Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Straining at gnats

Straining at gnats

The Editor,

The indignation of William Shawcross and Steve Heder (Post, Oct 18-30) in both

cases is characterized by the straining at gnats with which liberal defenders of

the status quo typically try to distract attention from their breakfast of a camel

and a water buffalo or two.

Shawcross reads non-existent "sneers at King Sihanouk" into the letter

of Craig Etcheson of the Cambodia Genocide Program (Post, Sept 20-Oct 3) but that

fiction pales before his description of Julio Jeldres as someone who "has contributed

much to the restoration of civil society in Cambodia."

If true, that would only be compensation of a sort for Jeldres' past role as a supporter

of the Khmer Rouge - before they lost power. (Jeldres was made an "honorary"

- what a word - member of the KR's FUNK in 1971, and was still boasting of this fact

and defending the KR in letters in 1978). Unfortunately, his consistent role in Cambodian

politics since then has been to attack anyone and everyone who appears as a serious

opponent of the KR - often doing so in the guise of "attacking" the KR.

He does this with more fervor than intelligence, thus producing the absurd inconsistencies

of the sort referred to in Etcheson's letter.

Etcheson's mentioning of these inconsistencies is, according to Shawcross, "deeply

unprofessional conduct" and will enhance the "doubts" about the CGP

"which have been voiced". Voiced by whom, Mr Shawcross? Can't you spare

even a footnote? Was it perhaps Julio Jeldres? Or is this a reference to that other

scholar, Stephen Morris, whose previous claim to professional fame was the discovery

in Kremlin archives of "evidence" of US prisoners of war still held in

Vietnam?

For his part, Heder uses a column and a half of your paper attacking the CGP for

not yet having delivered results it promised to produce in 1997. Those of us with

a satirical and "unprofessional" streak would suggest that someone give

Heder a current calender. No doubt Shawcross would praise Heder as "contributing

much to the restoration of chronology".

- Allen Myers, Sydney, Australia.

0

Comments

Please, login or register to post a comment

Latest Video

Phnom Penh eats: Homegrown veggies at Bayon Beoung Snor

​Nestled along National Road 1, Bayon Beoung Snor is a farm-cum-restaurant. The team grows their own vegetables, which they then use to whip up traditional Khmer food.

Bill Clough reflects on The Phnom Penh Post's 25 year history

The Post's publisher Bill Clough, under whose leadership the publication went from a fortnightly to a daily one, discusses his investment in Cambodia, his vision for the paper in an increasingly digital age,

NEC officials tally votes during a recount last week in Phnom Penh.

Cambodia’s National Election Committee last week rejected 33 of 61 complaints filed over the conduct of June 4’s commune election, according to a s

People search for their names on the voter lists at a polling station in Kampong Cham’s Veal Vong commune earlier this month.

Four years ago, when the opposition snatched Kampong Cham away from the ruling party in 2013 national elections, it hinted at a deeper shift taking