Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Lawyers fire back at Nuon Chea defence

Lawyers fire back at Nuon Chea defence

Lawyers fire back at Nuon Chea defence

The prosecution at the Khmer Rouge tribunal has issued a response a motion by the Nuon Chea defence team to disqualify the current trial chamber judges on grounds of bias, saying the motion is founded on shoddy reasoning, and should be “dismissed outright”.

In their original filing, the defence argued, among other things, that the court’s refusal to summons National Assembly President Heng Samrin; the chamber’s seemingly dismissive attitude towards defence positions; and Cambodian judges’ purported inability to separate the case from their own experiences under the Khmer Rouge amounted to an unmistakable appearance of bias.

The prosecution, however, argued in Friday’s filing that many of the Chea defence’s allegations were a “mischaracterisation of facts and misapplication of law”.

“The Application is simply another volley in Nuon Chea’s longstanding and illegitimate strategy to undermine the [Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia] as an institution rather than confront the overwhelming evidence of his criminal responsibility,” the filing reads.

Much of the defence’s allegations of national judges’ bias are drawn from remarks given by ex-judge Silvia Cartwright, who said at least two judges on the bench were victims of crimes up for consideration in the upcoming Case 002/02, and that Cambodian judges could often be heard making disapproving utterances in court.

However, the prosecution argues, the substance of Cartwright’s remarks “merely reflected her personal speculation”, given that specific crime sites – and the specific judges themselves – have not been identified.

Court legal communications officer Lars Olsen said yesterday that since the matter was currently under judgment, he was unable to comment as to whether an investigation into Cartwright’s remarks was under way.


  • Serious flooding across country

    The Kampong Speu provincial Committee for Disaster Management on Wednesday issued an alert after non-stop heavy rain caused widespread flooding. In Koh Kong province, authorities are working with the disaster committee and the Cambodian Red Cross to assist those affected after more than 350 homes were

  • CNRP points to King in call for vote boycott

    Leaders of the former Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP) have taken a new tack in their call for a boycott of the national elections later this month. They are now claiming that the people should follow the King, who is expected to abide by tradition

  • Malaysian MP calls on his government to take stand on Cambodian elections

    A Malaysian parliamentarian raised concerns in his country on Wednesday about Cambodia’s July 29 national elections and urged his government to clarify its position on the subject, the Asean Parliamentarians for Human Rights (APHR) said on Thursday. Wong Chen, a member of the People’s

  • Troop moves ‘won’t worry people’

    Senior officials at the Ministry of Defence and National Police said on Tuesday that riot training provided to the country’s police forces were aimed at preventing unexpected demonstrations and strikes before and after the July 29 national elections. The troop mobilisation, they said, would not