Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - CPP plan to 'open the blood way' in case of dispute

CPP plan to 'open the blood way' in case of dispute

CPP plan to 'open the blood way' in case of dispute


The 'Eye of Justice' watches the vote counting on July 28.

Eventually, everyone agreed the meeting took place. And there was even consensus

that what was written in notes taken at the meeting and obtained by the Post was

pinpoint accurate. But on the most important elements, the Cambodian People's Party

(CPP) denied everything.

What is not in dispute is this: at 8 a.m. on July 4, a collection of more than 100

local NGOs-of which 76 were registered to monitor the election-went to a meeting

with Prime Minister Hun Sen at his Takhmau residence, the so-called Tiger's Lair.

The man who organized the meeting was Om Yentieng, the PM's advisor on information,

local relations and human rights. When the Post spoke to him on July 25-just two

days before the vote-Yentieng refused to answer any questions on the topic.

Also present were some CPP heavyweights-Senior Minister Sok An, Police Chief Hok

Lundy, and Minister of Defense Tea Banh. An unusual mix for what the on-the-record

participants maintain was merely a casual meeting of election-related NGOs.

In all, more than 300 people were present to hear the Prime Minister's thoughts ahead

of the election. Also discussed were the ruling party's plan to discredit the main

local election monitoring organizations (EMOs), and even organize bloody demonstrations

in support of the CPP if necessary.

The hand-written notes of the meeting state that the ruling party had put in place

a plan to counter unfavorable findings by the largest local EMOs by using the 76

local NGOs that had been granted observer status by the National Election Committee


At the meeting, discussion centered around these EMOs, which the party considers

trustworthy, and the remaining 13, which it does not. None of the EMOs regarded as

unfriendly to the ruling party-among them Comfrel, Nicfec and Women for Prosperity-was


By July 4, the NEC had approved 89 local EMOs. That climbed to 102 by election day,

representing an eight-fold increase since the previous general election: NEC figures

show just 13 were granted observer status in 1998, while 15 observed last year's

local elections.

The Post has been told that all 76 are affiliated to the ruling party. That would

fit a pattern by the CPP, which has established numerous NGOs over the years to do

its bidding. Human Rights Watch noted as much in its 1998 country report, which stated


"In October 1997 the government launched an NGO Monitoring Commission, chaired

by Cabinet Minister Sok An, to follow the activities of NGOs, in particular those

suspected of being involved in political work ... NGOs are not only being monitored

but courted as well, with new ones being set up and funded by the CPP."

The head of the NEC's legal department, Keo Phalla, told the Post that technically,

all the EMOs were operating within the rules.

But, he admitted, it was difficult for his department-which provides first scrutiny

of applications-to know where the EMOs' funding really came from. Asked whether he

thought a number of them were affiliated with the CPP, he replied: "I know,

but I don't want to know."

NEC spokesman Leng Sochea said that according to the NEC's Code of Conduct, no EMO

may be affiliated with any local political party. In theory, at least, that means

none of the 76 should have been granted observer status.

This group of 76 was divided into four alliances, under the collective name 'The

Eye of Justice'. The logo, as seen in the photograph on the page, is a stylized eye

designed especially for this election.

One alliance is headed by Chea Chamroeun, who has confirmed he was at the meeting;

a second by Chhay Veasna, who denied being there; a third by Chan Savuth, whom the

Post was unable to contact; and the last by Kang Sothea, who said he did attend the


Chea Chamroeun is president of at least two of the 76 NGOs-the Cambodian Coordination

Committee (CCOC) and the Cambodian Institute for Development and Human Rights (CIDH).

He also has a controversial prior association with the NEC. In 1998 the Post ran

several stories which reported that Sok An and Om Yentieng successfully lobbied to

have NGOs vote Chamroeun on to the NEC as the NGO representative. It was alleged

that $100 was paid to local NGOs to ensure they voted for him.

In a conversation with the Post on July 28 this year, Chamroeun confirmed several

key details in the notes. Among them: the meeting was indeed organized by Yentieng;

Sok An and Tea Banh were present; and it consisted predominantly of a monologue by

Hun Sen.

He also confirmed that Hun Sen told participants that Funcinpec president Prince

Norodom Ranariddh would not be President of the National Assembly if the royalists

lost the vote.

However, he claimed its motive was entirely benign.

"It was simply a chat with Khmer NGOs which support the government's policies,"

he said. "The meeting did not discuss any big issues. It was simply to appeal

to the observers to work justly to monitor the election to ensure justice, transparency

and the acceptability of the result."

Chamroeun said those invited were NGOs which are not regarded as "against the

government" and which wanted to observe the election. Hun Sen had appealed to

the NGOs to "keep up their good work and to work properly".

"He also said that if he lost the election, he would step down peacefully from

power and not create any problem," Chamroeun said. "And he said we have

to cooperate and work together."

Fellow alliance head Kang Sothea, who told the Post on July 29 that he had 28 NGOs

in his grouping, echoed Chamroeun's comments and maintained that there was no political

party alliance.

"My alliance will support the election result called by the NEC," he said.

However Om Yentieng's silence on the meeting raises questions about just how innocuous

it really was. Fifteen minutes of questioning failed to elicit an answer on whether

the meeting even took place (see box).

The notes suggest the reason. They reveal a darker purpose, as does the fact that

the party's most senior political, military and police officials were present. The

notes record the Prime Minister saying that if the party lost, "Hun Sen will

be a normal MP". But they go on to outline measures to ensure that losing was

not on the cards. Halfway through the session, the writer states that the remaining

point of discussion "is to destroy the result of the upcoming election".

"We would like a fair and just election, just like it is stated in the law,"

it continues. "But if it is against the law, no one will come here to solve

this problem. We will not let this happen. Everyone needs to accept the result of

the election."

