Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - NGO puts Appeal Court on trial

NGO puts Appeal Court on trial

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Kem Sokha's lawyer Chuong Choungy walked into the Appeal Court for the Kem Sokha's bail hearing in February. Hong Menea

NGO puts Appeal Court on trial

In its annual report released on Tuesday, the Cambodian Center for Human Rights (CCHR) said while a number of key fair trial rights were guaranteed before the Appeal Court, in virtually all the hearings it monitored, the judges failed to cite the legal provisions and evidence upon which they had relied to reach their verdict.

CCHR’s Fair Trial Rights Project Coordinator, Hun Seang Hak, said it was pleased that protections against double jeopardy, non-retroactivity, the right to understand the nature and cause of the charges, adequate time and facilities to prepare the defence, and the right to a public judgment were consistently met.

“However, despite this positive stance, judges at the Appeal Court only stated that the first instance court’s judgment was upheld or overturned, without explaining why,” he said.

Seang Hak said data for the CCHR report entitled Fair Trial Rights in Cambodia, Monitoring at the Court of Appeal were collected between November 1, 2016, and October 13, last year.

It was carried out in collaboration with President of the Court of Appeal You Bunleng, whom the CCHR praised for “his ongoing collaboration and commitment to continue improving respect for fair trial rights”.

The CCHR analysed data gathered through the daily monitoring of 340 randomly selected criminal cases at the Court of Appeal in Phnom Penh, using a specifically designed trial-monitoring checklist to assess adherence to fair trial rights as set out in international and Cambodian law.

CCHR’s monitoring showed that the presumption of innocence was not fully respected, and insufficient attention was given to allegations that a confession – which often forms the basis for convictions – was obtained under duress or violence.

This, the CCHR report said, was despite 40 defendants making such allegations before the Appeal Court. In more than 65 percent of the cases monitored, the judge also failed to inform and explain to the defendant his right to remain silent.

“Furthermore, the right to have legal representation was not always respected, as 21% of the defendants were not represented by a lawyer. Also, the lack of respect for the right to a reasoned judgment remains one of the most concerning findings in the report,” Seang Hak said.

Seang Hak said the rights of juvenile defendants, who should be given special protection under international human rights law and in Cambodian law, were often ignored.

No specific measures are put into place to protect the rights of juveniles, and all but two of the 35 whose cases were monitored by CCHR had been held in pretrial detention.

“While there have been some significant improvements regarding respect for Fair Trial Rights at the Appeal Court, some fundamental human rights are still not being respected. We hope that the data, analyses and recommendations set out in the report will help facilitate an increased respect for fair trial rights in Cambodia,” Seang Hak said.

The CCHR also urged the authorities to promptly take all appropriate steps to ensure that fair trial rights, and particularly the presumption of innocence, the right to a reasoned judgment, and the protection of juvenile’s privacy, are vigorously protected.

Lawyer Sok Samoeun declined to comment on the report itself, but said from his experience in the Court of Appeal, some things were lacking, such as cases that were pending for years.

“It just extended the accuseds’ detentions, for example on grounds that lawyers were absent. So some cases were pending conclusion for years. But we cannot say the Appeal Court was wrong on such matters because the postponements were based on law,” he said.

MOST VIEWED

  • Over $3M in traffic fines collected in two months

    Traffic police officers collected over $3 million in fines throughout the Kingdom during the past two months when officers strictly enforced the law in accordance with a May sub-decree, officials said. As incentives, law enforcement officers received between 200,000 and two million riel ($50 to $500) each. The figures

  • More than 10,000 workers suspended

    More than 10,000 workers at 18 factories in Svay Rieng province have been suspended because of Covid-19, said provincial deputy governor Ros Pharith. Home to 11 special economic zones, Pharith said Svay Rieng has not been spared as the pandemic takes a toll on the global economy. “There

  • Oz lauds Kingdom’s passage of money laundering laws

    In a press release published by the Australian embassy in Phnom Penh on Monday, the country applauded Cambodia’s stance on transnational crimes as well as its promulgation of an anti-money laundering law and a law on combating proliferation financing. The praise came after King

  • Lotus face masks designed to cover globe

    A French designer in Cambodia has produced ecological face masks from lotus fibre to supply local and international markets with an eye on preserving ancestral techniques and supporting Cambodian women in rural communities. During a trip to Asia, Awen Delaval, an eco-friendly fashion designer, was

  • Accused not treated equally, says CCHR

    The Cambodia Centre for Human Rights (CCHR) has urged the Court of Appeal to do more to ensure that an accused’s right to a fair trial is fully respected. In a bulletin released on Monday, the CCHR said it had monitored 273 cases at the

  • Planning ministry hands out cash to 420,000 poor families in Kingdom

    The Ministry of Planning has identified 20,000 more poor families in the country, bringing the total to over 580,000, while over 420,000 of them have received the government’s cash assistance. In the meantime, many social security cards from families not deemed to be poor have been revoked.

  • Investors’ $14.4M projects approved

    New investments from local and foreign sources continue to pour into Cambodia despite the Covid-19 pandemic remaining a lingering threat to regional and global economies. This comes as the Kingdom’s gross domestic product (GDP) is expected to contract between one and 2.9 per cent this

  • NagaWorld casinos set to reopen, schools to follow

    NAGACORP Ltd has requested that it be allowed to reopen its NagaWorld integrated resorts in Phnom Penh after the government recently approved casinos to operate again, provided they follow Covid-19 prevention measures set by the Ministry of Health. Mey Vann, the director-general of the Ministry

  • Rubber exports stretch 17%

    Cambodia exported 97,175 tonnes of natural rubber in the first five months of this year, surging 17 per cent compared to the same period last year as the Covid-19 pandemic stretches on, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries official Khuong Phalla told The Post on Thursday. Phalla,

  • ASEM supports Kingdom’s proposal to postpone meeting amid Covid

    The 13th Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM13) scheduled to be held in Cambodia in November has been postponed until mid-2021 due to the Covid-19 pandemic, a Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation press statement released on Saturday said. The decision was made during a two-day meeting