Search form

Login - Register | FOLLOW US ON

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Nuon Chea queries Becker

Journalist and author Elizabeth Becker gives her testimony before the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia in Case 002/02 yesterday in Phnom Penh
Journalist and author Elizabeth Becker gives her testimony before the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia in Case 002/02 yesterday in Phnom Penh. ECCC

Nuon Chea queries Becker

“Brother Number Two” Nuon Chea momentarily broke his silence during the Khmer Rouge tribunal yesterday to pose two questions to veteran journalist and witness Elizabeth Becker regarding the United States’ criminal role in the historic destruction of Cambodia.

Choosing to leave his holding cell for a rare appearance, the 88-year-old specifically questioned Becker about Operation Freedom Deal, an aerial campaign waged in Cambodia from 1970-73.

“[The United States] engaged in bombardment for 200 days and nights . . . and as a result, many innocent Cambodian people died, and [there was] destruction of the houses, rice fields and pagodas,” Chea said. “I’d like for you, the expert, to give us the reason for that bombardment.”

Becker answered, saying that the bombings were the US’ show of support to Lon Nol’s Khmer Republic regime against the Khmer Rouge and the North Vietnamese.

“The bombardment . . . was a result of the fear at that stage that the Khmer Republic would lose and the belief by . . . the administration of Richard Nixon that by bombing, the Khmer Rouge would come to the negotiation table – and that failed.”

The bombings subsequently ended in August 15, 1973, after the US Supreme Court upheld a law passed by Congress to end the operation because “they didn’t want any more reports of innocent Cambodians being killed”, Becker added.

Chea then went on to ask his second question.

“Is it your opinion that the US government was solely responsible for the tragedy that it inflicted upon the Cambodian people?”

To which Becker, who authored the 1986 book When the War Was Over, replied that though the issue remains a bone of contention, to her, the US is fully responsible for the immensely destructive attacks on the Kingdom.

Following the questions, Chea’s lawyer Victor Koppe continued cross-examining Becker about a “secret” civil war within Cambodia after 1975 that was behind the mass carnage in Democratic Kampuchea – a narrative that the defence has sought to put forward to support the accused’s claims.

Koppe read short passages from an interview by Thet Sambath, a journalist who co-wrote the book Behind the Killing Fields, meant to reinforce his questioning. He was prevented from pursuing the line, however, by multiple objections from the prosecution and civil parties accusing him of only citing excerpts allegedly proving the presence of a civil war.

The chamber sustained the objections, with judge Claudia Fenz saying in one instance that it “share[d] the prosecution’s concern about what appears to be a pattern of selectively misrepresenting documents and asking witnesses and experts to comment on it”.

While it didn’t rise to the level of incidents seen in the previous Case 002/01, in which defence teams saw their microphones cut off midsentence, Panhavuth Long, a program officer with the Cambodian Justice Initiative, reminded the court that the defence has a right to pursue certain lines of questioning.

“The defence has to have enough opportunity to present evidence that’s relevant to the case to prove guilt and element of crimes,” Long said. “Judges need to reassess between ensuring an expedient trial and achieving a criminal judgement.”

Though some of her testimony rehashed earlier responses, Becker also gave evidence on co-defendant Khieu Samphan’s role as the “face of the regime”, in which he wielded significant power.

“He was the liaison for Sihanouk and what became the leadership of the Democratic Kampuchea,” she said. “He took foreign trips as head of state and met delegations. He was one of the few Democratic Kampuchea leaders who were able to travel outside of the country.”

Becker’s testimony concluded yesterday, and the tribunal will resume proceedings today.



Please, login or register to post a comment
Bob's picture

I was very young back then but I have read and do my research and listen to WaterGate Nexion scandal.

I don't agree at all with Mrs.Becker saying that American bombings were the US’ show of support to Lon Nol regime but more likely to show off American power by illegally bombing a neutral country. Pol Pot's armies were back than a very small only a few thousands and unorganized interest groups, mentor by a well organized Vietcong. American actually was bombing Vietcong in Cambodia territory....
Sorry Mrs. Becker, you may claim that you are expert but many of your answers are not balanced or wage the true reality... want the true? make public the Water Gate tapes and those thousands of secret docs...

As Mr. David Chandler mentioned in his book History of Cambodia, the Khmer Rouge forces were built from the back clashes of the American bombings in Cambodia... Not doubt about it and I have talked to Ex-Khmer rouge solders and they affirmed strongly, the most reason that they were joining KR then because bombing was so inhuman killing innocent Khmer and lost many of their family members....

Brief, Khmer Rouge was not alone fighting Lon Nol and could never win Lon Nol armies, a well armed with the latest ammunition from America but Vietcong did most of the work for the KR... At the end, all interests go Vietnam!!!!
You judge who should you blame?

louisgodena's picture

Very good points, Bob. An argument can even be made that the casualties arising from the US bombing equal in number those attributed to the Khmer Rouge.

Bob's picture

Remark one other thing, if Mrs. Becker knows KR so well back then when interviewing Pol Pot, why does she kept her silence after returning from Phnom Penh? She knew back then, it wasn't norml to have seen a Phnom Penh in so a desert city.... Phnom Penh was then was a renown city in South East Asia known as a pearl of the South east Asian city. But in 1978 must a hell city on earth... Had she alerted her authorities?If she made noise back then, it would possibly save thousands of Cambodian's life. !!!!Contrarily, Mrs. Becker kept her silence!!! What a selfish journalist is she?

fabtouch's picture

Unfortunately that was the guy everybody was waiting to return. Norodom Sihanouk was put on house a rest by Pol Pot in Phnom Penh. People like Sinsisamuth he could easily left the country. Exactly you too young for that you will not understand the scope of the true tragedy 2 plus million of khmer senseless killed by Pol pot. Back to Norodom Sihanouk he broadcast from Beijing propaganda that is why people go to forests to fight the US. Sihanouk had no clue so do khmer people communist can not be coexist. There no King in communism.