Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Debating Genocide

Debating Genocide

Debating Genocide

Craig Etcheson's claims ( PPPost, V13/N26, Dec 17/04) that (1) the UN Group of Experts,

most legal scholars and jurists are of the view that the KR committed genocide, and

(2) the Vietnamese minority was reduced from about 500,000 to zero by extermination

and deportation are factually and legally wrong.

In fact, neither the UN Experts nor most legal scholars have concluded that the KR

atrocities constituted genocide. A very few lawyers and some political scientists,

however, have attempted to conclude that KR's killings constituted "genocide",

but they have done so by misapplying the Genocide Convention or by their ignorance

of the national/ethnic composition of the KR leaders.

"Genocide" as defined in the Genocide Convention is conduct such as mass

murder committed with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national,

ethnic, racial or religious group. Killing of an ethnic/national Khmer by an ethnic/national

Khmer is not genocide under the Convention. Prohibition of religious practices is

also not genocide so long as there is no intent to eliminate a group on the basis

of their religion.

Under international law, deportation (of Vietamese residents) alone did/does not

constitute genocide unless it was intended to cause serious mental and physical harm

with the intent of bringing about their physical elimination. It is incorrect to

say that KR had such intent in relation to the Vietnamese returnees (who were, incidentally,

lucky to have left).

In KR liberated zones (over 80% of Cambodia), the repatriation commenced in 1973

and continued after April 1975. By the end of 1975, virtually all Vietnamese were

gone. This was because, firstly, trade and commerce were strictly prohibited and,

like everyone else in Cambodia, the Vietnamese were (or would have been) herded into

co-operatives. Thus, there was no incentive for them to remain in Cambodia. Second,

soon after the US-Vietnam 1973 Paris Agreements, in February 1973, Pol Pot and Nuon

Chea and the Vietnamese Secretary. Nguyen Van Linh and Gen. Tran Nam Trung held a

meeting where the Vietnamese requested that all the Vietnamese be repatriated into

North Vietnamese liberated zones in the South to prepare for the national elections

as stipulated under the Paris Agreements. Pol Pot and Nuon Chea agreed and the repatriations

followed soon after.

It is true that over 400,000 Vietnamese were in Cambodia before 1975. However, Lon

Nol massacred thousands and expelled about 320,000. By April 1975, about 50,000-100,000

Vietnamese remained in Cambodia, but by December 1975, most, if not all, were repatriated.

There is no proof that the KR leadership had the intent to eliminate the Vietnamese

or other minorities based on race/ethnicity. Political killings of a few hundred

Vietnamese did occur, after the 1977 attempted coup in which KR leaders blamed Vietnam.

The security forces were directed to search for Vietnamese suspected of being foreign/KGB

agents.

The allegation that the KR committed genocide against other Cambodia ethnic minorities

is also without foundation. Of the eight members of the top organ, the Standing Committee

of the Communist Party, only two were ethnic Khmer, Ros Nhim and Chhit Cheoun (Mok).

The rest, Pol Pot, Nuon Chea, Vorn Vet, Sao Phim are of Sino ethnicity; Son Sen,

Ieng Sary are of Vietnamese origin. Kaing Kek Eav (Duch), the notorious Tuol Slaeng

Prison Chief is of Chinese/Vietnamese background; Khieu Samphan is of Sino ancestry.

This mixed national/race/ethnic composition makes it difficult to argue that the

KR leaders intended to kill ethnic minority groups to which they belonged.

- Bora Touch, Sydney, Australia

MOST VIEWED

  • Trio from Cambodia earn gold medals at int’l math olympiad

    Three Cambodian students won gold awards in the grade 12 math competition at the Singapore and Asian Schools Math Olympiads (SASMO). A total of 33,679 candidates from 28 countries competed in the tough contest. Lim Chhingy, was the highest ranked among the three. “Of the grade 12 students, I

  • Historic Battambang town bans billboards

    The Battambang town administration informed all house and business owners in Svay Por commune to remove all billboards by August 1 as it is preparing to submit the town to UNESCO for inclusion on its historical cultural heritage list. Its July 25 notice said all signage was

  • All foreigners' accommodations to be inspected: Sar Kheng

    The Ministry of Interior is undertaking a serious effort to inspect all the accommodations of foreigners in Cambodia – except diplomats – in order to find and identify human traffickers. Minister Sar Kheng said this would include inspections on the homes of foreigners employed by businesses, private

  • Ice cream, noodles flagged over carcinogen

    The General Department of Customs and Excise of Cambodia (GDCE) has identified three types of instant noodles and ice cream trademarks originating from Thailand, Vietnam and France that are suspected to contain ethylene oxide, which poses a cancer risk to consumers. The general department has

  • Exclusive interview with Josep Borrell Fontelles, High Representative of the EU

    CAMBODIA is hosting the 55th ASEAN Foreign Ministers’ Meeting (AMM) and Related Meetings this week with top officials from the US, China, and Russia and other countries in the region slated to attend and to meet with face-to-face with their counterparts on the sidelines. In

  • Compulsory vehicle insurance on the cards

    The government plans to introduce compulsory insurance for private vehicles to make sure that health and property costs for victims of road crashes are protected, according to Ministry of Economy and Finance secretary of state Ros Seilava. This would make Cambodia the last country in