Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Defining genocide

Defining genocide

Defining genocide

Raymund Johansen (Post, December 16) reiterates the important point that,

regardless of what we call it or what legal findings emerge during the tribunal,

the violence that occurred during this period was heinous and deserving of our

full condemnation.

Rupert Haw, in turn, raises questions (Post, January

13) about whether mass murder undertaken for a "political objective" can be

considered a genocide (it can be, as illustrated by various ideological

genocides that took place during the 20th century, ranging from the Armenian

genocide to Rwanda and now Darfur). Their comments, even if we disagree at

points, are productive and civil.

Touch Bora's latest letter (Post,

January 13), in contrast, throws up a smokescreen of figures, innuendo, and

one-liners to cover poor reasoning and misunderstanding.

In my original

letter (Post, October 7), I stated that I view the DK violence as genocide both

in the strict sense of the UN Convention and "in the broader sense used by most

scholars of genocide (which encompasses systematic attempts to annihilate

political and economic groups, among others)."

Touch Bora replied that

this "assertion is wrong in law and in fact" and that I was "incorrect to claim

that (1) killing of political and economic groups is also genocide in the 'broad

sense' of the convention and (2) that most scholars of genocide agree" (Post,

November 4). Bora misread/misunderstood the first part of my argument, which

held that the Cambodian case warrants the term genocide when defined more

broadly, as originally intended by the person who coined the term genocide

(Raphael Lemkin) and the preliminary 1946 UN General Assembly resolution that

included "political and other groups."

Touch Bora now implicitly

acknowledges his misreading/misunderstanding of this point and concedes the part

of my argument: he is now focusing only on the narrow definition promulgated in

the 1948 UN Genocide Convention, which excluded "political and other groups" for

political reasons.

So we are only left with the question of whether or

not a genocide took place in the narrow sense of the UN convention. Touch Bora's

original letter answered this in the negative (Post, November 4), drawing on a

fairly narrow range of documentary evidence to support his claims. Although I am

not a lawyer, as Touch Bora notes, I was able to point out to him that a much

broader range of evidence is relevant, including demographic studies, forensic

analysis, mapping surveys, eyewitness testimonies, and so forth (Post, December


In his latest letter (Post, January 13), Touch Bora does not attack

the gist of the argument, instead focusing on three sources of evidence I


First, he critiques Ysa Osman's figures, which I cited, on the

mortality of Chams. In doing so, he directly borrows from Ben Kiernan's 2003

article in Critical Asian Studies. Ironically, after using Kiernan's critique of

Ysa Osman, Touch Bora dismisses Kiernan's detailed demographic work on the

genocide of the Chams by simply saying his figures are "inflated." He presents

no evidence to support this claim. While they differ in terms of the absolute

numbers, the studies of Osman and Kiernan both highlight the key point "that

Chams appear to have perished at a much higher rate than the general populace

during DK (Kiernan's study lists the rate of Cham mortality as 36 percent versus

21 percent nationally). This suggests that there was a genocidal intent to

destroy Chams, though, as I originally stated, such findings need to be

supported by other types of evidence, including eyewitness


Second, Touch Bora states that I was mistaken when I stated

that Ben Kiernan's demographic analysis holds that 20,000 ethnic Vietnamese died

during DK. In fact, it is Touch Bora who is incorrect: Kiernan uses this figure

on page 458 of The Pol Pot Regime, which represents the higher end of his

projected mortality figures for ethnic Vietnamese (between 10,000 and 20,000

deaths). Even as he attempts to chip away at Kiernan's figures, Touch Bora again

obfuscates the crucial point that most remaining ethnic Vietnamese appear to

have perished during DK, another indication of genocide.

And, third,

Touch Bora suggests that I was either lied to or fabricated an interview in

which a cadre who worked at a subdistrict office told me that he received a

letter specifying that ethnic Vietnamese and Chams, among other enemy groups,

should be "swept clean."

