Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - COMMENT: U.N.'s Appeasement Policy Falls into Hands of Khmer Rouge Strategists

COMMENT: U.N.'s Appeasement Policy Falls into Hands of Khmer Rouge Strategists

COMMENT: U.N.'s Appeasement Policy Falls into Hands of Khmer Rouge Strategists

Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge have called the world's bluff, and the Cambodian peace process

is in crisis.

Since last October's Paris agreement, the international community has given the Khmer

Rouge valuable time to aggressively expand their military control, move into the

political arena, stockpile weapons, and collect vast sums of money-all without the

U.N. control which the agreement stipulates and to which the other Cambodian parties

are subjected.

As the country's economy collapses through international pressure and continuing

denial of aid, the Khmer Rouge again threaten the people of Cambodia. Without determined

international action, they will become an integral part of the country's political

future, despite their genocidal past.

The Khmer Rouge have refused to disarm their soldiers as required by the second phase

of the peace agreement. Meanwhile, 50,000 of their opponents have been disarmed by

the U.N. Transitional Authority in Cambodia (UNTAC).

On Sept. 25, the U.N. Security Council warned the Khmer Rouge that at a meeting the

following week it would decide "whether to close Thailand's border with Cambodia

to cut off the Khmer Rouge's export trade in tropical lumber and precious stones,

the group's main source of income."

But this option was not adopted. The outcome was a decision to go ahead with elections

even if the Khmer Rouge deny the population in their zones a vote, and a future meeting

to "discuss ways of bringing the Khmer Rouge back into the peace plan."

Pol Pot must be quaking in his boots.

Deadline after deadline has been ignored. Since notifying UNTAC on June 10 of their

refusal to disarm or give UNTAC access to its zones, the Khmer Rouge have continued

to violate the peace agreement with impunity.

In mid-June UNTAC Director Yasushi Akashi said that the Khmer Rouge "seems to

have returned to the offensive in the northern part of Cambodia," committed

"pretty serious violations," and "gravely compromised" the settlement.

In early June a U.N. helicopter flying near the Khmer Rouge base of Pailin in northwest

Cambodia was hit by a ground fire. UNTAC again responded with restraint, merely sending

a letter "to the senior liaison officer in Pailin, requesting troops in the

area. . .to refrain from such actions."

Meanwhile, U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Lawrence Eagleburger stated: "We do

not believe that efforts to halt the [peace] process should be cost-free to those

involved. . .We must resolve to ensure that the saboteurs of peace would be the ones

to suffer the most."

French Deputy Foreign Minister Georges Kiejman proposed a plan "to prevent the

Khmer Rouge from getting resources as they do right now through the more or less

illicit trading of gems" from Pailin, and timber. The Khmer Rouge are estimated

to be making U.S. $100 million a year through mining and logging. But Kiejman's plan

has not been implemented.

The Khmer Rouge's intransigence provoked a split in the UNTAC ranks. In mid-July

the deputy commander of the U.N. forces, French General Michel Loridon, who favored

a tougher approach, resigned.

"I am leaving Cambodia frustrated by my inability to implement the U.N. mandate,"

he said. "Here was our chance to deal with the Khmer Rouge, push them to implement

the accords they have signed. But I haven't succeeded in getting my superiors to

agree with me." UNTAC, Loridon said, was "just sitting and waiting for

the Khmer Rouge leaders to agree to disarm their troops."

Loridon believed that firm action would have brought results. "It is possible

at some point they will try to block the U.N. move by force. If it comes to that,

one may lose 200 men-and that could include myself-but the Khmer Rouge problem would

be solved for good."

According to an Australian U.N. military officer, the Khmer Rouge also "moved

into areas of Battambang and Siem Reap provinces to fill the vacuum created by the

cantonment" of their opponents and the U.N.'s disarming of Phnom Penh government


Also in mid-July, the Khmer Rouge again escalated their violent activities. Eight

civilians were killed and 11 injured in new fighting in central, northern, and southern

Cambodia. Akashi blamed the Khmer Rouge, saying: "Unfortunately the present

ceasefire violations continue to increase in number and in seriousness. The nature

of these actions points to a deliberate policy against ordinary Cambodians."

This terror has included racial massacres. On April 28 Khmer Rouge troops, armed

with B-40 rocket launchers and AK-47 rifles, stormed a village in Kompong Chhnang

province and killed seven ethnic Vietnamese civilians.

