FOUR men have been convicted in Kampot Provincial Court for the June 3, 2000 murder
of a Funcinpec commune elections candidate and his wife.
Kampot Provincial Court Judge Kem Ravy on March 15 sentenced Laboeuk CPP commune
chief Im Nan and former Laboeuk militia member Rith Kha to 17 years in prison for
the murder of Prak Chhoeun and his wife Doung Meas.
Chhoeun and Meas were gunned down with AK-47s while sleeping in a hut next to their
Kampot rice field.
Two other suspects, Keo Khan and Svay Run, were sentenced in absentia to prison terms
of 15 years and 12 years respectively.
The four are also required to pay a compensation claim of six million riels to family
members of the victims.
The March 15 verdict, which followed one-day trial proceedings on March 12, was closely
monitored by human rights organizations due to its apparently overt political motivations.
Nan was widely suspected of having ordered the killing to eliminate a potential rival
for the long delayed commune elections. Chhoeun, a popular and respected member of
the Laboeuk commune, had been nominated as the Funcinpec commune election candidate
just days before his death.
Three witnesses - a soldier, a policeman and chief of Laboeuk commune's militia -
testified during the trial that Nan had made numerous unsuccessful attempts over
the last few years to hire them to kill Chhoeun.
However the judge strenuously distanced his verdict from any linkage to a political
motive for the killings.
"Our investigation proved that the evidence pointed to a revenge [motive] because
the victim was thought to have been a witch," said Ravy. "It was not a
Human rights observers at the trial were critical of the verdict's avoidance of a
possible political motive.
"Children of the victim are unhappy with the verdict because they claim that
their parents were victims of a political killing connected with their father's candidacy
for the upcoming commune elections," Adhoc spokesperson Yi Kosalvathanak said.
Kosalvathanak said the children rejected allegations in the court's finding that
the murders had been committed to avenge suspected "black magic" wrought
by Soeun and his wife.
"I think that this trial was incomplete because the court didn't mention [the
factor of] political intimidation," Kosalvathanak said.
Kosalvathanak's concerns were echoed by Sidney Jones, Executive Director of Human
Rights Watch (HRW).
"Without recognition of the political underpinnings of the crime, the deterrent
impact of Im Nan's conviction is going to be lost," Jones was quoted in a HRW
press release. "Official impunity for criminal acts will only end when the full
facts of cases like this one are publicly aired."
Funcinpec Co-Minister of Interior You Hockry, however, expressed satisfaction with
the court proceedings saying that the court was legally unable to address a possible
political motivation to the killing.
"In our law there is no article for the punishment of [crimes of] political
assassination," Hockry told the Post. "I think that the trial was fair
and is a message to everyone to cease...the desire for political assassinations."
Human Rights Watch has documented attacks against Funcinpec and opposition Sam Rainsy
Party commune election candidates including the separate murders of two SRP members
in Kampong Cham on Feb 10, 2000 and Aug 17, 2000.
The violence is widely believed to be linked to a reluctance of CPP commune chiefs
to surrender two decades of control of the Kingdom's grassroots in the coming 2002
Contact PhnomPenh Post for full articlePost Media Co Ltd
The Elements Condominium, Level 7
Hun Sen Boulevard
Phum Tuol Roka III
Sangkat Chak Angre Krom, Khan Meanchey
12353 Phnom Penh
Tel: +855(0) 23 888 161 / 162
Fax: +855(0) 23 214 318