Search

Search form

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Views of a slaughter

Views of a slaughter

Views of a slaughter

The Editor,

In the Phnom Penh Post of April 18 - May 1 we were fortunate enough to see an

interesting combination of views concerning the aftermath of the slaughter of men,

women and children on March 30th.

Michael Clifford wants the photographic evidence to be suppressed, while Beat Richner

thinks it was "wise" to refuse assistance to seriously injured and dying

people, some of whom waited up to an hour to die on the pavement.

If photographs of the victims of violence were never published, where would we find

irrefutable evidence of the Nazi policy of exterminating Jews, Romanies, the mentally

and physically disabled? Would a tribunal have been established to investigate war

crimes in the former Yugoslavia? How would the resistance to the American presence

in Vietnam have been fuelled? How would we know that in the USA some police officers

batter black people? How would justice have been done (finally) for the victim? What

of the recent filming of violence and extortion by the police in Brazil? Should the

bas relief of slavery and torture to be found on many Khmer ruins be screened off

to show respect for the victims and their successors? How many more would have died

of starvation in numerous famines or natural disasters across the world?

It is only in societies where such material cannot be published that violence and

abuse is perpetrated with impunity. These pictures are not only evidence of an important

event, they form part of the archive material needed to interpret history.

What a blessing for the perpetrators that there were no reporters, cameras or tape

recorders to document the gory details of the Pol Pot regime, or the paranoid madness

of Mao or Stalin, Idi Amin's tyranny or Cromwell's wholesale butchery of the Irish.

Apparently not only should we not be allowed to see the evidence of such events,

we are also expected to sympathise with the boss of a hospital situated a few yards

from the scene, who says it was wise to refuse emergency first aid to the victims.

The Kantha Bopha hospital gets its money from people who freely give, as well as

from the long-suffering tax payers of Switzerland, a country renowned for its claim

to neutrality and humanitarian stance. This money comes in the name of humanitarian

aid to Cambodia. I wonder if the donors would agree that the denial of emergency

first aid help to the dying was either "wise" or humanitarian?

No hospital, not even the Kantha Bopha, can operate without taking account of its

context. The Kantha Bopha, despite what Beat Richner would have us believe, is not

unique and is not special, though it is expensive and rather unrealistic in its operation

and structure.

As with any hospital, the Kantha Bopha should have an emergency plan clearly stating

the extent to which it could contribute in an emergency such as this, along with

a management structure which allows people to put things in motion even when the

boss is playing his cello.

- David Hayter, Phnom Penh.

RECOMMENDED STORIES

  • Breaking: PM says prominent human rights NGO ‘must close’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has instructed the Interior Ministry to investigate the Cambodian Center for Human Rights (CCHR) and potentially close it “because they follow foreigners”, appearing to link the rights group to the opposition Cambodia National Rescue Party's purported “revolution”. The CNRP - the

  • PM warns party of complacency in leaked audio

    Two leaked audio tapes, purportedly of Prime Minister Hun Sen speaking candidly to senior officials, appear to hint at insecurities within the ruling party over the controversial dissolution of the country’s main opposition, with the premier warning that the party’s “struggle” didn’t

  • Government approves plan to relocate Phnom Penh’s airport

    The government has signed off on a proposal to build a new airport to serve Phnom Penh and has earmarked land in Kandal province for the $1.5 billion project. A new international airport to replace the existing Phnom Penh International Airport will be constructed on partially

  • Music festival promises big stage, has even bigger hopes

    With a line-up of local and international artists, and a massive outdoor venue booked on Koh Pich, or Diamond Island, Saturday’s Diamond Moon Festival is aiming to showcase contemporary musical and artistic talents at a scale rarely seen in the Kingdom. [img] But the