Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Judges' robes a symbol of political intrigue

Judges' robes a symbol of political intrigue

Judges' robes a symbol of political intrigue

I N a cramped, dimly-lit tailor shop on the third-floor of a tenement building near

Psar Thmei, Toch Linara carefully hand-finishes one of the last in a $1,470 order

of long silk robes, colored black, purple and white.

"It is an honor to do this job because my work is appreciated by my clients,"

says the 40-year-old seamstress.

But the robes represent more than Linara's high craft. They could be seen as symbols

of political wrangling over one of the cornerstones of the Kingdom's Constitution

- the judiciary.

Today, 42 new trainee judges will be presented with the robes - called "silks"

- before 14 of them depart for provincial courts around the country.

They all finished a year's training with the Ministry of Justice at the end of 1995.

Since then they have been "drifting"; some have had to drive moto-taxis

and cyclos to make ends meet, said trainee judge Tan Sarong.

The 14 who have jobs - as "trainee judges" at least - are mostly from the

Cambodian People's Party (CPP). The other 28 will have to put their new robes into

their wardrobes for a day sometime in the future. They'll probably go back to their

motos and cyclos.

Officially, none of the 42 can be sworn in as real judges until the Supreme Council

of Magistracy (SCM) is formed. That's where the big problems start.

The SCM - nine members sitting for a five-year term - will hire and discipline judges,

guarantee the independence of the judiciary, and ensure the "good functioning"

of the Kingdom's courts.

King Norodom Sihanouk will be its chairman. Other members will be Minister of Justice

Chem Snguon (CPP), Supreme Court Chief Dith Munty (CPP), Supreme Court General Prosecutor

Hang Somphearith (Funcinpec), Appeal Court Chief Seng Ron (Funcinpec), Appeal Court

General Prosecutor Hang Roraken (CPP), and three other judges to be elected.

Three of this group will also sit on the powerful Constitutional Council - another

independent body yet to be formed - which will review laws passed by the National

Assembly and be the final authority on Constitutional matters.

A legal observer, who would not be named, said the SCM was not expected to be set

up before the 1998 elections because of disagreement within the two major parties.

"If the SCM were set up now it is sure to belong to the Cambodian People's Party

[CPP] because most of the judges and prosecutors are members of the CPP. Funcinpec

has put pressure on the King not to set up the SCM. I am sure if the SCM is not being

set up, it is because of the King", he said.

Other sources said CPP was preventing the SCM's establishment, by refusing to share

its membership with Funcinpec.

Funcinpec has proposed that it nominate three members of the SCM, CPP four and BLDP


CPP, according to a Funcinpec official who wouldn't be identified, is insisting that

it should hold all the seats.

Another highly-placed official said that Justice Minister Snguon was instrumental

in stymieing the SCM's formation.

"Snguon has asked [Second Prime Minister] Hun Sen not to set up the SCM, because

he [Sgnuon] would lose power.

"Once it is set up, all the Minister of Justice would be is one member of the

SCM," he added, noting that the hiring and firing of judges and other duties

would no longer fall exclusively under ministerial control.

Sngoun, when interviewed, expressed his willingness to have the SCM formed soon.

He said he had reported to the King that there were enough members ready and willing

to compose the council and that he was waiting for the King to hold a meeting.

Contributing to the lack of progress in forming the SCM, experts say, is that its

existence would mean that the Constitutional Council would come a step nearer to

being formed. "And no-one seems to want this independent body set up to scrutinize

the Government's decisions and laws," said a Western legal expert.

Uk Vithun, Secretary of State for Justice (Funcinpec), said: "If the Supreme

Council of Magistracy is formed, it must be formed under the image of the independent


"If it is just formed and not independent, and chooses bad judges to be in the

SCM and punishes others, it is useless. It is just the name."

Vithun said the King was waiting for assurances that the SCM would be independent,

and that he was very sad because people complained to him everyday.

Vithun said he hoped the National Assembly and the co-Prime Ministers would soon

announce the formation of the SCM because, without it, it was hard for Cambodians

to get real justice from the court system.

"People complain to the King, the National Assembly, the Prime Ministers, Council

of Ministers and to human rights groups because of unjust convictions.

"People are crying out for justice. [As] Secretary of State of Justice, I see

that some convictions are wrong... but I have no right to interfere," Vithun


Vithun said 90 per cent of judges commit wrongdoings and people had no confidence

in the courts.

