Search

Search form

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Trafficked girls deserve protection by law

Trafficked girls deserve protection by law

Trafficked girls deserve protection by law

On June 20 the police arrested 14 Vietnamese girls who had been in custody at AFESIP,

an NGO which protects victims of sexual trafficking.

Most of the girls had been rescued in the first place in a police raid on three Svay

Park brothels. The arrested girls were then charged with illegal immigration. On

July 5, foreigner police in a raid on a guesthouse in Daun Penh district in Phnom

Penh took 21 girls 13 of whom were later charged with illegal immigration.

The charges of illegal immigration for the first batch of foreign girls have sparked

off immediate open criticisms while those for the second batch have aroused no less

concern, when there are claims that these girls are trafficking victims. The girls

have been arrested and charged under the Immigration Law enacted in 1994. However,

according to critics, their case, indeed their plight, could and should be considered

under the Human Trafficking Law enacted in 1996. Under this law the girls are trafficking

victims if they can prove their case, and cannot be charged with illegal entry into

Cambodia.

The case of the foreign girls is actually one of conflict of law: which of the two

laws should have jurisdiction over them. The court should not hear their case until

this conflict has been resolved. Pending such a resolution the girls should not be

treated as suspects and detained under the Immigration Law.

The Cambodian legal system must pronounce whether the supremacy of international

law prevails over the supremacy of constitutional law, and subsequently whether the

Human Trafficking Law prevails over the Immigration Law or vice-versa. Cambodia's

status and international obligations under the Paris Peace Accords of 1991 should

determine a decision either way.

Cambodia has an international obligation "to ensure respect for and observance

of human rights and fundamental freedoms" and "to adhere to relevant international

human rights instruments." Such an obligation has been incorporated in its Constitution

of 1993 (Art. 31). It has now adhered to a number of such instruments but not yet

to the Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Persons and of the Exploitation

of the Prostitution of Others (1949).

Considering that Cambodia has an international obligation to respect human rights

and that this Convention itself is a human rights instrument listed in UNESCO's brochure

Human Rights: Major International Instruments, the adherence to this Convention and

to the supremacy of international law would form a solid argument for the jurisdiction

of the Human Trafficking Law over the case of these girls. It would be incumbent

upon them to prove that they are trafficking victims.

The lacunae created by the lack of Cambodia's adherence to that Convention should

not be a handicap though for the challenge against the jurisdiction of the Immigration

Law. The following can be cited in support:

  1. the general obligation of Cambodia vis-à-vis respect for human rights

    under the Paris Peace Accords of 1991;

     

  2. Cambodia's obligation to adhere to all relevant instruments under the same Accords;

     

  3. Cambodia's recognition of and respect for all human rights under its own Constitution;

     

  4. the prohibition of sexual exploitation of children under the Convention of the

    Right of the Child (art.39) which Cambodia has adhered to has jurisdiction over the

    plight of the minors among the girls arrested;

     

  5. the Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Persons and of the Exploitation

    of the Prostitution of Others (1949) being also a relevant international human rights

    instrument, human trafficking is a violation of human rights;

     

  6. the constitutional prohibition of human trafficking and sexual exploitation of

    women and children (art. 46 and 48);

     

  7. the principle of the supremacy of international law under the Paris Peace Accords

    with regards to human rights and of the Convention of the Right of the Child;

     

  8. the constitutional obligation of the courts of law to "protect the rights

    and freedoms of the citizens" (Art.128-New);

     

  9. the humanitarian principle prohibiting heavier sentences when there are two or

    more laws with different sentences for the same crime;

     

  10. the continued policy of the Royal Government of Cambodia to combat human trafficking

    and sexual exploitation of women and children;

     

  11. society's abhorrence of any punishment of victims of wrong rather than the wrong-doers.

The case for the supremacy of international law and for the prevalence and precedence

of the Human Trafficking Law over the Immigration Law in the case of these foreign

girls seems overwhelming. So does the case for the foreign girls to be treated first

as victims, not as law-breakers.

The charges under the Immigration Law against these proven traffic victims should

be dropped. These girls should be released immediately and given humanitarian assistance

and other support, and arrangements should be made to repatriate them to their homeland

if they are indeed aliens.

This is not the end of the story though. The police must endeavor to arrest the human

traffickers and owners of the brothels - and males having sex with minors - and bring

them to justice. And in future these wrongdoers should be their primary targets.

RECOMMENDED STORIES

  • Breaking: PM says prominent human rights NGO ‘must close’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has instructed the Interior Ministry to investigate the Cambodian Center for Human Rights (CCHR) and potentially close it “because they follow foreigners”, appearing to link the rights group to the opposition Cambodia National Rescue Party's purported “revolution”. The CNRP - the

  • Rainsy and Sokha ‘would already be dead’: PM

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Sunday appeared to suggest he would have assassinated opposition leaders Sam Rainsy and Kem Sokha had he known they were promising to “organise a new government” in the aftermath of the disputed 2013 national elections. In a clip from his speech

  • Massive ceremony at Angkor Wat will show ‘Cambodia not in anarchy’: PM

    Government officials, thousands of monks and Prime Minister Hun Sen himself will hold a massive prayer ceremony at Angkor Wat in early December to highlight the Kingdom’s continuing “peace, independence and political stability”, a spectacle observers said was designed to disguise the deterioration of

  • PM tells workers CNRP is to blame for any sanctions

    In a speech to workers yesterday, Prime Minister Hun Sen pinned the blame for any damage inflicted on Cambodia’s garment industry by potential economic sanctions squarely on the opposition party. “You must remember clearly that if the purchase orders are reduced, it is all