Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Corruption or survival: the price to pay

Corruption or survival: the price to pay

Corruption or survival: the price to pay

"Are we corrupt?... Yes, I suppose we are," admits the primary school teacher

after a moment's thought. "But we are corrupt just to survive."

As she sits supervising a class of students who have paid her for this lesson, the

teacher, from Bak Touk primary school in Phnom Penh, draws a distinction.

"Are we different from the corrupt officials who have become millionaires?"

she asks. Denouncing those corrupt officials "who close their eyes and swallow

big money by destroying the national forests or selling state property," she

adds: "They are very, very rich. They never have to worry about having nothing

to eat like us. They have plenty of money, even for their great-grandchildren in

the future.''

Every morning before school officially starts, and every lunchtime, this teacher

- and virtually all of her colleagues throughout Phnom Penh - holds "extra"

classes for her students, charging several hundred riels a lesson.

Aged in her late 30s, the teacher, who asked to remain anonymous, is thin and sick.

She talks faintly, and coughs regularly - she complains of lung problems which she

attributes to standing in front of a chalkboard since 1979. She nurses her young

baby on her lap in the classroom; she says she has no choice but to bring her baby

to school with her every day.

Earning about $20 a month from her official salary, she says it isn't enough to even

pay for her family's food. She needs the money from the extra classes. To her, charging

for these classes is a fair swap - money in exchange for knowledge - and a matter

of survival.

Corruption or survival, the charging of such fees by teachers is a fact of life in

Cambodia's skeletal school system. Typically, primary school teachers hold two extra

classes a day - one in the early morning and one at lunchtime - and charge each student

200-500 riels a class.

The practice is implicitly permitted by education authorities, who unofficially restrict

teachers' charges to no more than 100 riels a day, though that is frequently exceeded.

Then there are extra charges: to get your son or daughter in a good seat near the

front of a class, or to ensure that the teacher pays special attention to them.

For parents and teachers, it's a system which is hard to avoid - the "extra"

classes are virtually mandatory; a student who doesn't attend them is hardly likely

to get well-treated in their "normal" classes. Switching teachers to one

who doesn't charge as much is also frowned upon, as teachers have an unwritten code

not to ëinterfere' in each other's business by taking each other's students.

Although primary school teachers maintain that they target the "rich",

and don't charge the poor, the reality is that some kids don't go to school because

their parents can't afford to send them.

Some parents balk at the paying the charges, but others accept them as necessary

for their children's education.

Heng Lida, 27, who lives near Toul Tompong market, says she has no problem paying

200 riels a day for her son Heng Seyha to study at Phom 6 school. Moreover, she pays

another 5,000 riels a month to his teacher for extra attention.

"If I don't give the teacher extra money, he will not keep his eyes on my son,"

Lida said. Before she offered the teacher money, she found no lessons had been written

in her son's book. "After I gave the teacher some money, I found my son had

written some lessons in his book when he came back home."

Lida notes that her son is "lazy to learn, so I cannot blame the teacher for

not paying attention to my son because there are many more students in the class

the teacher has to deal with".

While Lida is forgiving, other parents are angry at the "corruption" within

schools. As for the teachers, they claim they don't like the system any more than

most parents do, but that - unless the government pays them more - they don't have

any choice.

"Am I happy to get 200 riels extra from my students? I don't want to be a disreputable

teacher like this, but my hungry stomach forces me to do this," says You Ngorn

Chheang, another teacher at Bak Touk primary.

Every day, Chheang rides his old second-hand motorcycle to the school, near the Juliana

Hotel, where his working day is lengthened by the extra classes he teaches.

"I'm too tired to do this [extra] work. I would like to rest, but I can't,"

says Chheang, looking pale and thin. With his wife and three children to support,

he says he holds extra classes even during the school vacation.

Although primary school teachers haven't joined the current strike by high school

and university tutors, Chheang supports their cause.

"The government told us lies many times before as they produced the words like:

'Let the people be rich before the State'. Then, the government used other words

like ëto eliminate poverty' and later they corrected the word from 'eliminate' to

'reduce'," he says.

Chheang says he charges his students 200 riels a day, and that his family is dependent

on the roughly 5,000 riels a day extra income that this earns him.

But students at Bak Touk say their teachers regularly charge 500 riels. With typical

class sizes of 40-60 students, teachers could easily reap more than 20,000 riels

a day from their classes.

Officially, teachers earn $15-$20 a month (60,000-80,000 riels), and high school

and university teachers have gone on strike in pursuit of about $300 a month. The

government has offered only an extra 20,000 riels ($5) to them, which - if accepted

- would also be paid to primary teachers.

Chheang accepts that $300 a month is going to be difficult to secure, and would be

happy if the government extended its offer of 20,000 riels to 30,000 riels. That,

he says, would help eliminate the need for extra classes.

Complaints over teacher salaries - and their unofficial fees - have escalated with

Cambodia's transition over the past decade from communism to a free market economy.

