Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - How bribes can outweigh 19 years' residency

How bribes can outweigh 19 years' residency

How bribes can outweigh 19 years' residency

KEO Sovannavuth holds no illusions about her court case next week. She doesn't have

enough money to bribe the judge, so chances are that he will rule against her.

That means that she stands to lose the house she and her children have been living

in for 19 years.

This 40-year-old widow is but one of countless Cambodians struggling to obtain legal

rights to the houses or land they inhabit. Like many others, her case is a story

of forced movement, dubious documents and corrupt court rulings.

But through the years, Sovannavuth has also endured verbal abuse, physical assaults

and intimidation. In October last year, she and her son were even thrown into jail

by their opponent in the dispute.

Her story begins in the chaotic aftermath of the Khmer Rouge regime, when hundreds

of thousands of dislocated Cambodians were searching for a home.

In 1979, Sovannavuth moved into a house on Monivong Boulevard in Phnom Penh. A year

later, the house was expropriated by the state, who needed it for a local police

unit. Sovannavuth was forced to relocate to the ground floor of a neglected building

on Street 63.

Ten years later, she realized that although the state had promised to find a better

house for her, this would be her permanent home. She decided to repair the building

and spent approximately $4,000 renovating and improving the house.

But that's when problems broke out with the family living in the flat on the second

story. The mother of the family, Mrs Uch Yan, complained that Sovannavuth had no

right to repair the building and embarked on a vicious campaign to make her leave

the house.

Though previously a friend and good neighbor, she instructed her son to assault Sovannavuth.

She threw food and household waste into Sovannavuth's yard. And she poured urine

and dirty water down the inside of the walls of the house, so it ran into the downstairs

kitchen and bedrooms.

"She has made it very clear that she wants us to leave the house because she

wants to own it all. She constantly abuses us and demands that we leave our house.

She actually says she does [it] so we will have to leave," Sovannavuth wrote

in a 1992 letter to the UNTAC Civilian Police, asking for help to solve the dispute.

The threats and abuses continued and when intimidation failed to chase Sovannavuth

and her family out of the house, the upstairs neighbors charged that they were the

rightful owners of the whole building. They filed a complaint and asked the court

to sign over ownership of the house to Dr Uch Yan.

In August last year, the Phnom Penh Municipal Court heard the case - a case that

Sovannavuth believes she should have won. For the hearing, she produced legal papers

and statements from Sangkat and Khan authorities to prove that she was the rightful

owner and resident of the property.

There was, however, a problem with the official land title for the house that was

issued during the State of Cambodia times. It didn't divide the building into a ground

floor and a second story flat, even though the house was now practically two separate

units. And the name on the document was the name of Dr Uch Yan's mother, so the Yans

used it as a heavy - though outdated - argument for their ownership.

Sovannavuth suspects that they also used another tool to win the case: money.

"Through my lawyer, I was asked how much money I could afford to pay the judge

who was handling the case. But I am poor. I could only pay the judge $300,"

says Sovannavuth.

The judge took her money, but later it seems the amount Sovannavuth could offer was

not enough to buy her justice.

" Just before the hearing day, I was told by my lawyer that the judge did not

agree to take $300. He wanted $8,000".

"Uch Yan is rich. He is a doctor and has made a lot of money. He had paid the

judge more than I did," says Sovannavuth, who got her money back after she lost

the case.

Now, she is waiting for the appeals court to hear her case. But she is not optimistic

about the outcome.

"I have very little faith that I will win. Everybody, even my lawyer and most

of the court officials, told me that I will lose because I don't have money to bribe

the judge," she says.

On Tuesday next week, Sovannavuth will know if legal documents and testimony of 19

years of residence will win her house back. Or if a simple stash of money is enough

to drive her out of her home.

MOST VIEWED

  • US imposes sanctions on Oknha Pheap and Kun Kim

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation expressed strong dismay on Monday over the designation of Cambodian tycoon Oknha Try Pheap and General Kun Kim under the US’ Global Magnitsky Act. “It is very disturbing when the public figures of a country become the

  • Mother, daughter killed in hotel fire

    The bodies of a mother and daughter were found locked in an embrace after they were killed in a hotel fire in Phnom Penh at around 3:30am on Wednesday at the Phkar Chhouk Tep 2 Hotel and Restaurant in Phsar Doeum Kor commune, in the capital’

  • EBA withdrawal a destruction of EU achievements, PM says

    Prime Minister Hun Sen said the EU’s possible suspension of its Everything But Arms (EBA) agreement amounted to a destruction of its achievements in the Kingdom and the demise of the opposition group. Hun Sen made the remarks while addressing more than 6,700 students during

  • Rights Day forum denied in Sihanoukville

    The Preah Sihanouk provincial administration last Saturday denied the request of land communities for a public location in the province to celebrate International Human Rights Day 2019 as the administration had already held forums to discuss land issues. However, the land community representatives said they would

  • US told to refrain from interfering in Sokha case

    Senior Cambodian officials said on Thursday that the US can monitor Kem Sokha’s trial as it wishes but would not be allowed to interfere in court procedures. The point was made in response to US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s comments on Wednesday

  • Kingdom calls on Japan to increase number of direct flights to Siem Reap, Phnom Penh

    Cambodia is requesting Japan to increase the number of direct flights from Japanese cities and provinces to Phnom Penh and Siem Reap, so as to contribute to increasing cooperation and tourist numbers between the two countries. During the opening ceremony of 3rd Japan Travel Fair