Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - The Montagnards - a 70-year saga of betrayal

The Montagnards - a 70-year saga of betrayal

The Montagnards - a 70-year saga of betrayal

Montagnard refugees shelter under canvas in Mondulkiri.

Y Dlang Ebhar is a nationalist without a nation. A Montagnard tribesman from a village

in Vietnam's DacLac province, he is one of the latest in a decades-long tradition

of Montagnards who have sought shelter in Cambodia.

Y Dlang's present home is a makeshift tent he shares with six other family members.

Under the protection of the UNHCR for the last month, he waits in Mondolkiri with

over 170 other Montagnards in a cluster of temporary shelters for someone else to

decide his fate.

Meanwhile he has time to talk about his problems - it is something he has been waiting

to do for a long time.

"Inside Vietnam we cannot talk about our problems, to journalists, to UNHCR,"

he said.

The Montagnards, as the French dubbed the various tribes who inhabit the western

mountains of central Vietnam, have seen their ancestral lands transformed first by

war, and then by a massive influx of outsiders. He is one of many tribespeople who

protested what they say is systematic abuse at the hands of the Vietnamese government

earlier this year. He says his reward has been more systematic abuse.

He says that after he took part in protests in Dac Lac province, the police came

for him, visiting his house after midnight, five nights in a row. Those five nights

he spent hiding in some land he was farming several kilometers away. After the last

visit he gathered his family and headed for Cambodia.

Y Dlang Ebhar is a Rhade, a member of a tribe that speaks a Malayo-polynesian language.

According to Dr. Gerald Hickey, an American ethnologist who spent years studying

tribal cultures of the Central Highlands, the Rhade are thought to have originated

as an island people, and that their folklore contains legends of arriving on the

mainland by boat.

Y Dlang knows these stories only vaguely. Tribal traditions - he says his village

has not held a

ceremonial dance in 10 years - are not cherished by local authorities. "The

Vietnamese say we have no history," he said.

"Well, that's not true," Hickey counters. "The Vietnamese have always

put them down."

Hickey says that this racial prejudice drives a Vietnamese government program of

assimilation which has done more harm to Montagnard culture than the decades of war

that proceeded it.

Montagnard rights groups detail a host of abuses against their people in Vietnam

including the

expropriation of Montagnard land, massive resettlement of ethnic Vietnamese in the

Highlands, destruction of their culture, and repression of religion, especially directed

at Christian tribespeople.

Protests by Montagnards demanding better treatment swept through the Central Highlands

in early February. Many accounts say that the resulting crackdown by Vietnamese authorities

has been harsh, and drew condemnation from Amnesty International and Human Rights


Hickey said that similar demonstrations had occurred in the Dac Lac capital of Buon

Me Thuot in 1958 over much the same issues. "[The South Vietnamese government]

responded in the same way, by sending in tanks and crack troops," he recalled.

"From what I understand the government today has done pretty much the same thing."

The refugees in Mondolkiri say that in the wake of the unrest, large numbers of troops

and police have been deployed in the Central Highlands, and movements of tribal people

are being watched and tightly restricted.

Y Dlang Ebhar says he left Vietnam not to find a new home, but to work for the independence

of his native land. "Ho Chi Minh promised this for us, for Montagnard people,"

he said. "Do you know that?"

He was not exaggerating. The Indochinese Communist Party, formed by Ho Chi Minh in

1930, proclaimed minorities would have the right to "self-determination"

in an independent Indochina the same year.

While the Vietnamese communists would declare "autonomous zones" for tribespeople

in both the north and the south in the 1950s and '60s, Hickey said it was the French

colonists who went the farthest in actually providing a measure of autonomy for the

Montagnards. Ethnic Vietnamese were barred from settling in the Central Highlands,

and the standard colonial bureaucracy was replaced in part by institutions such as

courts which were run following tribal custom.

The departure of the French saw these measures replaced by the imposition of South

Vietnamese law in the Central Highlands, and hastily-planned migration schemes helped

to create the unrest which led to the demonstrations in 1958. But ironically, the

Vietnam War breathed new life into Montagnard nationalism.

From 1960 the American Special Forces and CIA started a program to arm and train

the jungle-savvy tribesmen, forming militia units to fight communist guerillas. By

1964, 40,000 Montagnards had been recruited.

In September of that year a revolt broke out among Montagnards in five Special Forces

camps who had formed the nationalist organization United Front for the Struggle of

the Oppressed Races, or FULRO by its French acronym. The revolt, carried out to demand

political autonomy from the Vietnamese and the right to a standing army among other

things, was quelled by the American military, who convinced the Saigon government

to institute various reforms in favor of the Montagnards.

FULRO remained dormant as long as American troops remained in the Central Highlands,

but the organization's leader, Y B'ham Enuol, set up a headquarters in Mondolkiri

province and went to Phnom Penh, where he enjoyed a measure of sponsorship from then-Prince


"He was being kind of used by Sihanouk as an anti-American figure" at a

time when US-Cambodian relations were severely strained, Gerald Hickey said. He says

the Prince saw good propaganda value in expressing solidarity with indigenous movements

opposed to South Vietnam.

"He showed up in some of the magazines that Sihanouk was putting out."

Hickey said that when he traveled to Phnom Penh shortly after Sihanouk was deposed

in 1970, he found his former FULRO contacts there wearing Lon Nol uniforms. Most

significantly, a Cham colonel named Les Kasem, whom he'd recognized from the 1964

uprising in Vietnam, was in charge. FULRO leader Y B'ham Enuol was under house arrest.

"[The Cambodians] said that he was going to destroy the FULRO movement,"

Hickey says.