Four days later, UNTAC sent a representative to the village, and locals appealed

for 10 troopers to be stationed there for their protection. But this was not done,

and on May 14 the Khmer Rouge struck again. "The people have lost hope and left,"

a local official said.

On July 21 came another atrocity, this time in Kampot province. In a small village

near the Vietnamese border, gunmen massacred an ethnic Vietnamese couple and their

seven-day old son, four other children aged seven to 16-Cambodians whose grandmother

was Vietnamese-and their uncle. Neighbors heard shouts of "Destroy the Vietnamese

enemy!" Villagers told UNTAC that the killers were wearing military uniforms,

but that "after the slaughter the men ran towards a hideout of the Khmer Rouge."

However, one U.N. official in Phnom Penh claimed "there is no evidence"

that the attack was carried out by the Khmer Rouge and another claimed that renegade

government forces were responsible. U.N. officers further claimed that a government

military unit stationed nearby had done nothing to stop the hour-long attack.

All this proved false. When UNTAC's Civilian Police Component concluded its investigation

in August, Deputy Representative Behrooz Sadry revealed that witnesses' testimony

and other evidence proved the government soldiers did try to catch the assailants

and that Khmer Rouge guerrillas were to blame. But no suspects were apprehended,

and much damage had been done by the U.N.'s predilection to take seriously the propaganda

of the Khmer Rouge-despite their recent similar attacks, their history of genocide,

and their long record of deception.

The Khmer Rouge soon threatened yet another racial pogrom. The U.S. Chief of Mission

in Phnom Penh, Charles Twining, stated his fear that history might repeat itself,

with bodies of Vietnamese seen floating down the Mekong as in 1970.

Khmer Rouge leader Khieu Samphan said: "If the Cambodian people cannot see a

peaceful resolution to the problem, they will seek other means. So Twining's nightmare

might become a reality."

But Khmer Rouge targets are not restricted to Vietnamese residents. Three days before

the Kampot massacre, Khmer Rouge guerrillas mortared a Cambodian Buddhist monastery

in Siem Reap province, killing one monk, injuring three others, and destroying the

temple. In July, defectors told UNTAC that a Khmer Rouge general had executed their

company commander for his readiness to respect the Paris agreement on cantonment

of troops.

On July 21 the U.N. Security Council voted "to ensure that international assistance

to the rehabilitation and reconstruction of Cambodia from now on only benefits the

parties that are fulfilling their obligations." However, by early October, no

measures had been taken against those not fulfilling their obligations, and no aid

had arrived for those who are.

On July 26 Thai Foreign Minister Arsa Sarasin announced that the Khmer Rouge had

until the end of August to comply with the Paris agreement. This deadline, too, passed

by unnoticed.

Akashi overruled the Khmer Rouge to insist that UNTAC was "entitled to send

civilian and military police to zones under [Khmer Rouge] control at a suitable point

in the near future," but two months later he had still not done so. On Sept.

4 the United Nations lamely expressed "serious concern."

The international policy towards the Khmer Rouge amounts to appeasement, and it has

elicited similar results. Australian Foreign Minister Gareth Evans, an architect

of the peace plan, had asserted after it was signed that the "genocide issue

and all the emotion that's associated with that had now been resolved." He even

stated in July that the Khmer Rouge's complaints have "some reasonable foundation,"

and he "agreed with the idea of holding meetings with the Khmer Rouge, and that

things should not be as before."

On Aug. 20, the U.S. State Department warned that "if the Khmer Rouge continue

to obstruct the peace process, we expect that the Security Council may have to [consider]

further measures against the Khmer Rouge." But no action was taken.

UNTAC military commander General John Sanderson expressed optimism that UNTAC would

be able to "bring the Khmer Rouge back to the peace process," saying he

was "certain he can persuade local Khmer Rouge leaders to disarm." UNTAC

officials even claimed that "Khmer Rouge officers in several provinces have

said they are making active preparations to cooperate in the cantonment process in

the weeks ahead." Little came of this either.

Moreover, Eagleburger, then Acting U.S. Secretary of State, backed away from his

June warning that violations should not be "cost-free" and that "the

saboteurs" should "suffer."

"We may have to come to that," he said, describing sanctions as "something

we may have to look at reasonably soon." But now, he said, "the fundamental

point [is that the Khmer Rouge] are not going to benefit from the agreements if they

are not going to play by the rules."

The real point, however, is that the Khmer Rouge have already benefited enormously

from the implementation of the agreement. Denying them further benefits is no substitute

for punishing them for failure to respect an agreement they signed, which the other

Cambodian parties are implementing at their own cost.

