Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Rivals in review: raw intensity in Belgium’s "Broken Circle Breakdown"

Rivals in review: raw intensity in Belgium’s "Broken Circle Breakdown"

Johan Heldenbergh and Veerle Baetens star.
Johan Heldenbergh and Veerle Baetens star. PHOTO SUPPLIED

Rivals in review: raw intensity in Belgium’s "Broken Circle Breakdown"

Of the films up for an Oscar alongside Rithy Panh’s The Missing Picture, Belgium’s offering is one of the most impressive, finds Emily Wight.

Most people wouldn’t associate bluegrass music with Belgium. A sub-genre of American country music, its influences are in Celtic folk songs, as well as some blues and jazz. Bill Monroe, its most famous figurehead, is from Kentucky.

Why, then, are bluegrass bands now springing up around Belgium? One of the men who can be credited for this is Johan Heldenbergh. A long-time fan of bluegrass, he co-wrote the stage play Broken Circle Breakdown and stars in Felix van Groeningen’s film adaptation of the same name, which has been well-received in Belgium, and nominated for an Oscar in the Best Foreign Language Film category.

"Broken Circle Breakdown" is among five films nominated in the foreign language category.  BLOOMBERG
Broken Circle Breakdown is among five films nominated in the foreign language category. BLOOMBERG

In Broken Circle Breakdown, Heldenbergh plays Didier, one half of a bluegrass-singing couple whose relationship – and its demise –is played out alongside footage of rehearsals, performances, and an original score by improvisational musician Bjorn Eriksson. It is the music that unites him with the tattoo artist Elise – played with a delicate conviction by Veerle Baetens – as on their first meeting in her tattoo parlour, they argue over whether Monroe or Elvis Presley is the greater musician. Elise goes to watch Didier perform with his band, and gets sucked into both his music and his life.

The film is first and foremost a very human love story, but it is also a love letter to America. In fact, if it wasn’t for the Flemish language, you might be forgiven for assuming it was an American production. In what is almost some kind of parody of the American dream, Elise strips down to a stars and stripes bikini and writhes around on the bonnet of Didier’s car; the pair rides horses naked but for cowboy hats and boots. In one episode, the camera moves past a family scene to focus on a television screen broadcasting footage of the 9/11 attacks, followed by a speech by George Bush which he ends with the ubiquitous line “God Bless America”. Ostensibly, this feels odd, but it is part and parcel of the American imagery that builds up to Elise having to remind Didier, after his angry reaction to another speech by Bush, that they don’t live in the United States. It’s almost as if she’s reminding the audience, perhaps deterred by the all-American sounding bluegrass soundtrack, too. While at first the Americana theme feels slightly bizarre, it seems like an attempt by Heldenbergh and van Groeningen to highlight the universality of the human experience, rather than to express an Americaphile sycophancy.

The non-linear structure of Broken Circle Breakdown is critical to its intrigue. We begin the film in 2006, when Didier and Elise are visiting their sick daughter, Maybelle, in hospital. The film follows the effects of her suffering on the pair as they attempt to deal with their grief in separate ways. Juxtaposed against this unravelling heartbreak are scenes that celebrate their love: the first time Elise watches Didier perform, urgent sex, a marriage proposal, preparation for the birth of their child. This technique is not new: Broken Circle Breakdown is in many ways similar to Derek Cianfrance’s Blue Valentine. It even contains echoes of Michael Gondry’s Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, and François Ozon’s 5x2, which tells the story of a divorce backwards. However the continuous bluegrass soundtrack provides a constant thread that ties the otherwise disjointed scenes together, and the film’s theme song Will The Circle Be Unbroken? is a nod to the chaotic structure as well as to Didier and Elise’s relationship. The story is also played out on Elise’s body, which is covered in tattoos that refer to important events – and men – in her life.

Bluegrass music is at the heart of Oscar-nominated "Broken Circle Breakdown".  PHOTO SUPPLIED
Bluegrass music is at the heart of Oscar-nominated Broken Circle Breakdown. PHOTO SUPPLIED

Broken Circle Breakdown is not a film that will cheer you up. Its light-hearted shots of a couple falling in love only make the rest of the plot more heartbreaking and the tragic ending in particular almost unbearable to watch. Some critics have labelled it melodramatic, but its jolly bluegrass soundtrack and flashing footage of happier times provides a blunt contrast that reminds the viewer of the arbitrary and unfair nature of life.

Adding to the raw intensity of the film is the fantastic acting and extraordinary chemistry of Heldenbergh and Baetens. Heldenbergh’s big, bearded Didier towers physically over the bird-like fragility of Baetens, but it is her powerful presence that fills the screen, in her love, grief, anger, and onstage performances. Her delicate, all-American blondeness, and Baetens’ ability to deconstruct this in one simple line or gesture, is reminiscent of Reese Witherspoon in Walk the Line, Robin Wright Penn in Forrest Gump, even January Jones as Betty Draper in Mad Men. In Belgium, Baetens is well-known for her lead role in the popular TV series Sara, but in Broken Circle Breakdown she will no doubt catch the eyes of international filmmakers. If this film deserves credit for one thing, it is for providing her with a breakthrough role.

MOST VIEWED

  • Chinese nationals on the decline in Sihanoukville?

    It is no secret that real estate prices in Sihanoukville have been on the rise over the last few years due to the influx of Chinese nationals. Their arrival has brought investment in the real estate, construction, hotel and casino sectors, as well as small

  • PP massage parlours raided, 29 suspects held for prostitution

    The Phnom Penh municipal Military Police on Sunday raided four massage parlours in Por Sen Chey district and detained 29 suspects for questioning over their alleged involvement in prostitution. Deputy municipal Military Police commander Pu Davy on Monday said the four massage parlours were located near

  • PM: All 10 Asean countries to receive Rainsy arrest warrants

    Prime Minister Hun Sen said on Thursday that all 10 Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) member states will receive warrants for the arrest of Sam Rainsy. The warrants have already been sent to Laos and Thailand. He was speaking at a joint press conference at

  • Overtourism still threatens Angkor Wat

    Ticket sales to the Angkor temples are down. An Angkor Enterprise report has revealed that ticket sales to the Angkor Archaeological Park dropped by more than 11 per cent from the same period last year. Prime Minister Hun Sen isn’t concerned. He told journalists that