"You had some of the young FULRO who were trying to move in and take over. I've

heard people say, 'we don't have unity among the Montagnards who are in North Carolina,'

and I said, 'well, they didn't have unity in Vietnam, either'."

Hickey says that the FULRO lead-ership's decision to remain in Cambodia helped

in the splintering of the organization as the Americans withdrew and FULRO saw a

resurgence. Ironically, he points out, one of these splinter groups made a deal with

the North Vietnamese to not alert Saigonese forces that communist tanks were approaching

Buon Me Thuot in March 1975. The capture of that town was the first thrust in the

"Ho Chi Minh Campaign" which precipitated the collapse of South Vietnam

only six weeks later.

FULRO negotiates a "ceasefire" with UNTAC in August, 1992.

When Phnom Penh fell to the Khmer Rouge on April 17, Y B'ham Enuol and his family,

as well as several other FULRO members, sought shelter in the French Embassy.


"They were all taken out," Hickey says, and taken to the Olympic Stadium

and executed there.

However, FULRO's relations with this latest Cambodian regime were only beginning.

As Vietnam was reunited, the communists quietly abolished autonomy for minorities.

The Central Highlands became the target area for the establishment of "New Economic

Zones", the first step in a program to resettle millions of ethnic Vietnamese

in the mountains.

FULRO managed to gather 10,000 fighters to wage a resistance campaign against Hanoi.

The Khmer Rouge and FULRO joined in an uneasy alliance against their common Vietnamese

enemy. By supplying the Montagnard insurgents, the Khmer Rouge had a client keeping

the Vietnamese military preoccupied in the highlands, while their own attacks on

Vietnamese border towns intensified.

During the years of Khmer Rouge rule FULRO cadres were lured to Phnom Penh and died

in Tuol Sleng; despite this, both sides kept up an appearance of co-operation, signing

an agreement for the exchange of information and training in 1977.

In 1978 a FULRO cadre appeared on Radio Phnom Penh, denouncing Ho Chi Minh as a fascist.

The tide turned against FULRO by 1979, however an intensive campaign by the Vietnamese

had reduced their number of fighters to only 2000, and their Khmer Rouge ally was

toppled and fled towards Thailand. The remaining FULRO troops were forced to seek

sanctuary in Cambodia once again.

The Montagnard group fell out of favor with the Khmer Rouge in 1986, a Khmer Rouge

official told journalist Nate Thayer in 1992.

"They had no political vision," the official was quoted as saying. "Their

fighters are very, very brave, but they had no support from any leadership, no food,

and they did not understand at all the world around them."

Only a few remnants of the force emerged from the forest. In 1986, 220 survived a

journey across

Cambodia and wound up in a refugee camp in Thailand before being resettled in the


Six years later, another group of 398 Montagnards - fighters and their families -

surfaced in Mondolkiri province and contacted UNTAC peacekeeping troops. They demanded

to speak with their long-dead leader Y B'ham Enuol.

"I told them he was dead," recalls Thayer, who was among the first outsiders

to make contact with them. "They were shocked and did not believe me. Some broke

into tears."

Contact with former comrades from the US convinced them to surrender and they too

were resettled in the US.

While the dream of continuing armed resistance was difficult for that last band of

fighters to give up, younger Montagnards like Y Dlang Ebhar say they are too well

aware of logistical realities to entertain such notions.

"Not enough food, not enough guns; we have only hands, Y Dlang said. "The

Vietnamese have all the guns to kill us - how can we fight?"

Like the idea of armed revolt, the FULRO name is also dead, Y Dlang claimed. "Now

we have a new name: 'Dega'."

"Dega" is a combination of Rhade words which means "son of the mountains",

and is used to describe the Montagnard peoples collectively, their homelands, and

the organization which carries on their struggle.

"We are members of Montagnard group but we fight by politics - we have no guns,

but we fight."


  • Cambodia unveils new quarantine regulations

    The government has modified Covid-19 quarantine requirements, shortening the duration for, among others, Cambodian officials, foreign diplomats and delegations, investors and inbound travellers in general. According to an official notice signed by Minister of Health Mam Bun Heng late on October 16, quarantine length for Cambodian

  • Cambodia sets new Covid-19 quarantine rules

    The government has modified Covid-19 quarantine requirements, shortening the duration for, among others, Cambodian officials, foreign diplomats and delegations, investors and inbound travellers in general. According to an official notice signed by Minister of Health Mam Bun Heng late on October 16, quarantine length for Cambodian

  • Hun Sen: Cambodia set to fully reopen

    Prime Minister Hun Sen concludes that the October 5-7 Pchum Ben public holiday, during which many people either flocked to their hometowns for family reunion or gathered at tourist attractions across the country, has not caused an outbreak of Covid-19. In a special address to

  • Will Evergrande change the way Chinese developers do business in Cambodia?

    China’s property sector policy has exposed the grim financial condition of real estate developers including those operating in Cambodia, which raises questions over the viability of their projects and business going forward The dark blue netting draping over one of Yuetai Group Co Ltd’

  • Cambodia resumes issuance of tourist visas

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation has announced the resumption of its tourist visa and visa exemption programme after a long hiatus due to the Covid-19 pandemic. In a letter dated October 20 and addressed to foreign embassies and consulates, foreign minister Prak Sokhonn

  • S’ville set to turn into ‘second Shenzhen’

    The Ministry of Economy and Finance has awarded a master plan consultancy contract to top Chinese institute for the development and transformation of Preah Sihanouk province into a “Model Multi-Purpose Special Economic Zone”, Southeast Asia’s next logistics and resort hub and innovation centre. The