Touch Bora's unbecoming remark is once again

based on a lack of understanding. Touch Bora claims that if such a letter

existed, reference to it would exist in the S-21 archive and that the DK

administrative system did not include subdistricts. If Touch Bora was familiar

with the existing archival material, he would know that the S-21 holdings are

incomplete and that very little documentary material on the Northern/Central

Zone security apparatus appears to have survived.

Moreover, the

subdistrict was a meaningful administrative unit in the Northern/Central zone

and other locales during DK. Touch Bora can find confirmation of this point in

academic sources (see, for example, Kiernan 1993:13) and Tuol Sleng confessions

from Northern/Central Zone personnel, such as that of Koy Thuon's deputy,


After repeating his erroneous claim that "certainly, there was no

[subdistrict] office," Touch Bora argues that "the Cham were not anywhere near

being 'swept clean.'" This is a strange argument for a lawyer to make: the

Genocide Convention encompasses attempts to destroy given groups "in whole or in


Regardless, with regard to the area of Kampong Cham province where

I conducted fieldwork, there is evidence that, in some places, most or all of

the Chams were "swept clean." Survey reports for the 1979 tribunal also suggest

the widespread massacre of Chams in places like Kampong Siem and Kang Meas


No doubt Touch Bora will try to undermine such sources of

data. Accordingly, I'd like to suggest that he carry out his own field surveys

of the area. (To date, he has provided no evidence that he has ever conducted

any relevant primary field research on this issue.) I'd be happy to give him

directions to relevant areas of the former Northern/Central Zone. If he took the

time to conduct such primary research, he'd find evidence suggesting that

genocide in the narrow sense of the UN Convention took place.


Touch Bora claims that the "fact that the majority of the DK top leaders were

from various (Sino/Viet/Cham) ethnicities supports a lack of genocidal intent

toward ethnic minorities" (Post, January 13), an assertion that echoes an

argument he made in an earlier letter to the Post (January 26, 2005). This is an

odd line of reasoning. On the one hand, the Khmer Rouge leadership did purge two

high-ranking cadre who had strong ethnic identifications, Prasith and Sos Man.

On the other hand, most of the top DK leaders were fully assimilated and

identified as Khmer. If he were alive, Pol Pot, who once assumed the pen name

"the original Khmer," would no doubt be befuddled to find Touch Bora referring

to him as a member of an ethnic minority.

Touch Bora has worked hard for

Cambodia and deserves to be commended for this. Unfortunately, his recent

letters to the Post have been plagued by misunderstanding, faulty logic, and

basic mistakes. I'm sure both of us look forward to the beginning of the

tribunal when at least a handful of former Khmer Rouge leaders will be held

accountable for the project of mass murder in which they participated. Time will

tell if they are charged with and convicted of genocide in the narrow sense of

the Genocide Convention.

Alex Hinton - Rutgers University, New

Jersey, USA


  • Kingdom may hire Turkish power ship

    Cambodia is considering negotiating with Turkey to hire a 200MW-capacity power ship to meet electricity demands as the country faces an ongoing electrical shortage, according to the prime minister. Speaking to garment workers in Pursat province on Wednesday, Prime Minister Hun Sen said Electricite du

  • ‘Kingdom lacks up to 400MW in available electricity’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has called on the general public, hoteliers and businesspeople with generators to use them as back-up as the Electricity Authority of Cambodia cannot generate enough electricity to meet needs due to low water levels in power station reservoirs. On Saturday evening

  • EDC tackles power shortfall

    Electrcite Du Cambodge (EDC) on Monday issued a statement updating the public on its efforts to tackle insufficient electricity supplies during the ongoing dry season. Reductions in electricity prices have resulted in a steady increase in consumers in the Kingdom, while local and international investors

  • African swine fever spreads to VN-Cambodia border

    African swine fever has spread to parts of Vietnam that border Cambodia’s Ratanakkiri and Kratie provinces, a Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries official said on Friday. Tan Phannara, the General Directorate of Animal Health and Production director-general, told a Phnom Penh workshop that