Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - CHRC reviews ‘factual errors’ in Smith’s report

CHRC reviews ‘factual errors’ in Smith’s report

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Rhona Smith (Centre-left), UN special rapporteur met with Keo Remy, Chairman of Cambodia Human Rights Committee (CHRC) on April, 2019. Hong Menea

CHRC reviews ‘factual errors’ in Smith’s report

The Cambodian Human Rights Committee (CHRC) on Monday led an inter-ministerial meeting at the Council of Ministers to review “factual errors” in the draft annual reports compiled by Rhona Smith, the UN Human Rights Council’s (UNHRC) Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Cambodia.

CHRC spokesman Chin Malin said Smith’s report would be submitted to the 42nd session of the UNHRC, which will be held in September. He said Smith’s report showed the result of her last two visits to Cambodia.

He said the procedure is for the Special Rapporteur to send her draft report to the government for assessment and feedback on errors before submitting it to the UN.

“After the government received the draft report, CHRC organised the inter-ministerial meeting to check its contents because they are relevant to many government institutions."

“During the meeting, we categorised the report into parts so that the relevant institutions could check and give feedback on whether there are any errors or any points that do not reflect the real situation in Cambodia,” said Malin.

Smith recently made two visits to Cambodia – in November last year and in May.

During her May visit, she continued to focus on the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). She said at the end of her visit that an important development since November was the adoption of the SDG localisation plan.

However, she said some important human rights aspects of the SDGs did not appear in the plan.

She also called for the release of the leader of the Supreme Court-dissolved Cambodia National Rescue Party, Kem Sokha and said there was a “need to change the political culture to one that focuses on issues rather than persons”.

Mahmoud Garga, spokesman for the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights in Cambodia said Smith would report at the 42nd human rights council session and her report would be available publicly early September 2019.

Chin Malin said the government would give their feedback to Smith, but it would be up to her to accept or reject it.

“It is her right to accept or reject our advice for corrections on her report because she is an independent expert,” he said declining to cite the exact errors Smith had made.


  • Hun Sen asks Cambodians to believe in government

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Monday asked citizens and investors to trust that the government will overcome the challenges brought about by Covid-19 and the loss of the EU’s Everything But Arms (EBA) scheme. Speaking to reporters at the Peace Palace in Phnom Penh,

  • Westerdam passenger ‘never had’ Covid-19

    The US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) said the US citizen that allegedly tested positive in Malaysia after travelling on the Westerdam was never infected with Covid-19 in the first place. In an article published in the newspaper USA Today on Friday, CDC

  • ‘Ghost staff’ found, $1.7M returned to state coffers

    The Ministry of Civil Service said more than seven billion riel ($1.7 million) in salaries for civil servants was returned to the state last year after it discovered that the books had been cooked to pay ‘ghost officials’. This is despite claims by the Ministry of

  • Woman wanted for killing own son

    Police in Phnom Penh’s Meanchey district are on the lookout for a woman who allegedly hacked her son to death on Sunday in Stung Meanchey III commune. District police chief Meng Vimeandara identified the son as Chan Sokhom, 32. “The offender can’t escape forever.

  • H5N1 also poses deadly threat, ministry warns

    The Ministry of Health’s Communicable Disease Control (CDC) department has called on citizens to excise caution over H5N1 or bird flu that is spreading in the southern province of Vietnam. In a Facebook post, the department announced that it has made a series

  • Malaysia in turmoil

    Malaysian Prime Minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad has done it again. At the centre of two days of high drama and political manoeuvring, he has, wittingly or not, contributed to shaking Malaysia, and further causing its equities market to fall nearly three per cent. The drama