Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Lesbians struggle to change perceptions

Lesbians struggle to change perceptions

Lesbians struggle to change perceptions


Sou Sotheavy . . . says the Cambodian Women's Union has won recognition for sex workers. If lesbians are similarly determined they will likewise be rewarded, but it will take a lot of work to build the support necessary to bring about change.

Pon Samnang has close-cropped hair and a face devoid of make up. Oversized men's

clothes hang loosely from her slight frame, but her lips are full and her cheek bones

high. Her androgynous beauty demands attention.

Samnang, 25, was just four years old when she realized she was a lesbian. She has

been grappling with the social implications of her sexual orientation ever since.

Her parents, who are farmers, were devastated when she first came out. Blaming her

for bringing them bad luck, they pleaded with her to change her behavior. But as

the years passed they have gradually grown to accept her as she is.

For Keo Samet, 26, parents have never been a problem - hers always knew she was a

lesbian and have loved and supported her all her life. But her siblings were initially

opposed to her sexuality.

"At first my brother and sister didn't like me being a lesbian," she explained.

"But we have talked about it a great deal and they now understand and love me."

By day Sien Vanna, 24, fixes air-conditioning units, by night she sells sex to wealthy

foreign and Khmer women. Her $280 monthly income goes towards supporting her parents

and her many girlfriends in Phnom Penh.

"After work I come home, shower, eat and then go out to meet my customers,"

she said. "My parents don't criticize me for anything - we have a very good

relationship. I worry more about my girlfriends - I know some of them are using drugs."

Samnang has just broken up with her long-term girlfriend. Now, she is trying to spend

all her time with men in an attempt to mend her broken heart. She is helped by her

job as a mechanic which keeps her in a male-dominated environment.

"I only spend time with men," she said. "If I spend time with women,

I will fall in love again. I work as a mechanic. I am the only woman working in the

garage. I am treated like one of the boys."

Social discrimination has been a hard fact of life for all these women. Consequently,

with the help of the Cambodian Women for Unity (CWU) organization, they have formed

Cambodia's first lesbian rights group. The Post attended the group's inaugural meeting

on March 17.

Being a lesbian can be difficult, Samet said. But she has an impressive self-belief

that allows her to take the sting from her fellow garment workers' comments.

"When people in the factory know I am a lesbian they sometimes discriminate

against me - both openly and secretly," she said. "But this is my character;

it is natural, and I can't change. Discrimination doesn't upset me now at all."

The precept "Turn the other cheek" proved true for Samnang: the mocking

of her peers gradually subsided as she refused to let it rile her.

"In my village I used to experience discrimination, but I just ignored it,"

she said. "I have always ignored people talking about me and gradually they


For Vanna, the gossiping of her friends over her sexual orientation has been a help

rather than hindrance: the majority of her wealthy clients hear of her by word of


"My foreign clients are mainly French and American women; my Khmer clients are

the children of the rich and powerful," she explains. "Everyone who knows

me knows my character - they know I like women and don't sleep with men. People hear

about my character and come to find me."

But while Vanna, Samnang and Samet have not allowed the widespread and institutionalized

discrimination encountered by lesbians in Cambodia to prevent them living as they

wish, there is one hurdle they still face - legal marriage.

While it is possible for two women to marry - Cambodia's first lesbian marriage happened

in 1995 - it is a complex process and the couples are currently sure to encounter

considerable difficulty in obtaining the official trappings of marriage - certificates,

documents, forms - necessary to make the union fully legal.

"The Cambodian marriage law only specifies that a man must be 20 and a woman

18 years old prior to marriage," said Sakheun Sabady, deputy director of legal

protection at the Ministry of Women's Affairs. "It does not mention whether

men can marry men or women can marry women - it just doesn't say. Nor does the Constitution."

But although lesbian marriage remains legally adrift, Sabady believes that with enough

popular support the system could mature, as it has in several Western countries.

"If there are many same-sex couples who protest and assert their right to get

married, then there will be change in this society which could lead to a Constitutional

amendment, "she said.

For some traditional Cambodian women, a good marriage and the subsequent child-bearing

cycle are the pinnacle of life's achievements.

"Most people say we destroy our future - we were born daughters so the achievement

of our lives should be our marriage," Samet said. "We don't want this,

we don't want marriage and children - so we are [perceived as] destroying our future.

But while Cambodia's lesbians defy the social norm in eschewing offers of husbands,

they are still looking for life partners and for the right to have their relationships

accorded the status of marriage should they wish.

"We are real people and this should be recognized," Samet said. "We

must struggle for social recognition, and then women could marry women."

Although she has had an excellent relationship with her fiancee for a number of years,

Keo Samet says they will not be getting married soon.

"Although my parents support my marriage, we will not wed. Firstly, we don't

have enough money to get married. But secondly, I am worried about the law."

Despite their personal success in preventing discrimination impinging on their daily

lives, Vanna, Samnang and Samet all recognize that the bigger battle for social and

legal recognition requires broader support.

"When we set up this organization we wanted to help sex workers," said

Sou Sotheavy, a transgendered sex worker who was born male but lives as a woman,

and works for CWU. "We may not be able to cure AIDs but we have helped sex workers

a lot. They are now recognized in society and feel able to assert their rights."

She argues that the past few years have seen an improvement in social perceptions

of sex workers.

"We have fought for our rights and now attitudes are changing," she said.

"People don't call us prostitutes any more, but sex workers."

Sotheavy says if lesbians are similarly determined they will be rewarded, but it

will take a lot of work to build the support necessary to bring about change.

"If we want to change the law we need a lot of support - we have to work together

to change social discrimination."

At a personal level Samnang has been successful in fighting discrimination, but she

believes that a change in the law will help lesbians in Cambodia in the future.

"I have never felt unable to do anything because of my sexuality, except to

marry my partner. I think that discrimination against lesbians would decrease if

the law were changed and we were given social and legal recognition. If the law were

to change then I would have a traditional Cambodian wedding with my girlfriend."


  • Thousands attend CNRP-organised pro-democracy vigil in South Korea

    Thousands of supporters of the Supreme Court-dissolved Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP) on Saturday gathered in the South Korean city of Gwangju to hold a candlelight demonstration calling for the “liberation” of democracy in Cambodia. Yim Sinorn, a CNRP member in South Korea, said on

  • US Embassy: Chinese trade does not help like the West’s

    The US Embassy in Phnom Penh on Friday said relations between China and Cambodia did not create jobs or help industry when compared to the trade between the Kingdom and the US. “About 87 per cent of trade [with China] are Chinese imports, which do not

  • Vietnamese land-grabbers held

    Following a provincial court order, Ratanakkiri Military Police on April 16 arrested 12 Vietnamese nationals accused of crossing the border into Cambodia and illegally clearing forest land. The accused are now being detained at Phnom Svay prison in the province. Ratanakkiri military police commander Thav Yen told

  • Eight people sent to court over violent protest

    Preah Sihanouk provincial authorities on Sunday sent eight people to court for blocking National Road 4 and using violence against authorities in a land dispute in Prey Nop district’s Bit Traing commune. Four police officers and two commune security guards sustained injuries when the protesters