Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Duch appeals verdict

Duch appeals verdict

Duch appeals verdict

Lawyers for former Tuol Sleng prison chief Kaing Guek Eav have officially lodged an appeal against the verdict handed down by the Khmer Rouge tribunal in July, arguing that his case falls outside the court’s jurisdiction.

Kang Ritheary, one of two Cambodian lawyers representing the infamous jailor, better known as Duch, said the defence team filed its appeal to the KRT’s Supreme Court chamber on Friday.

“We have asked the court to acquit Duch, since [his case] is outside of its jurisdiction,” he said yesterday.

“We did not consider the crimes he committed at Tuol Sleng [to fall into this jurisdiction], because the agreement between the government and the UN is that low-ranking officials like Duch are not those most responsible.”

Kang Ritheary also called for Duch to be released, adding that he could act as a valuable witness in the tribunal’s upcoming second case against four former regime figures.
The full text of the appeal had not been made public as of press time last night.

The agreement between Cambodia and the United Nations that established the tribunal limits prosecutions to “senior leaders of Democratic Kampuchea” and those deemed “most responsible” for crimes committed under the regime.

In its July 26 verdict, the court found Duch guilty of crimes against humanity and grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, sentencing him to 30 years in prison.

Duch’s legal team made little mention of the jurisdictional issue during hearings last year before closing arguments, when defence lawyer Kar Savuth abandoned his team’s strategy of pushing for a lenient sentence and instead argued that the court had no right to try Duch in the first place.

Long Panhavuth, a project officer at the Cambodia Justice Initiative, said the jurisdictional issue had already been settled by the court’s Pre-Trial Chamber and that the appeal had little chance of success.

He said that Duch, who oversaw the deaths of as many as 16,000 people at S-21, was undoubtedly one of those most responsible for the crimes of the Khmer Rouge.

“I would say the whole [trial] process has been credible,” he said. “This is an attempt to prolong the case.”

Last month, prosecutors also filed an appeal against the sentence, seeking a 45-year prison term without parole for Duch and claiming that the 30-year sentence he received, which amounted to just 19 years after the deduction of time already served, was “plainly unjust”.

In their 66-page appeal, the prosecutors asked that Duch receive a life sentence that would then be commuted to 45 years due to his unlawful pretrial detention.

In an earlier statement, they said the sentence handed down on July 26 was “arbitrary and manifestly inadequate” and gave undue weight to mitigating circumstances, such as Duch’s expressions of remorse during the trial and his cooperation with the court.

Court spokesman Lars Olsen said that the court’s Supreme Court chamber had not yet scheduled a hearing for either appeal.

According to the court’s rules, Olsen said, appeal hearings are generally public, though there are cases in which the Supreme Court can rule otherwise.

Four other ageing senior leaders of the Khmer Rouge – Brother Number 2 Nuon Chea, former head of state Khieu Samphan, former foreign minister Ieng Sary and his wife, former social affairs minister Ieng Thirith – are in detention at the hybrid court.

MOST VIEWED

  • PM orders immediate action against ‘sexy’ live streamers

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Monday ordered immediate action against women who live stream their sales pitches on Facebook wearing revealing clothing. The prime minister said the practice erodes traditional Cambodian values and disgraces women. Hun Sen gave the order to officials attending the Cambodian

  • Trump tweets praise for Kingdom docking ship

    Cambodia continues to earn praise for its humanitarian act of allowing the MS Westerdam cruise ship with more than 2,200 passengers and crew on board to dock at the Preah Sihanouk port. The praise this time comes from none other than US President Donald Trump. “Thank

  • Tourist area greenlit in Sihanoukville

    The National Committee for Coastal Management and Development will coordinate with relevant ministries over the establishment of a billion-dollar tourist area named Neak Reach in Preah Sihanouk province after it was proposed by the Ministry of Tourism. The Ministry of Land Management, Urban Planning and

  • Hun Sen defends decision to dock Westerdam cruise ship

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Thursday hit back at critics who say he allowed the Westerdam cruise ship to dock in Sihanoukville for political reasons. Speaking at an annual gathering of the Ministry of Interior, Hun Sen said he acted to avert a humanitarian catastrophe

  • Organic vegetable retailer unveils QR code scheme for origin source

    Organic vegetable retailer Natural Agriculture Village has introduced QR codes on its product packaging, which will allow consumers to see where their produce comes from. Natural Agriculture Village president Bun Sieng, who is also a member of local distributor Green Gold, told The Post on

  • Cool heads will defeat Covid-19

    Since Covid-19 was first reported as a world health issue, cruise ships have been the worst to suffer after airlines. The experiences of those who were initially trapped on the Covid-19-stricken Diamond Princess are unimaginable. The cruise ship was rejected from docking at one