Global talks tasked with neutralising the threat of global warming got under way in Madrid on Monday, but their narrow focus on rules and procedures remains out of sync with the world’s climate-addled future.
Mindful of this gap, UN chief Antonio Guterres warned on Sunday that a “point-of-no-return” in the climate crisis is “in sight and hurtling towards us”.
Indeed, three decades after Nasa scientist James Hansen made headlines by telling the US Congress global warming had begun, evidence of its dire impacts is so overwhelming that “climate denier” is synonymous with insisting the Earth is flat.
Guterres lambasted the world’s major economies, describing their efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions overheating the planet as “utterly nadequate”.
He didn’t name names, but he didn’t have to.
“Some countries like China and Japan are signalling their unwillingness to increase ambition,” said Laurence Tubiana, CEO of the European Climate Foundation and, as a former negotiator for France, a main architect of the Paris Agreement.
Nor have India, Russia or Brazil expressed any enthusiasm for ratcheting up carbon-cutting pledges submitted under the 2015 treaty.
US President Donald Trump has taken things a step further by yanking the US out of the Paris deal entirely.
But even if all the world’s nations honoured their pledges, the planet would still heat up at least three 3C above preindustrial levels, a sure-fire recipe for calamity, scientists say.
Nations have agreed to cap warming – already up by 1C – at “well below” 2C.
Beyond the 2C threshold, “we are at risk of unleashing self-reinforced warming”, said Johan Rockstrom, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research.
“This is what Earth system scientists fear most.”
The talks in Madrid – the 25th “COP”, or conference of the parties, in as many years – will focus on finalising rules for global carbon markets, and setting up a fund to help countries already reeling from climate-enhanced heatwaves, droughts, floods and storms made worse by rising seas.
Poor and vulnerable nations are set to receive $100 billion annually from next year to prepare for future impacts, but no concrete provisions exist yet for the “loss and damage” already incurred.
Frontline negotiators here describe COP25 as “technical talks” setting the stage for next year’s meeting in Glasgow, where countries must confront the yawning gap between the Paris targets and current emissions.
But events outside the conference hall in Madrid may change the agenda.
“A key question will be to what extent the growing social movements throughout the world will be factored into decisions of the COP 25,” Tubiana said.
Alden Meyer, director of strategy and policy at the Union of Concerned Scientists, agreed.
“How to address the inadequate political response is the elephant in the room,” he said.
Under the European Commission’s new president Ursula von der Leyen, Europe has emerged as a key player in pushing for a more rapid drawdown of carbon pollution.
Nearly a decade ago, the EU engineered 2015 as the deadline for a climate deal. But the bloc ceded much of its leadership after that role to China and the US under Barack Obama.
Today it may once again finds itself thrust onto the centre stage.
“The EU Commission is the new political element,” Tubiana said. “The EU will signal its intention to increase ambition by 2030 and achieve net-zero by 2050.”
For the world’s most vulnerable nations, that kind of action can’t come soon enough.
“Anything short of a vastly greater commitment to emission reduction through new national plans . . . will signal a willingness to accept catastrophe,” said Lois Young, an ambassador from Belize and chair of the Association of Small Island States.