He said low salaries and a lack of independence from the executive wing of Government

had lead to court ineffiencies.

Some legal observers, meanwhile, say the court system has worsened, particularly

in the provinces, and corruption is rife.

The head of one human rights group said serious problems existed in Kompong Cham,

where local authorities and foreign companies abused people's land rights; and in

Kampot, where the military is so powerful that, if a court judgement goes against

them, they harass judges. Sometimes they stop court proceedings.

"It is difficult for judges and prosecutors to work against soldiers. It is

difficult for them to charge soldiers," he said.

There are 90 judges and 50 prosecutors working in Cambodia.Some provinces, however,

have only one judge and one prosecutor.

Fourteen of the 42 new judges graduating today have been assigned by Snguon, under

Royal decree, to work as trainees in Phnom Penh, Kampot and Prey Veng. This, Snguon

said, was "just to calm the anxiety of the new judges wanting jobs."

Some of the new judges, keen for work, sent a letter a few months ago to the King

urging that the SCM be formed quickly.

One of the 14 who will go to work as trainee judges, Mong Munychariya, said he would

have no right to decide anything inside the court, but would do whatever the court

director told him to do.

Khuth Sopeang, one of those who signed the letter to the King, said he has been staying

at home for the past year, doing nothing, supported by his parents-in-law.

Sopeang, who formerly worked at the Ministry of Justice for five years, said he gave

up that job when he began the judges' course.

"I don't know what to do because I have no money. Even if I wanted to be a moto-taxi

driver, I have no motorcycle."

However, he said he has no regrets about being jobless. He knows he just has to be

patient and wait for his chance, "because this is the country's internal affairs."

Sopeang, who belongs to no political party, said: "Being a judge, I don't want

to be in any party because I could not find justice for the people."

Another judge, Sarong, a graduate from Russia who currently works at a department

of the Ministry of Justice, said: "If I become a judge, I can find justice for

Cambodian people.

" I want to change the old things. I want to change the society and the country

to implement laws, as so far people have said judges are corrupt and unjust.

"And I want to have good relation with other judges.

"If there is no Supreme Council of Magistracy, it is hard because no one will

punish judges who commit offenses. If there is no SCM I cannot do the job."

The trainees' new silks - paid for by 28 American judges who each donated $35 to

have them made - "will make people more confident with the new judges,"

Sarong said.

"And the people want us to start as soon as possible."

Linara, meanwhile, unaware of the larger issues that lie behind the silk gowns falling

across her old sewing machine, has just been worrying about doing the best job she

can with the complicated French styles.

"It is much more difficult and time consuming than normal sewing. Just one robe

takes two to three days to be done, but I am happy with my work."


  • Massive stingrays may live in Mekong’s deep pools

    US scientists have suggested that unexplored deep pools in the Mekong River in an area of Stung Treng could potentially be home to significant populations of giant freshwater stingrays, one of the world’s largest freshwater fish species. This comes as a fisherman hooked a 180

  • PM takes time to meet, greet Cambodians living in the US

    After landing in the US ahead of the ASEAN-US Special Summit, Prime Minister Hun Sen was received by over 1,000 Cambodian-Americans including political analysts who welcomed him with greetings, fist bumps and selfies. Hun Sen also met with analyst Mak Hoeun, who had allegedly spoken ill

  • PM heads to Washington for ASEAN-US special summit

    Regional and international issues and how to bring the ASEAN-US partnership to another level will be discussed at length as Prime Minister Hun Sen and his ministers arrive in Washington, DC, for a special summit on May 12-13. During the trip, Hun Sen and ASEAN

  • National Assembly refutes EU resolution

    The National Assembly (NA) has hit back at a European Parliament resolution condemning the political and human rights situation in Cambodia, calling it another display of the Parliament’s “double standards”. Key points of the resolution include a warning that the Parliament could exclude the

  • Soaring global fuel prices: an opportunity for Cambodia?

    Cambodia is feeling the squeeze from the soaring global coal and oil prices. Electricity du Cambodge (EDC)would certainly be hurting from this reality, and most likely re-assessing its plans to add more coal power stations. EDC buys half of Cambodia’s electricity from plants

  • PM reflects on shoe throwing: Free speech or act of violence?

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on May 17 questioned whether a man who threw a shoe at him while he was in the US was exercising freedom of expression or if it was an act of hostility. Hun Sen was referring to an incident last week when