Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Long road to day of reckoning

Long road to day of reckoning

Long road to day of reckoning

On Monday morning, hundreds of journalists, diplomats, government officials and Khmer Rouge-era survivors will descend on Cambodia’s war crimes tribunal in Phnom Penh for the historic verdict in its first case, that of Tuol Sleng prison chief Kaing Guek Eav, alias Duch.

United Nations court spokesman Lars Olsen said all major TV and radio stations in Cambodia would be broadcasting the event live, with more than 300 media representatives from around the world scheduled to attend. So what is it listeners and viewers can expect when they tune in?

Proceedings at the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia are scheduled to begin at 10am, and Olsen said the session was not expected to extend “beyond lunchtime”. Trial Chamber President Nil Nonn is scheduled to read out a summary of the judgment, and Olsen said it was “not foreseen that the format of the hearing will allow various parties to speak”.

This means that unless judges grant Duch a special request to speak, he will not be heard before the Trial Chamber on Monday.

Anne Heindel, a legal adviser with the Documentation Centre of Cambodia, said that after presenting an analysis of the case and of the charges Duch faces under domestic and international law, Nil Nonn would then likely devote “some significant time explaining how they arrived at the sentence” before finally announcing the sentence itself.

Under the Cambodia-UN agreement, suspects at the ECCC may be liable both for offences in the 1956 Cambodian penal code and those that existed under international law at the time under investigation. The court’s prosecutors, judges and defence teams comprise both international and Cambodian lawyers. ECCC/POOL

In March, after procedural hearings, the court convened for opening statements and the first days of “substantive” hearings. Duch apologised when given the chance to speak, saying he was “responsible for the crimes committed” and felt “deep regret and heartfelt sorrow”. AFP

Some of the few survivors of Tuol Sleng, including Bou Meng, Vann Nath and Chum Mey (left), delivered wrenching testimony about their experiences at the prison. Family members of those killed at Tuol Sleng also appeared, demanding answers from Duch about the fate of their loved ones.

Surviving Tuol Sleng staff members, including guard Him Huy and chief interrogator Mam Nai (right), also testified, describing the inner workings of Duch’s prison. In total, 55 people testified before the Trial Chamber: 17 fact witnesses, 9 expert witnesses, 7 character witnesses and 22 civil parties.

On July 9, the court announced that Duch had dismissed his international co-lawyer, Francois Roux (left). Observers said the dismissal, which followed Duch and Kar Savuth’s dramatic split from Roux during closing arguments, suggested a plan to appeal in the event of a guilty verdict.

In the event of a guilty verdict – which appears inevitable – Duch “would eventually be handed over to the Cambodian authorities”, Olsen said.
“If he is convicted, he will stay at the ECCC detention centre until there has been a finalised agreement between the ECCC, represented by the prosecutors, and the Cambodian authorities,” Olsen said. The detention centre itself, he added, was under the control of the Ministry of Interior, with the ECCC covering only the cost of food.

Parties to the case have 30 days from Monday’s verdict to give notice if they wish to file appeals to the tribunal’s Supreme Court Chamber. If they choose to do this, they will be granted an additional 60 days to file the appeals.

Civil parties can appeal against a ruling on reparations only if the prosecution chooses to challenge the judgment. A decision on reparations may accompany a guilty verdict, though it is not yet clear what forms such reparations might take.

Because there is no death penalty under Cambodian law, Duch faces a maximum sentence of life in prison. During closing arguments, prosecutors requested a 40-year sentence, citing as mitigating factors the five years of unlawful detention Duch spent in a military court following his arrest in 1999, and his “general cooperation, limited acceptance of responsibility, his conditional remorse and the possible effect it may have on national reconciliation”.

Their request, however, was delivered before Duch’s surprise bid for an acquittal during closing arguments. The stunning turnabout, a departure from the defence team’s strategy throughout the trial, “should aggravate his sentence”, international co-prosecutor Andrew Cayley said in May.

Chum Mey, 78, and Bou Meng, 69, both Tuol Sleng survivors who testified tearfully before the court in June, said that although they understood the court would be considering mitigating circumstances, they hoped to see Duch receive life imprisonment nonetheless.

“The international prosecutor requested that the chamber give Duch a 40-year sentence,” Chum Mey said. “This is the law, and the court even has the right to punish Duch for only five or 10 years, but our hope is to see Duch face life imprisonment.”

During closing arguments in November, Duch and his Cambodian co-lawyer, Kar Savuth, broke from the defence team’s established strategy of emphasising Duch’s contrition and cooperation in pushing for a mitigated sentence; instead, they called for his acquittal and release. The split shocked observers, and led many to question the honesty of Duch’s earlier claims of remorse.


  • Prince injured, wife dies after accident

    THE wife of former First Prime Minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh, Ouk Phalla, 39, died while the prince was “severely” injured following a road accident in Preah Sihanouk province’s Prey Nub district on Sunday morning, officials said. Rananriddh, who is also the president of the Funcinpec

  • Bun Heang mocks US, threatens its citizens in scathing open letter

    After being hit with sanctions from the US Department of Treasury, Cambodian General Hing Bun Heang said he would retaliate against any US national who does not respect his country’s sovereignty, has ambitions to invade Cambodia or incites “traitors” in the Kingdom to do

  • Police warn boycott FB group involved in the “Clean Fingers Campaign”

    Police said on Tuesday that they will pick up members of a Facebook group involved in the “Clean Fingers Campaign” that promotes a boycott of next month’s national elections. However, police merely planned to “educate” the group for now, but warned that if the

  • Ranariddh 'seriously injured', his wife dies in accident in Preah Sihanouk

    THE wife of former first prime minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh has died. Ouk Phalla succumbed to injuries sustained in a traffic accident on National Road 4 in Preah Sihanouk’s Prey Nub district this morning. She and the prince were immediately rushed to the Preah Sihanouk