"Before, the standard of living of the teachers was high, and the level of society

was low. But now, the level of society is high and the standard of living of the

teachers is low," says Chea Cheath, deputy director of Phnom Penh Education


Between 1979 and 1988 teachers received salaries of 90-105 riels per month - which

was adequate, because they also got free housing, electricity and water and some

rations of food and other supplies.

But in the 1990s, many of them lost their free housing and other supplies, and their

salaries failed to keep up with inflation. On their own, teachers began to demand

money from students' families.

The Phnom Penh municipal department of education tried unsuccessfully to crack down

on this practice but - unable or unwilling to boost teachers' salaries - eventually

accepted it. An unwritten deal was hatched: the department agreed to turn a blind

eye to teachers' charging 100 riels a day, providing that they offered additional

classes to students in return.

"We realized that is not legal but we closed our eyes to it because we didn't

have another solution. If we didn't agree, the teachers would not teach, and when

the teachers don't teach what would happen to Cambodian students?" says Chea


The agreement was not long in being breached; the standard quickly became 200 riels

a day, and up to 500 riels depending on the level of the class.

Um Hoeung, the director of Phnom Penh Municipal Education Department, both sympathizes

with the teachers and vows to try to keep them in line. About 20 teachers - those

who were considered to be too greedy - have been administratively disciplined in

the past few years.

"We suspended them because they had forced students to buy them cakes and charged

them more than one hundred riels for their extra classes," says Hoeung, explaining

that the teachers had been transferred to office duties.

The user-pays practice is by no means limited to primary schools. According to parents

and teachers, high school teachers also charge fees but in different ways - for instance

they might charge to give a written copy of a lesson to a student, rather than make

the student copy it down from a blackboard. High schools and university teachers

also charge for extra tutoring, but these classes are more optional than they are

in primary schools.

At one Phnom Penh primary school, Boeng Trabek, headmaster Men Samon notes that teacher

salaries and pupil fees are just part of the problem with Cambodia's poor education


Typically, one primary school classroom is shared by two classes, with daily lessons

compressed into a half-day. Students are taught at an accelerated rate and not able

to absorb their lessons.

For teachers, the quality of education suffers because of the amount of time and

energy they expend on mere survival. For pupils and their families, financial pressures

can mean that only the relatively wealthy get a good education. In some cases, the

pressures explode into violence: teachers beat students, and vice-versa, and some

secondary school students carry guns.

Men Samon, of Boeng Trabek primary, worries about the collapse of Cambodian culture

and society unless education is made a high priority. "Remember when the culture

collapses the nation will melt away," he warns.

In the meantime, Cambodia's young - or those who can afford it - go on learning what

is needed to survive in the school system.

Heng Lida, the mother who pays 200 riels a day plus 5,000 riels a month for her son

to get special attention, recalls taking her son to school one morning. Stopping

on the way to buy breakfast near the school gates, her son got frightened when he

saw the school director.

"Mother, mother, look at that... he is Om Neayouk, (uncle director)" Lida's

son told her. Asked why he was frightened, her son said: "I'm afraid that he

will beat me because I do not buy cake for my teachers."


  • Hong Kong firm done buying Coke Cambodia

    Swire Coca-Cola Ltd, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Hong Kong-listed Swire Pacific Ltd, on November 25 announced that it had completed the acquisition of The Coca-Cola Co’s bottling business in Cambodia, as part of its ambitions to expand into the Southeast Asian market. Swire Coca-Cola affirmed

  • Moody’s sets outlook rating to ‘negative’ for Cambodia

    US global rating agency Moody’s Investors Service Inc on November 15 announced that it downgraded Cambodia’s outlook from “stable” to “negative” and maintained its B2 local and foreign currency issuer ratings. “The negative outlook reflects a deteriorating external position as illustrated by the severe

  • NagaWorld union leader arrested at airport after Australia trip

    Chhim Sithar, head of the Labour Rights Supported Union of Khmer Employees at NagaWorld integrated casino resort, was arrested on November 26 at Phnom Penh International Airport and placed in pre-trial detention after returning from a 12-day trip to Australia. Phnom Penh Municipal Court Investigating Judge

  • Korean first lady paves way for ill boy’s surgery

    A 14-year-old boy with congenital heart disease who was lucky enough to meet with South Korean first lady Kim Keon-hee may get the chance of a lifetime and receive surgery and treatment at Asan Medical Center in Seoul, South Korea. After seeing his plight, many

  • Kingdom’s rice crowned world’s No1

    Cambodia’s Phka Rumduol jasmine variety has been crowned the World’s Best Rice for the fifth time at the TRT (The Rice Trader) World Rice Conference in Phuket, Thailand on November 17, according to leaders of the Kingdom’s apex rice industry body. Phka Rumduol

  • Ministry to 'seek justice' for officials indicted in US for 'monkey smuggling'

    The Cambodian government and the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries said they will make the “utmost effort” to seek justice for a Cambodian official arrested in John F Kennedy International Airport in New York for allegedly conspiring to smuggle crab-eating macaque monkeys (Macaca fascicularis)