Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Disparate charges in bride-trafficking case

Disparate charges in bride-trafficking case

Khim Chantrea, 23, one of four accused of trafficking brides to China, is escorted by officials after his hearing earlier this month at the Phnom Penh Municipal Court.
Khim Chantrea, 23, one of four accused of trafficking brides to China, is escorted by officials after his hearing earlier this month at the Phnom Penh Municipal Court. Niem Chheng

Disparate charges in bride-trafficking case

Four people accused of attempting to traffic Cambodian women into China’s bridal trade were given disparate sentences in a verdict handed down on Friday, which could see three of the perpetrators released as early as next month.

Judge Y Thavrak sentenced Chan Sokhim, the mastermind behind the elaborate scheme – which involved the false promise of work in Singapore, smuggling women into Vietnam and a trip to Myanmar to obtain visas for China – to 10 years in prison. She was charged with “unlawful recruitment for exploitation”.

The sentence for Sokhim, who was on bail as she recently gave birth, was much more severe than that of her co-conspirators – Khim Chantrea and his mother, Bun Huor, and his aunt, Bun Sim.

The latter three were handed the minimum sentence of two years, with one year suspended, for their role in illegally crossing into Vietnam and entrapping the women. They were each fined 4 million riel (roughly $1,000).

The three were arrested in July last year and have almost served their one-year sentence for “receipt of a person for assisting the offender”.

Two of the victims, sisters Kean Nay and Kean Nee, said they, along with their sister and another woman, had been promised jobs in Singapore for $500 per month.

They only escaped after they failed to obtain visas for China in Myanmar. Upon their return to Vietnam, they encountered a woman who gave them money to flee and distracted their traffickers.

Sorn Kinal, defence lawyer for Chantrea and his relatives, insisted his clients were merely “helpers”.

“If the victims said my clients kidnapped them or exploited them illegally, why didn’t they run away in Myanmar and call police for help?” he said.

“I requested the court to lift the charge from them. They went to visit Myanmar and . . . just helped [the victims] fill out the form and took care of them and is that punishable? Let the law decide, let the court decide.”

Throughout the proceedings, prosecutor Che Song, was tough on the victims, warning them not to lie and saying there was “no evidence or witness against the accused”.

Touch Sarith, lawyer for Sokhim, and Ouk Sinaketh, a lawyer for the victims, yesterday claimed they did not know Friday’s verdict.

MOST VIEWED

  • Chinese-owned shops are on the rise in central Phnom Penh

    Informal businesses owned by Chinese nationals are on the rise in central Phnom Penh, especially in Tonle Bassac commune, surrounding Koh Pich. Such businesses have sprung up notably in Central Market, Orussey Market, Sovanna Shopping Mall, Rattana Plaza, as well as Kakab commune across from

  • Breaking: Eighty-three containers of waste at S'ville port came from US, Canada

    The plastic waste found in 83 containers at Sihanoukville Autonomous Port on Tuesday came from the US and Canada, the Ministry of Environment has said. The huge shipment of rubbish weighs some 1,600 tonnes. Officials are continuing their investigation to find the company or individuals responsible for

  • ‘Long road for Cambodia bill to reach the White House’

    Analysts have questioned whether the “The Cambodia Democracy Act of 2019” bill would be passed by the US Senate and finally signed off by the president after its approval by the lower chamber, the House of Representatives, on Monday. Introduced by Republican Representative for Florida Ted

  • Two men arrested for stealing $2M

    Two men were arrested on Friday accused of stealing $2 million from a company after their employer sent them to withdraw the cash in Phnom Penh. Phnom Penh municipal police chief Sar Thet said on Sunday that the suspects were 37 years old and one was a