W HILE alleged sex tourists to Asia are increasingly targeted for prosecution in their
home countries, those who are arrested in Cambodia are likely to meet a lenient fate.
Two foreigners arrested in March, and later convicted for having sex with children,
quietly left Cambodia in recent months after serving what one policeman called "abnormally
soft sentences" by the Phnom Penh Municipal Court.
French photographer Amedee Hennion, 54, and Canadian Manfred Albert Horst, 50, a
Bangkok resident who visited Cambodia frequently, were both arrested in Phnom Penh
in early March.
The arrests were made by Cambodian Interpol officers amid great media hoopla - with
Hennion and two of his young accusers paraded in front of journalists at press conferences
- in what police described as "a warning" to other pedophiles.
A local NGO providing shelter to street children tipped police off about the two
men, Interpol officers said, after several 12- to 14-year-old boys said the men paid
them $2 to $3 for sex.
Two photo albums of young children were found at Hennion's residence, as were 31
explicit pictures of nude boys in Horst's room at a guesthouse. The photographs were
displayed to reporters.
The municipal court sentenced Horst to four months in July, and Hennion to five months
in prison in August, under a law introduced during the United Nations' UNTAC mission
to Cambodia, according to Yim Po, director of the Cambodian Center for the Protection
of Children's Rights.
Both men were also put on two years' probation, he said.
Police and child rights officers have cried foul, saying the UNTAC-era law requiring
sentences of six months to two years in prison, is a far cry from the 10-year minimum
sentences mandated by the law on human trafficking passed by the National Assembly
last year.
A senior officer at the municipal police bureau for foreigners, who asked not to
be identified, said: "The sentence should have been 10 years and not four and
five months,"
"The sentence depended on the justice [system] and in Cambodia the justice system
is not good. It depends on money. The police are very disappointed," he said.
"Four children testified against Horst and said that other children had been
used [for oral and anal sex]. In the case of Hennion, four children aged 12 to 16
testified but for oral sex only."
Yim Po said that poverty made the children easy victims: "These children need
money and they are willing to be used because they need to survive. "
He agreed that Horst and Hennion had received lenient sentences. "According
to the law, anyone who commits sexual acts on children under 15, even if they consent,
should face a prison sentence of 10 to 20 years."
Horst left Cambodia several weeks after he was freed in July, officials said.
Hennion was freed three days after being sentenced as he had already served four
months and 27 days, officials added, noting that he left for France a week later.
The municipal police officer speculated that Hennion may have received a harsher
sentence than Horst - who was accused of the more serious crime of paying for anal
sex - because the French Embassy followed the case very closely and even would have
preferred to have him judged in France.
French Consul Jacques Le Jeune visited police to claim Hennion's photo albums and
his case file in order to forward them to French authorities, according to the policeman,
who showed the Post an Aug 22 document signed by Le Jeune acknowledging receipt of
them.
Le Jeune, however, said French Embassy involvement in the case was limited to protecting
the physical well-being of a Frenchman, and he denied having the case files.
A friend of Hennion's, meanwhile, lamented violations of the Frenchman's rights while
in prison.
"Hennion was beaten up and sexually abused while in prison. And I can tell you
he always stuck to not paying anybody. The Canadian paid for his release because
he hoped it would help to get a softer sentence, [so] he reached the court a month
before Hennion."