This is where Chamroeun's version differs from what is in the notes. The Post was

told further details of the meeting by a person involved in monitoring the election.

He refused to be identified for fear of being targeted.

Although the man was not present at the meeting, he said three people who were there

had told him of the July 4 gathering shortly after it took place.

All three, who spoke with the observer separately and whom he has known for several

years, told a similar tale: the message was that the coalition of the CPP and the

76 NGOs "could not afford to lose" the election.

"If we can win by the law, then we win. If we lose by the law, we must still

win," one of them said they were told.

The three said the 76 EMOs were instructed to release a statement describing the

election as free and fair, regardless of what actually happened. The sources also

said the CPP had decided upon two strategies to counter potentially negative statements

by the largest EMOs-Comfrel and Nicfec-both of which the CPP distrusts.

The notes outline those strategies. The NGOs, it states, were to announce that they

"accept the result of the election". The first option-and it is not entirely

clear from the notes whether this was addressed to the NGOs or the military-would

be "to deploy force to protect the statement of the 76".

The second, ominously, would be "to open the blood way", with the 76 organizing

counter-demonstrations in support of the CPP "in order to attack".

"This means that Hun Sen will protect himself in order to counter-attack,"

the notes record him saying.

The term "opening the blood way" is a military one, used in a situation

where the only way to escape is to rush the enemy and shed blood. In terms of resolving

post-election disputes, it is a worrying turn of phrase.

Quite apart from the CPP's attitude towards the election outcome, the episode also

raises questions about the supposed independence of the NEC. The election body, which

was reformed in the wake of last year's local elections, has again been criticized

in the approach to this ballot for bias towards the CPP.

Whether it knew about the affiliation of the 76 NGOs that it approved as monitors

is not clear-NEC chairman Im Suosdey refused all comment on the approval process,

except to confirm that his board does sign off on the applications. He said he had

not attended the Takhmau meeting, then hung up.

But it is remarkable that a coalition of 76 pro-CPP NGOs-three-quarters of all those

observing, and making up around one-third of the 29,500 local observers-could get

accreditation to observe the elections, apparently with a plan to call them free

and fair regardless. And why the body responsible for ensuring the election was conducted

in a free and fair manner did not notice.

Such a blunder, if that is what it was, also raises questions about the involvement

of the UN Development Programme, which is deeply involved with the NEC. After last

year's local elections it was criticized by some local and international election

observers for overstepping its mandate by lobbying the international community on

behalf of the NEC over equal media access. The observers said the action "clearly

smacked of pro-NEC bias".

But Jonathan Burrough of the UNDP's election unit, told the Post on July 30 that

the UN body had little to do with the day-to-day operations of the NEC such as observer

approvals. It simply provides advisory services to the legal and media departments,

as well as staff training and education.

He said he was not aware of the CPP affiliations of the majority of local EMOs, adding

that the UNDP expected all observer organizations to meet international standards.

There is another aspect: among the final entries in the notes is one that records

that a sum of around $350,000 was with Om Yentieng. The notes do not make clear what

the money was for, but the NGOs were told to contact him about it. The Post was told

by the anonymous observer it was to pay for unspecified "activities".

But Chamroeun claimed his EMOs had not received any funding from the CPP. And on

July 29, his alliance issued its statement, noting that the election was undertaken

"freely, fairly, transparently and equally, without any intimidation or violence".

It went on to state that such an outcome reflects "the CPP's efforts so far

in terms of serving all the citizens with great concern", and closed by saying

that to refute the result of the election would be "an illegal act leading to

political instability and to chaos".

"[That] will bring about new disasters and have an impact on the daily lives

of the citizens, and will also destroy the democracy which is growing these days,"

it concluded.


  • Hong Kong firm done buying Coke Cambodia

    Swire Coca-Cola Ltd, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Hong Kong-listed Swire Pacific Ltd, on November 25 announced that it had completed the acquisition of The Coca-Cola Co’s bottling business in Cambodia, as part of its ambitions to expand into the Southeast Asian market. Swire Coca-Cola affirmed

  • Cambodia's Bokator now officially in World Heritage List

    UNESCO has officially inscribed Cambodia’s “Kun Lbokator”, commonly known as Bokator, on the World Heritage List, according to Minister of Culture and Fine Arts Phoeurng Sackona in her brief report to Prime Minister Hun Sen on the night of November 29. Her report, which was

  • NagaWorld union leader arrested at airport after Australia trip

    Chhim Sithar, head of the Labour Rights Supported Union of Khmer Employees at NagaWorld integrated casino resort, was arrested on November 26 at Phnom Penh International Airport and placed in pre-trial detention after returning from a 12-day trip to Australia. Phnom Penh Municipal Court Investigating Judge

  • Sub-Decree approves $30M for mine clearance

    The Cambodian government established the ‘Mine-Free Cambodia 2025 Foundation’, and released an initial budget of $30 million. Based on the progress of the foundation in 2023, 2024 and 2025, more funds will be added from the national budget and other sources. In a sub-decree signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen

  • Two senior GDP officials defect to CPP

    Two senior officials of the Grassroots Democratic Party (GDP) have asked to join the Cambodian People’s Party (CPP), after apparently failing to forge a political alliance in the run-up to the 2023 general election. Yang Saing Koma, chairman of the GDP board, and Lek Sothear,

  • Cambodia's poverty cut in half from 2009 to 2019: World Bank report

    A report published by the World Bank on November 28 states that Cambodia’s national poverty rate fell by almost half between 2009 and 2019, but the Covid-19 pandemic recently reversed some of the poverty reduction progress. Cambodia’s poverty rate dropped from 33.8 to 17.8 per cent over the 10