On Sept. 2 Prince Norodom Sihanouk announced that the elections should go ahead without

the Khmer Rouge, who should be "set aside."

Ten days later Sihanouk, Akashi, and representatives of the five permanent members

of the U.N. Security Council made a pilgrimage to Pailin, where they attempted to

persuade the Khmer Rouge to rejoin the peace process. They failed. Sihanouk, at the

behest of China, then withdrew his statement that the U.N. peace process should go

ahead without the Khmer Rouge.

The U.N. Security Council's October decision to hold elections on schedule in May

1993 without an attempt to prevent the Khmer Rouge denying a vote to the people in

its zones was a weak enough response to repeated violations of the ceasefire and

the agreement.

But the Khmer Rouge responded with further violations, blowing up two bridges in

northern Cambodia, "the closest yet the Khmer Rouge have attacked to Phnom Penh,"

according to an UNTAC official. At the same time a senior Khmer Rouge commander admitted

that his guerrillas kidnapped eight ethnic Vietnamese, and the bodies of another

10 were found near the Cambodian coast. Khieu Samphan appears to have kept his word.

In late August, the former director of the U.S. State Department's Office for Vietnam,

Laos and Cambodia, Shep Lowman, acknowledged that from 1978 until 1986, "the

U.S. countenanced the revival and building up of the Khmer Rouge's political and

military capacity as ways to counterbalance Vietnamese might."

But from 1986, Lowman asserted, the U.S. had to "find a way to control the monster

that we had allowed to be created." Few people were more associated with the

creation of that monster than Jeane Kirkpatrick, who as U.S. ambassador to the United

Nations had voted for the Khmer Rouge to represent their Cambodian victims in international


But Kirkpatrick now sees the problem. She wrote in August that "the Khmer Rouge

refuses to turn in its weapons or permit U.N. access to areas under its control."

Because this "aggressor" has refused "to carry out an agreement to

which it had acquiesced, [the Cambodian peace plan] is on the verge of collapsing,"

she wrote.

"The Khmer Rouge," Kirk-patrick continued, "has used a painstakingly-negotiated

international agreement for disarmament, resettlement, and elections as an opportunity

for its troops to re-enter Phnom Penh and other areas of Cambodia from which they

had been driven." Unfortunately, she added, U.N. officials speak as if Pol Pot

"rather suddenly developed a will to peace and could be counted on" to

honor his commitments-"next time."

"They talk as if they did not know the consequences of such delays are irreversible,"

Kirkpatrick said.

- Ben Kiernan is associate professor of Southeast Asian History at Yale University

and author of How Pol Pot Came to Power and other works on modern Cambodia.


  • No payment required for travellers taking rapid Covid tests on arrival

    Ministry of Health officials said there would be no payment required for the rapid Covid-19 tests given to travellers who arrive in Cambodia from November 15 onwards after the quarantine requirement is lifted for fully vaccinated people. Health ministry spokeswoman Or Vandine told The Post on

  • General’s gun smuggling ring busted

    The Military Police sent six military officers to court on November 22 to face prosecution for possession of 105 illegal rifles and arms smuggling, while investigators say they are still hunting down additional accomplices. Sao Sokha, deputy commander of the Royal Cambodian Armed Forces and commander of

  • Prince Norodom Ranariddh passes away at 77

    Prince Norodom Ranariddh, the second son of the late King Father Norodom Sihanouk and former First Prime Minister of Cambodia, has passed away in France at the age of 77. “Samdech Krom Preah Norodom Ranariddh has passed away this morning in France just after 9am Paris-time,”

  • More Cambodians studying in US

    The number of Cambodian students studying at US colleges and universities in 2020-21 increased by 14.3 per cent over the previous year despite the Covid-19 pandemic, according to a recent US government report. The 2021 Open Doors report on International Educational Exchange showed that 848 Cambodian students studied

  • Cambodia, Thailand to discuss border reopening

    Cambodian authorities from provinces along the Cambodia-Thailand border will meet with Thai counterparts to discuss reopening border checkpoints to facilitate travel, transfer of products and cross-border trade between the two countries. Banteay Meanchey provincial deputy governor Ly Sary said on November 22 that the provincial administration

  • Police arrest Canadian with 167kg of drugs

    The Phnom Penh Municipal Court on November 15 placed a Canadian national in pre-trial detention in connection with smuggling and possessing 167kg of illegal drugs. Deputy National Police chief in charge of anti-drug enforcement Mak Chito told The Post on November 15 that the man was arrested