Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - King: PMs jumped the gun on Sary amnesty

King: PMs jumped the gun on Sary amnesty

K ING Norodom Sihanouk has distanced himself from the amnesty given to Khmer Rouge

breakaway leader Ieng Sary, reaffirming that the pardon is invalid without the approval

of two thirds of the National Assembly.

In a Sept 17 Royal statement, the King said he signed the amnesty because the Prime

Ministers were in a hurry to have the pardon ratified and were against a National

Assembly debate on the issue.

"I repeat that the Kret amnestying Mr. Ieng Sary, according to my verbal request,

should be made public and enforceable only after obtaining the official approval

in writing of two thirds of the members of the National Assembly," the statement

read, according to an unofficial translation.

"The two Samdech Prime Ministers of the Royal Cambodian Government... pronounced

themselves in front of me [to be] against debate within the National Assembly on

the subject of this amnesty. I replied to them that simple individual motions addressed

by our deputies to King Norodom Sihanouk would suffice.

"It is, therefore, not my fault if things did not happen as I had announced

to the Cambodian Nation and the international community."

Within hours of the King signing the amnesty decree, copies of the document were

freely circulated by both Prime Ministers, without the signatures of National Assembly

members having been sent to the King.

However, observers suggest any vote by the National Assembly would have reflected

the will of the Prime Ministers in any event.

According to one diplomatic source a CPP party meeting held September 14 at the Apsara

television station agreed - "eventually" - that an amnesty for Sary was


Funcinpec President and First Prime Minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh told the Post

that 48 of the party's 58 MPs had agreed to amnestying Sary before the official pardon

was presented to the palace for the King's signature.

At press time, however, the King had told diplomats he had been formerly informed

of less than 10 signatures of MPs.

Meanwhile - according to one ambassador - the international community in Phnom Penh

has reacted to the pardon with "stunned silence."

The source said there was "some disappointment" among diplomats in Cambodia

that the decision to grant Ieng Sary amnesty was not the subject of wider debate.

He said, however, the international community would accept the decision as there

continued to be widespread support for the peace process.

But, he added, there was significant concern that the KR - if permitted to rejoin

politics - posed a potential threat to regional peace in the future and could create

divisions within Asean.

"The Asean nations have a lot of experience in working through the fall-out

of communist insurgencies and the experience of post-communism throughout the world

indicates a [trend of] abandoning communist ideology," the diplomat said.

"However, the xenophobia of the Khmer Rouge is unique and anti-Vietnamese feeling

is very strong in Cambodia - the KR's anti-Vietnamese position could be attractive

to the electorate.

"But just what is the consequence of the KR in politics - politically, do they

stand for anything more than kicking the Vietnamese?"

Despite such private concerns, no foreign country has officially criticized the granting

of amnesty. Even the United States - which has funded the Cambodian Genocide Program

investigating crimes against humanity under the 1975-79 Pol Pot regime - has resisted

making any statement except to say the issue is a "Cambodian affair'.

But, increasingly, it appears the Royal pardon granted to Ieng Sary does not grant

him total immunity from prosecution.

The amnesty decree pardons Sary from a death sentence handed down to him after an

in absentia trial in 1979 after the Vietnamese invasion of Cambodia, and also gave

him an amnesty from legislation passed in 1994 outlawing the KR. It says nothing

about future trials about crimes against humanity during the Pol Pot regime.

In a letter to the human rights group Amnesty International - in response to

its opposition to any pardon for Sary - the King unequivocally supported any future

trial of Khmer Rouge leaders.

"If, one day, an international tribunal convenes... to judge Mr. Pol Pot, Ieng

Sary, Ta Mok, Khieu Samphan, Nuon Chea, Son Sen, and other notorious Khmer Rouges,

I would support, as a Cambodian citizen, this trial and its judgment," the letter


In a September 17 interview with the Post Ranariddh said: " I think the amnesty

will not prevent Mr Ieng Sary or Pol Pot - Pol Pot in particular - [from] being prosecuted."

The Prince said: "I think the amnesty will not protect Mr. Ieng Sary from prosecution

by the international tribunal...," but he noted that Sary had publicly claimed

to have evidence proving his innocence of crimes during the Pol Pot regime.

Second Prime Minister Hun Sen, in a speech delivered at the Royal School of Administration

Sept 16, also did not rule out a future trial of Sary.

"Amnesty for Ieng Sary has not hampered investigations into the crime of genocide

and the process of [setting up an] international tribunal at all... we have not kicked

it aside," Hun Sen said.

Additionally, a number of MPs from across the political spectrum said they supported

the amnesty but would also support Sary's prosecution if evidence implicated him

in crimes against the Cambodian people.

Parliamentarian Im Sethy (CPP) said: "If they find evidence linking Ieng Sary

to the crimes, he must be punished. All we've done is annul the verdict made against

him in 1979. When the tribunal is created, no-one escapes - we can't let two million

lives be meaningless..."

Funcinpec MP Nuon Ninara expressed similar sentiments. "I support a tribunal

if Ieng Sary is implicated in crimes [during the KR regime]. This amnesty does not

obstruct investigations."



Please, login or register to post a comment

Latest Video

Turkish Embassy calls for closure of Zaman schools

With an attempted coup against the government of President Recep Erdogan quashed only days ago and more than 7,000 alleged conspirators now under arrest, the Turkish ambassador to Cambodia yesterday pressed the govern

CNRP lawmakers beaten

Two opposition lawmakers, Nhay Chamroeun and Kong Sakphea were beaten unconscious during protests in Phnom Penh, as over a thousand protesters descended upon the National Assembly.

Student authors discuss "The Cambodian Economy"

Student authors discuss "The Cambodian Economy"

Students at Phnom Penh's Liger Learning Center have written and published a new book, "The Cambodian Economy".