Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Government deeds to face CG

Government deeds to face CG

Government deeds to face CG


From accusations of official in volvement in illegal logging, to claims that the

abuse of human rights is a tool of governance in the Kingdom, June ought to have

been a bad month for the Cambodian government.

Prime Minister Hun Sen has made many powerful promises in speeches over the last year. Whether or not the government has managed to live up to them will be put to test on June 19 when the Cambodian Development Cooperation Forum (formerly known as the Consultative Group) meets to discuss progress over 2006 and set benchmarks for the year ahead.

But the government has dealt with the barrage of criticism in a blasé manner.

The in-depth report from UK-based NGO Global Witness released on June 1, was dismissed,

then banned. While the damming assessment of the human rights situation in the Kingdom,

made by UN Special Rapporteur, Yash Ghai, on June 12, was refuted as ill-formed and


With this in mind, experts are wondering what will happen on June 19, when diplomats,

donors, and government officials sit down at their major annual meeting to discuss

the direction of Cambodia's future development trajectory.

"I worry that maybe the time for being firm with the government has passed,"

said one source with extensive experience of donor-government meetings, who requested

anonymity. "I worry that the donor community have missed their opportunity now."

Consultative Group (CG) meetings have been the annual fora at which donors and the

Cambodian government discussed the development of Cambodia, pledged next year's aid,

and set performance benchmarks.

At previous CG meetings, the government regularly failed to fulfill their agreed

benchmarks. But disregarding a decade-long string of broken promises, international

donors pledged $601 million dollars in aid to Cambodia at the 2006 CG meeting.

This year, the event's name and format have changed - from the CG to the Cambodia

Development Cooperation Forum (CDCF) and the Cambodian government has, for the first

time, taken on full responsibility for organizing the event.

Will the CDCF be any different? Will donors "be firm" with the government

and raise difficult questions about illegal logging, land concentration and human

rights, or will broken promises continue to be rewarded with more aid?

"It is a tough question to answer," said Chhith Sam Ath, executive director

of the NGO Forum on Cambodia, which has presented the 2007 NGO statement to the CDFC.

"But we must keep trying, we must keep up the debates and dialogue with the


Australia is Cambodia's third-largest donor nation and new ambassador Margaret Adamson

is optimistic about the meeting.

"This will be the first time donors and the Cambodian Govern-ment meet

in the new format of the CDCF which signals Cambodia's desire to increase its management

of the priorities and better coordination of international development assistance,"

she said.

But the track record of achieving results at CG meetings is poor. At the December

2006 CG meeting, World Bank Country Director Ian Porter said discussions had identified

three main areas of improvement which would be monitored in the run up to the next

CG meeting: the passing of an anti-corruption law, enactment of comprehensive judicial

reform and a commitment to natural resource management.

A year on and the anti-corruption law is still languishing in draft form, judicial

reform is progressing at a glacial pace, and the government's management of natural

resources is being lambasted from all sides.

This is unacceptable, said Leng Bunhong, an officer at Cambodian Independent Teachers

Association (CITA).

"Our biggest goal for the CDFC is that the donors will urge the government to

adopt the anti-corruption law as soon as possible," he said. "It is very

important, we need a law to punish people who commit corruption in Cambodia."

This year, NGOs and civil society organizations working in Cambodia have prepared

a statement which identifies three key issues - land, good governance, and human

development - that look very similar to 2006's three main areas of improvement.

"NGOs are in a position to offer constructive input and feedback to the government,

to help them implement their plans and to help them improve the lot of Cambodia's

poorest people," said Sam Ath. "Our statement is asking the government

to look at the impact of rapid economic growth on development - and start questioning

whether the poorest and most disadvantaged are able to access the benefits of this


But the specter of Cambodia's potentially-vast oil revenues haunts the 2007 CDFC

in a way it has not any previous CG meetings. Some experts worry this will make donors

more reluctant to take the government to task.

"Oil revenues may hit soon, and the donors are very conscious of that,"

said the source with experience of donor-government meetings. "They all are

obsessed with it and all see themselves as the key to coordinating it well."

But for others, Cambodia's nascent extractive industry heralds a new chance for constructive

cooperation. "With the prospect of substantial revenues from extractive industries

[donors want to] encourage the Government to put in place the legal, taxation and

policy framework to assist in the management of these revenues for the benefit of

the Cambodian people," said Ambassador Adamson.

A number of companies are now actively exploring Cambodia's off-shore reserves in

the Gulf of Thailand, yet information - for example whether "signatory bonuses"

have already been paid, and if so, how much and to whom - has not been forthcoming.

The secrecy surrounding Cambodia's oil is just one part of a far broader social problem

which the CDFC needs to discuss, said Sam Ath. "Many NGOs are concerned about

the lack of access to information in Cambodia," he said.

"The poor have a right to participate in the development process but to ensure

that they are able to, the government must release information. We just want the

government to consult the people, inform the people, and consider the social, not

just economic, aspects of development."

Donors could help with this, said an attorney working at USAID-funded Community Legal

Education Center (CLEC). For example, current high-profile cases of land-grabbing,

such as that between the villagers of Kong Yu and Kong Thom in Rattanakkiri province,

and Finance Minister Keat Chhun's sister, Keat Chlony, could be raised at the CDFC,

they said.

"This particular case is very important as this is the most prominent of many

other cases of land grabbing currently happening to Cambodia's indigenous people,"

they said. "This is the time that the government could show their position and

take action. It would be a good indication for donors to see if the government is

likely to do what they say they will."


  • No word on state of emergency

    The National Assembly (NA) said it will postpone all unnecessary meetings in line with guidance from the Ministry of Health and the World Health Organisation (WHO) amid the Covid-19 pandemic. However, it did not say when or how it will debate the “state of emergency”

  • Many in limbo as tension heightens

    As the Kingdom restricts travel and prepares for a state of emergency, some foreigners in Cambodia are scrambling for a way home. Foreign embassies in Phnom Penh are making efforts to get their citizens out, but cancelled flights have become common due to the coronavirus

  • State of emergency draft law set for NA

    A draft law aiming to place the Kingdom in a state of emergency amid the Covid-19 pandemic is set for a debate at the National Assembly (NA) after going through the Council of Ministers’ Standing Committee meeting led by Prime Minister Hun Sen on Tuesday.

  • Khmer New Year postponed

    In an effort to halt Covid-19 infections in the Kingdom, Prime Minister Hun Sen has postponed the Khmer New Year celebrations – to be held from April 13 to 16. Instead, he promised to compensate with a five-day holiday at a more suitable time. He told all government

  • NA, Senate set for bill on ‘emergency’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has requested the Senate to convene an extraordinary meeting to review the draft law that aims to put the Kingdom in a state of emergency after the bill reached the National Assembly (NA) on Friday. The draft law, which was approved

  • Hun Sen, ministers, officials donate salaries in virus fight

    Prime Minister Hun Sen and other senior government officials have decided to donate their salaries to the National Committee for Combating Covid-19 in support of the ongoing battle against the coronavirus. Hun Sen announced in an April 1 letter that because the Covid-19 situation in Cambodia