Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Scholar details flaws of Duch indictment

Scholar details flaws of Duch indictment

appealed the Closing Order , which was completed in early August. " />

Scholar details flaws of Duch indictment

A scholar from Duke University of Law claims the Co-Investigating Judges' Closing Order in the case of "Comrade Duch" is potentially misguided in several areas. The Co-Prosecutors recently appealed the Closing Order , which was completed in early August.

In an analysis of the Closing Order, Margarita Clarens claims the document "raises at least three legal concerns."

First, the judges' decision not to charge Duch under Cambodian law "was likely both premature and legally incorrect," she writes. While the Co-Investigating Judges argue that the domestic crimes of homicide and torture "must be accorded the highest available legal classification," international charges are not necessarily just a more serious version of domestic charges, Clarens writes. Indeed, "an accused could be found guilty of torture or murder under international law and not under Cambodian or, conversely, guilty under Cambodian law and not under international law," according to Clarens.

Second, Clarens claims that the judges' failure to address the "joint criminal enterprise" basis of liability (which was outlined in the Co-Prosecutors' final submission) may render the Closing Order defective. JCE exists when two or more people participate in a common criminal endeavor, sharing a common criminal purpose. She writes that the "Co-Investigating Judges have left the applicability of JCE undecided, rendering the Closing Order incomplete and, therefore, arguably defective."

Third, the crimes against humanity charge set forward by the judges does not fully acknowledge the level of Duch's complicity in DK atrocities. Crimes against humanity is partly defined by a "widespread or systematic attack" on a population. In the Closing Order, the Co-Investigating Judges limited the scope of the charge against Duch to crimes committed at S21. However, Clarens writes, such an "attack" can be defined far more broadly and Duch's actions can be considered as part of a much larger attack on the Cambodian population. "If the full scope of the crimes occurring during the period of the DK is not included as part of the 'attack,' then it will be less clear to victims how Duch is connected to the overall DK system and why it is appropriate to try only him -- and not the heads of other DK prison centers -- for violations of international humanitarian law in a special tribunal.

MOST VIEWED

  • PM to vet NY holiday dates

    The Ministry of Economy and Finance submitted a letter to Prime Minister Hun Sen asking him to formally set a five-day national holiday from August 17-21 to make up for the Khmer New Year holiday in April that was postponed. Finance minister Aun Pornmoniroth sent

  • Cambodia rejects UN rights claim

    Cambodia's Permanent Mission to the UN Office in Geneva on Friday hit back at David Kaye, the UN special rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression after he raised concerns over the repression of free speech and

  • Snaring may spawn diseases

    The World Wildlife Fund (WWF) has warned that snaring of animals has become a crisis that poses a serious risk to wildlife in Southeast Asia and could spawn the transmission of zoonotic diseases to humans. Its July 9 report entitled Silence of the Snares: Southeast Asia’

  • Ex-party leader, gov’t critic named as secretary of state

    A former political party leader known for being critical of the government has been appointed secretary of state at the Ministry of Rural Development, a royal decree dated July 9 said. Sourn Serey Ratha, the former president of the Khmer Power Party (KPP), told The Post

  • Residence cards set for over 80,000 immigrants

    The Ministry of Interior plans to grant residence cards to more than 80,000 immigrants to better keep track of them. The ministry announced the plan on July 10, following the results of an immigration census. “An inter-ministerial committee and many operational working groups have been set up

  • Kingdom produces PPE gear

    Medical supplies from Cambodia have been donated to member countries of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to assist in the fight against Covid-19, said an ADB report published on July 9. The report stated that the supplies were donated as a response to global efforts to

  • Kingdom, US vow stronger ties

    At an academic forum on Saturday to celebrate 70 years of Cambodia-US diplomatic ties, Cambodian researchers and officials expressed hope of encouraging US investments and for that country to deepen and improve its bilateral relations. Held at the Royal Academy of Cambodia, it reviewed the past 70

  • Fifteen Cambodians from Saudi get Covid-19

    The Ministry of Health on Sunday confirmed 15 more imported cases of Covid. The 15 men ‒ all Cambodian aged 21 to 33 ‒ arrived from Saudi Arabia on Friday via a connecting flight in Malaysia. They were travelling with 79 other passengers, three of them women. The ministry said 80 of the

  • Ministry requests school opening

    The Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport on Thursday said it would request a decision from Prime Minister Hun Sen to allow a small number of schools to reopen next month. Ministry spokesman Ros Soveacha said if the request is granted, higher-standard schools will reopen

  • Kingdom eyes India FTA, China deal set for August

    Cambodia is studying the possibility of establishing a bilateral free trade agreement (FTA) with India to open a new market with the second-largest regional economy. This comes as an FTA with China is scheduled to be signed next month while similar negotiations with South Korea