Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - King signs KR law, but obstacles loom

King signs KR law, but obstacles loom

King signs KR law, but obstacles loom

KING Norodom Sihanouk wasted no time in signing the Khmer Rouge tribunal law last

week, five years after the defection of former KR foreign minister Ieng Sary. That

event heralded the end of the movement as a political force.

The King's signature paves the way for the trial of those alleged responsible for

torture and killings committed during the 1975-79 Democratic Kampuchea regime.

While the UN, donors and NGOs responded with cautious optimism at the announcement,

some warned that the proposed trial faced a range of obstacles before it gains UN


However, Minister for the Council of Ministers, Sok An, told reporters that the government

wanted to expedite the process and said he expected to meet UN chief legal counsel

Hans Corell in Phnom Penh in September.

"We sent a letter to Corell stating that we have no intention of delaying the

trial. We are waiting on him for discussions on how cooperation should be organized,"

said Sok An.

Prime Minister Hun Sen's advisor, Om Yentieng, highlighted the urgency of arranging

the trial before Ta Mok, a former commander, and Duch, former head of S-21, had to

be released. The men are due to be freed in March and May next year respectively,

when their three-year legal detention period ends.

However analysts said that the men could still be charged with other offenses and

believed the UN would not be pressured by their release dates.

US Ambassador Kent Wiede-mann agreed that the deadline was not a major stumbling


Sok An's meeting with Corell could be delayed, however. Earlier this week Corell

said that agreement on the MoU might have to wait since he was engaged in negotiations

for a similar trial in the African state of Sierra Leone.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Hun Sen, in his first speech on the topic since the King

signed the law, emphasized the limited nature of the prosecutions and said former

KR commanders had nothing to fear from a tribunal.

"Charges will only be brought against the ten or more who were most responsible

during the DK regime. It is not necessary for you to go back to the jungle and protect

your people," the Prime Minister said at a bridge opening ceremony in Pursat

this week.

The UN has a copy of the previous legislation- which contains reference to the death

penalty - but said it would not act until it received an 'official translation' of

the updated law.

"The ball is still in the gov-ernment's court to send a copy of the text,"

said Suriya Dungel of the UN Cambodia Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

The Post understands that the text will not be sent until both the English and French

translations are approved, probably within a few days.

In January, Corell sent a letter to Sok An listing a range of objections to elements

contained in the tribunal law. None of the objections was addressed in the legislation,

and the Cambodian government has repeatedly declared that the law would not be changed.

That leaves negotiations on the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) as the UN's last

avenue to have its concerns addressed. Wiedemann said that the sticking points remained

the same, but said he was confident they would be easily resolved during face-to-face

negotiations between the UN and the government.

"At the time that the UN posed those questions, it said that none of them were

deal breakers," he said. "I take that to mean there were no substantive

issues [and] that they were mostly questions of language."

Among the objections contained in Corell's letter were that the articles failed to

clarify the right of the accused to choose their own legal counsel, as well as ambiguities

regarding the appointment of judges, prosecutors and the tribunal's deputy director.

If an agreement is reached the UN will form a trust fund and seek contributions from

member states to fund the trial. Although the UN has not released any costings for

the trial, analysts said that it would probably be similar to that of the mixed war

crimes tribunal in Sierra Leone, which is expected to cost $56 million over three


Wiedemann said that while the UK, Japan, Australia and others have indicated support

for the trial, agreement between the UN and the government was a likely prerequisite

for substantial international assistance.

Hun Sen, however, has adopted a take it or leave it approach to the UN's participation

in any trial, saying that if agreement could not be reached Cambodia would hold the

trial without the UN's assistance. Wiedemann thought it likely that the UN would

be involved.

"If they did [hold the trial alone] it would not have much credibility. I doubt

that they could," he said.

Prosecution of former KR foreign minister Ieng Sary remains the biggest hurdle to

an agreement. Corell's letter insisted on a paragraph giving the tribunal jurisdiction

to prosecute any person regardless of previous amnesties, a direct reference to Sary.

Wiedemann was confident this would be easily resolved.

"That issue has been dealt with before and I'd speculate that the UN just wants

to make doubly sure that [the commitment] still stands," he said. "Hun

Sen has said numerous times that no tribunal would be truly credible without the

trial of Ieng Sary."

In a statement released this week, British Foreign Office Minister Ben Bradshaw said

his government welcomed the final approval of the legislation.

"The Cambodian government should ensure that [the tribunal] is allowed to operate

as effectively as possible, not least by ensuring that all surviving members of the

Khmer Rouge leadership at last account for their actions," he said.


  • ‘Historic’ Khmer Rouge tribunal Case 002/2 verdict to be delivered

    The Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) are to deliver the verdict on Friday, in the trial of former Khmer Rouge leaders Nuon Chea and Khieu Samphan, in a pronouncement hailed as a “historic event for Cambodia and the world”. The verdict from

  • ‘No more Khmer Rouge leaders left to stand trial’

    Friday's verdict in the trial of former Khmer Rouge leaders Nuon Chea and Khieu Samphan has been hailed as “historic” for “Cambodia and all humanity”, while Minister of Interior Sar Kheng said no further cases of its kind would be brought to court. “There are

  • Hun Sen slams opposition lawyer for ‘incompetence’

    A defence lawyer for the opposition on Wednesday defended their “legalism” after Prime Minister Hun Sen slammed them as “incompetent” and “unqualified”, telling them to listen to and analyse what he said before making statements about a “bet”. Once again on Wednesday Hun Sen spoke

  • Chinese driver attacked after damaging vehicles

    Villagers in Sihanoukville’s Commune 4 on Saturday attacked a Chinese man for causing an accident involving two cars and many motorcycles, while the suspect tried to escape. Preah Sihanouk provincial traffic office director Prom Pov identified the suspect as “Zhear Ming Luy”, 16. The suspect hit