Subscribe Search

Search form

Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Lawyers appeal severance order

Lawyers appeal severance order

Lawyers appeal severance order

KRTalk logo

The prosecution took the Khmer Rouge tribunal Trial Chamber to task in an appeal of the court’s recent decision to re-sever Case 002 filed on May 10, criticising its ruling’s failure to grasp “the fundamental nature or theme” of the case itself.

In failing to add the notorious S-21 detention centre, the new severance order – identical to the old one – “effectively terminates the prosecution of the accused for the most serious charges of the Indictment, including the arrest, detention, torture and execution of hundreds of thousands of Cambodians at the network of security centres across Democratic Kampuchea”, the prosecution said in its filing.

The prosecution went on to criticise the Trial Chamber’s largely time-based rationale for leaving S-21 out, arguing the chamber itself had been found wanting in its time management skills, echoing critiques previously raised by the defence.  

“It was also an error and abuse of discretion to base the exclusion of S-21 on the purported time or delay associated with the trial of that crime site, when the Trial Chamber is failing to make use of all available trial days, as was directed by this Chamber,” the filing reads.

An annex attached to the appeal showed that, since it began, the court only sat an average of 9.5 days per month, despite theoretically being in session four days a week.

In one three-month stretch, from December 2011 through to February 2012, the Trial Chamber devoted 43 days to “judicial recess” and a further nine for document hearings, in which already-approved documents  are read aloud in court.

Michael Karnavas, a former defence lawyer for deceased co-accused Ieng Sary, was also a critic of the court’s trial management, which he characterised as having caused undue delays.  

There were “no meaningful trial management meetings prior to the commencement of the trial,” he said, and the single trial management meeting that was held beforehand was “too little, too late”.

What’s more, Karnavas continued, “there were wasteful procedural hearings from the very start of the trial”, including the document hearings cited by the prosecution.

“So, to get to the point, all the weeks spent on these hearings were unnecessary, causing delays in the taking of evidence,” he added.

Cambodian Justice Initiative program officer Panhavuth Long said that the parties aren’t the only ones upset at the Trial Chamber’s seeming mismanagement of its time.

“The victims are not very happy, looking at the way the Trial Chamber sits on the case,” he said.

According to Panhavuth, who also tracks hearing days, since the trial’s start, “the number of days they sit is less than the days that they spend on vacation”.

“It was not very good, especially when they know . . . the age of the accused,” he said. “The reason they did the severance order was that they wanted faster proceedings, but then they take this vacation.  We are not happy.”


  • Kak Channthy, Cambodian Space Project frontwoman, killed in crash at 38 [Updated]

    Updated 5:05pm, Tuesday, March 20, 2018 Kak Channthy, frontwoman of popular The Cambodian Space Project, was killed Tuesday morning in a traffic accident in Phnom Penh. She was 38. Channthy, the internationally recognised singer-songwriter also known as “Srey Thy”, was reportedly travelling in a tuk-tuk on the city's

  • Australian police investigating death threat against Kem Ley's widow

    Updated: 10:17am, Friday March 23, 2018 Australian authorities on Thursday confirmed they have launched an investigation into a crudely written death threat sent tothe family of slain political analyst Kem Ley and Victoria state MP Hong Lim. The typed letter, reported to Victoria police last week, is

  • Apparel groups including H&M and Gap urge Cambodia garment industry reform, seek meeting with Hun Sen

    A group representing some of the largest apparel brands in the US and Europe – including Gap, H&M and ASOS – expressed “growing concern” on Tuesday over several controversial labour laws and ongoing court cases against unionists described as restrictive and unjust. In an open letter

  • Cambodia, states clash at UN session

    Cambodia traded shots with the international community in a heated exchange at the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva on Thursday evening, with states condemning the Kingdom’s ongoing crackdown on the political opposition and civil society, and an increasingly agitated Cambodia accusing member states