February 2. The results have not yet been made public.

On January 31, the Khmer-language paper Voice of Khmer Youth, now aligned with the

Norodom Ranariddh Party, printed a story that claimed Cambodian ECCC officials -

including judges - were paying 30 percent of the salaries to government officials

to secure their positions. On February 14, the New York-based Open Society Justice

Initiative (OSJI) issued a statement calling for a comprehensive investigation into

the allegations.

"The official line is that we are supporting OSJI's determination to ensure

the ECCC is a transparent and independent court," said ECCC press officer Peter


Sean Visoth, the tribunal's administrative director, responded by banning OSJI officials

from his offices, and writing a letter to the NGO in which he called the statement

"offensive and destructive." He announced he no longer wished to cooperate

with OSJI.

"The disconnect between the official line and Visoth's response is understandable,"

said Theary Seng, director of the Center for Social Development. "Because the

ECCC is also a court of public opinion, appearances must be maintained. Part of it

is to obscure, part of it is misguided hopefulness, part of it is to buy time, part

of it is to shape public perception."

One UN official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, expressed "grave concern"

that Helen Jarvis, head of the ECCC press office, "speaks at the behest of the

Cambodian government and not for the tribunal as a whole."

Jarvis told the Post on February 22, "It is impossible to respond to anonymous

blanket slander. I am carrying out the job for which I have been appointed."

The press office has maintained a positive stance on the discussions over the court's

draft internal rules. But people close to the court have said the judges are divided

along Cambodian and international lines. One observer described it as a "clash

of legal cultures."

"Public statements that the negotiations are going well, when they are not,

compromise and even sabotage the negotiations," said Chantal Beaubien, legal

adviser for ADHOC's KRT program. "Such statements imply that the international

judges will not pull out of the negotiations and abandon the ECCC if international

standards are not being met. This weakens the position of the international judges."

Unlike some other hybrid tribunals, the ECCC does not have a separate press office

for the administrative and judicial components of the trial. There are no specific

plans to create one, Foster said. International judges have chosen to express their

thoughts on the progress of discussions over the court's internal rules to the press


"It's part of our job to explain what's going on in this court," Marcel

Lemonde, international investigating judge, told the Post on February 21. "People

have been awaiting this trial for 30 years, they wonder why the judicial process

appears to be delayed and I believe it would be absurd for judicial officers to refuse

to give information at all."

According to Beaubien, international judges bypassing the press office and making

statements about their positions directly to the local and international media, means

there is a lack of coherence between the position of the judges and that of the press


"The channeling of information and statements through the press office is no

longer functioning correctly," she said.

ECCC officials are using the media to raise their concerns and communicate their

stance on key issues both to the general public and to their colleagues, Seng said.

"There are cultural, linguistic, and political divides between the Khmer and

international ECCC officials," she said. "They are using the media as a

medium of communicating to their other colleagues. For example, Khmer officials do

not believe the UN will pull out of the ECCC."

The international judges have maintained that they cannot participate in a trial

that would not be a fair trial, before an independent and impartial court, Lemonde


"This is a non-negotiable issue and, if these conditions were not met, the judges

would just have no choice but require the UN to withdraw," he said. "This

is not a threat or, worse, bluff - it's just the reality."

It may be tempting to employ threats of a pullout in the heat of the talks, but it

would be premature to walk at this stage, said David Scheffer, the United States

Ambassador at Large for War Crimes Issues from 1997 to 2001.

"An enormous amount is now invested in this process of accountability for the

atrocities of the Pol Pot regime," he said by email. "Everyone must keep

the victims and the larger purpose in focus - justice for the atrocity crimes that

devastated Cambodia."

Direct communication and compromise will prove key to resolving the current division

over the IRs, Scheffer said.

"Achieving agreement here is not 'mission impossible,' and everyone surely understands

how historically significant their decisions will be in the weeks ahead," he

said. "Failure now will never be forgiven by the families of the victims or

by historians, regardless of what excuses are given."

As the judges seek consensus over the internal rules, and the administrative office

deals with allegations of corruption, accurate information, not excuses, is what

the public requires, Beaubien said.

"If press office statements are whitewashing the discussions by failing to disclose

that they are going badly, the public is no longer properly informed," she said.

Regardless of the problems the trial may encounter - be it audits, allegations, or

arguments over the IRs - it is imperative that they are honestly and openly addressed

that the trial might go on, Scheffer said.

"If the ECCC fails to become operational and hold trials then I believe that

Cambodian society will be taking an enormous risk," he said. "Without the

accountability and historical record that ECCC trials can establish, however partial,

for the atrocity crimes of the Pol Pot regime, Cambodian society will never fully

recognize the significance of what occurred and of the nation's responsibility to

prevent such crimes in the future."



Please, login or register to post a comment

Latest Video

Turkish Embassy calls for closure of Zaman schools

With an attempted coup against the government of President Recep Erdogan quashed only days ago and more than 7,000 alleged conspirators now under arrest, the Turkish ambassador to Cambodia yesterday pressed the govern

CNRP lawmakers beaten

Two opposition lawmakers, Nhay Chamroeun and Kong Sakphea were beaten unconscious during protests in Phnom Penh, as over a thousand protesters descended upon the National Assembly.

Student authors discuss "The Cambodian Economy"

Student authors discuss "The Cambodian Economy"

Students at Phnom Penh's Liger Learning Center have written and published a new book, "The Cambodian Economy".