Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - The complexities of genocide

The complexities of genocide

The complexities of genocide


Charges of bias against KR tribunal officials distract from the broader issues of justice and verge on defamation.

Remains of victims of the Khmer Rouge on display at Choeung Ek killing fields during the Day of Anger commemoration in May.

It is understandable that defence lawyers at the Khmer Rouge tribunal will look for every angle and every loophole to gain an acquittal.

Indeed, it is good to see that here is one trial happening in Cambodia where the rights of the accused to a fair trial are being fully respected.

However, in their efforts to pillory the credentials of my co-author Helen Jarvis - the newly appointed head of the ECCC's Victims Unit - by citing our book Getting Away with Genocide?: Elusive Justice and the Khmer Rouge Tribunal as evidence of bias, they appear to have abandoned the most minimal standards of research and fact-checking, and do a disservice to the court.

In a letter dated June 4 and addressed to the court's deputy director of administration, Knut Rosandhaug, the defence team led by Michael Karnavas argues that the use of the word "genocide" in our book calls into question Jarvis's "absolute impartiality and strongly implies that Dr Jarvis has preconceptions about the alleged crimes" - namely, that they constituted genocide.

If these highly paid defence lawyers had taken the trouble to read our book, they would have found within it an introductory discussion on the use of the word genocide.

In that introduction, on page 4, we address several problematic subjects, such as how many Cambodians died, whether their deaths were the result of genocide, and several other issues.

We carefully explained that we used the "G-word" - genocide - not as a precise legal term but in the sociological sense of common usage, rather than as a legally defined crime.

The Khmer Rouge Tribunal, edited by John Ciorciari and published by the Documentation Centre of Cambodia, makes the same point.

"Genocide, the crime of crimes, has become closely associated with Democratic Kampuchea in the popular lexicon. Countless historians, lawyers, journalists, and human rights organizations have referred to the Khmer Rouge regime as 'genocidal'"(page 24).

Ever since 1979 and the ouster of the Pol Pot regime, genocide edged its way into the vocabulary of how Cambodians viewed the depth of their suffering.

From Cambodia to Rwanda and many other places, genocide became synonymous with the most heinous crimes even if, in law, the classification "crimes against humanity" was often a more accurate indictment and easier to prove.

Throughout the 1980s, Cambodian government and society routinely referred to the "genocidal regime".

It was also invoked by the prosecution in the 1979 Peoples Revolutionary Tribunal and used by Cambodian survivors in the US.

In Cambodian language, they used the phrase pro lai puoch sars, and this has always corresponded to 'genocide' in English translation.
Our book, therefore, accurately reflects that populist terminology and legitimacy that transcends any legal debate as to whether the mass crimes committed in Cambodia from 1975-79 actually constituted genocide according to international law.

In fact, in chapter 11 of Getting Away with Genocide? , titled "Clinching Convictions: The Challenge for the Prosecution", we deal with legal issues, and Jarvis specifically addresses the problems of proving that genocide had been committed.

But again, it appears that the defence lawyers have failed to do their homework and have never read the very passages that totally disprove their absurd claims against my co-author.

The Phnom Penh Post reported [June 8, 2009] that Andrew Inuazzi, a legal consultant for Nuon Chea's defence team, said he "absolutely" agreed with the position articulated by Ang Udom and Michael Karnavas, Ieng Sary's international co-lawyers, adding: " Certainly, it sounds like she has made up her mind about the fact of a genocide."

But in the same article he admitted that he had never read the book. It is not Ms Jarvis that has " made up her mind about the fact of a genocide" as he alleges, but rather Mr Inuazzi who has made up his mind about what the our book has to say about genocide, without even bothering to read it!

To make serious allegations and judgments about an author without ever having read the book in the first place is not the kind of international legal standard you expect to come from counsel in such an important tribunal.

Furthermore, as all lawyers should know, if they have misrepresented both the authors and the contents of a book, they have left themselves open to the charge of defamation. As one of the co-authors, I look forward to an apology from the lawyers involved on two grounds.

First, they misrepresented the views of the authors and the contents of the book they so publicly criticised.

Second, they failed to read the book in question, which they misused in their barrage of attacks on Dr Helen Jarvis.

It is regrettable that so much media attention has been deflected away from the more important aspects of the tribunal by these peripheral issues and pseudo-controversies.

Tom Fawthrop has covered Cambodia since 1979 for the BBC, The Guardian and others, and is an independent documentary filmmaker.


  • Ministry requests school opening

    The Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport on Thursday said it would request a decision from Prime Minister Hun Sen to allow a small number of schools to reopen next month. Ministry spokesman Ros Soveacha said if the request is granted, higher-standard schools will reopen

  • Judge lands in court after crashing into alleged thief

    Sen Sok district police on Thursday sent a Koh Kong Provincial Court judge to the Phnom Penh Municipal Court on manslaughter charges after he crashed his car into a woman riding a motorbike on Wednesday, killing her. District police chief Hour Meng Vang told The

  • Gov’t to boost Siem Reap tourism

    The Ministry of Tourism released the results of an inter-ministerial committee meeting concerning Siem Reap province’s Tourism Development Master Plan for 2020-2035 on Wednesday, revealing the government’s plan to improve the overall tourist landscape there. The meeting was attended by Minister of Tourism

  • ‘On the offensive’: Cambodia to load up on loans to stimulate economy

    As the dust settles on the economy, Cambodia comes to grips with what needs to be done to turn the economy around, starting with a big shopping list for credit ‘We are going on the offensive,” Vongsey Vissoth, Ministry of Economy and Finance permanent secretary

  • Government set to make up for cancelled April holiday

    The government is set to make up for a five-day Khmer New Year holiday late this month or early next month. The holiday was earlier cancelled due to the onset of Covid-19. The announcement is expected on Friday as the government is studying a range

  • Families told to register for cash handouts

    The government has called on poor families to apply to commune authorities for evaluation to receive financial support during the Covid-19 crisis. A $300 million budget has been planned for implementation within a year. Ministry of Economy and Finance secretary of state Vongsey Visoth said this

  • Crumbling prices, rent ruffle condo segment

    The prolonged decline in international arrivals to Cambodia intensified by renewed Covid-19 fears has driven down condominium sales prices and rental rates in Phnom Penh, a research report said. CBRE Cambodia, the local affiliate of US commercial real estate services and investment firm CBRE Group

  • Over $3M in traffic fines collected in two months

    Traffic police officers collected over $3 million in fines throughout the Kingdom during the past two months when officers strictly enforced the law in accordance with a May sub-decree, officials said. As incentives, law enforcement officers received between 200,000 and two million riel ($50 to $500) each. The figures

  • More than 10,000 workers suspended

    More than 10,000 workers at 18 factories in Svay Rieng province have been suspended because of Covid-19, said provincial deputy governor Ros Pharith. Home to 11 special economic zones, Pharith said Svay Rieng has not been spared as the pandemic takes a toll on the global economy. “There

  • Nod given for school exams

    The Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport announced that State-run higher educational institutions can hold examinations to end the academic year, while private schools can organise grade 9 and grade 12 examinations at their premises for two days. However, private institutions have to take measures to prevent