Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Not so fast in Case 002




Not so fast in Case 002

Not so fast in Case 002

Long-awaited testimony in the Khmer Rouge tribunal’s Case 002 may have to wait until next year, while victims of the regime have urged the court to speed up its deliberations on the appeal of S-21 jailer Duch.

A number of legal issues need to be addressed before proceedings can begin in earnest against the four Khmer Rouge leaders in the second case.

The tribunal has scheduled hearings next week to determine whether two of the defendants – Brother No 2 Nuon Chea and former Khmer Rouge Social Action Minister Ieng Thirith – are fit for trial. It has also ordered Ieng Thirith to undergo a mental health exam, and said more hearings would be necessary to consider the results of the additional tests.

“It’s not possible for the Trial Chamber to schedule the start of the substantive trial before they have completed the fitness issue,” court spokesman Lars Olsen said yesterday. “And we don’t know when that will be.”

Anne Heindel, a legal advisor at the Documentation Centre of Cambodia, said it was “safe to say trial will not begin this year”, and noted that there would “likely” be rulings by both the court’s Trial Chamber and the Supreme Court Chamber on the fitness question.

Together with Nuon Chea and Ieng Thirith, former KR Foreign Minister Ieng Sary and head of state Khieu Samphan have been charged with offences including genocide and crimes against humanity for their roles in the deaths of between 1.7 and 2.2 million in Cambodia from 1975 to 1979.

A number of preliminary issues have been raised, including lists of witnesses and experts and Ieng Sary’s 1996 pardon and 1979 conviction in absentia for genocide.

Heindel said it would be up to the Trial Chamber to decide which issues must be addressed before substantive testimony in the trial can begin.

The court’s internal rules allow it to separate proceedings against defendants being tried in the same case in a situation in which one is declared unfit for trial or passes away, but Olsen said the Trial Chamber “has not given any indication that separation of the case is currently on their agenda”.

Heindel said that such a move for Ieng Thirith would be “unnecessarily time consuming if she is found fit for trial, but would likely be the next step if she is found unfit”.

Meanwhile, victims have written to the court urging its Supreme Court Chamber to issue a decision in the appeal of Kaing Guek Iev, alias Duch, who was convicted last year of crimes against humanity and
grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions. Duch was given a 30-year sentence, commuted to 19 years for time already served.

“We have been waiting for the verdict in Case 001 from the Supreme [Court] Chamber for several months, but it has not come out and we’re concerned that it will continue to be prolonged,” Chum Mey, an 80-year-old survivor of Tuol Sleng prison, said yesterday.

“We are concerned that the sentence against Duch is unfair already, so it will give a bad example for Case 002.”

Heindel said she did not believe the Supreme Court has taken an “excessive” period of time in its Case 001 ruling in comparison to other international courts. “They are likely addressing other foundational legal issues – such as the exact character of the court as a hybrid national/international institution – that will impact not only the Duch verdict but also cases 002-004.”

MOST VIEWED

  • Thailand offers Covid-19 funding

    The Royal Embassy of Thailand contributed two million baht ($62,765) to Cambodia’s fight against Covid-19 on Wednesday, as the countries celebrated 70 years of diplomatic relations. The donation was presented by Thailand’s Ambassador to Cambodia Panyarak Poolthup to Prime Minister Hun Sen at a meeting

  • Crowded prisons will set free 10,000 inmates

    Close to 10,000 prisoners will be freed as part of the country’s prison overcrowding campaign, Minister of Interior Sar Kheng announced on Wednesday. The bulk of the inmates have mostly served their sentences and will continue to be monitored by local authorities after their release

  • Sanctuary head sued for not stopping forest occupations

    Four Bunong and an Adhoc official filed a joint lawsuit against Keo Seima Wildlife Sanctuary head Prum Vibol Ratanak at the Mondulkiri Provincial Court for failing to stop illegal land occupation and the buying and selling of forest land. Vibol Ratanak denies the allegations against

  • US and Cambodia talk cybersecurity ongoing assistance

    US Ambassador Patrick Murphy met with Minister of Interior Sar Kheng on Wednesday to discuss bilateral collaboration including on issues of civil society organisations and democracy in Cambodia. But cybercrime seemed to be the prevailing topic at the meeting. Murphy posted on Twitter: “Productive meeting

  • UN: Don’t let patent rows hamper virus vaccine

    The UN patent agency has hailed the push to create a coronavirus vaccine and make it globally available but warned against allowing copyright rows to overshadow and delay the process. “What we need in the first place here is innovation,” said Francis Gurry, the head

  • ‘Be vigilant on human trafficking’

    Minister of Interior Sar Kheng on Wednesday urged provincial authorities along the border to remain vigilant against the transportation of Cambodian migrant workers into Thailand. Speaking during an annual meeting of the National Committee for Counter Trafficking (NCCT), he said despite the closure of the