Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Opposition gains, but CPP reigns

Opposition gains, but CPP reigns

Opposition gains, but CPP reigns


Prime Minister Hun Sen greets Sam Rainsy Party leader Sam Rainsy for the first time since Rainsy returned from self-imposed exile on February 10, 2006.

Summing up Cambodian politics in the wake of 2006 requires a certain amount of arithmetic.

It was the year that the two-thirds National Assembly majority needed to form a government

was changed to a formula of 50 plus 1.

It was a 365-day span in which longstanding coalition partner Funcinpec was divided

- and subsequently multiplied - into three separate royalist parties with almost

zero political clout.

It was also the year that opposition leader Sam Rainsy singled himself out as the

prime political challenger, and the time when the longstanding three-party equation

simply stopped adding up.

After doing the math, 2006 equaled a decisive, albeit controversial, victory for

the ruling Cambodian Peoples Party (CPP) as it strengthened control over all branches

of government, silenced its most salient social critics and broadened its power base

ahead of the April's commune elections.

"We have seen this year that the most dominating force in the government, the

Senate and the National Assembly is the CPP," said Koul Panha, executive director

of election watchdog NGO Comfrel. "Therefore, the CPP is now more powerful,

but any checks and balances have been weakened."

Along the way, the ruling party broached a compromise agreement with its opposition

and brought home, on December 21, the fugitive former police chief who some believe

may have represented the party's biggest threat.

"[2006] was the year that the CPP succeeded in taking control in running the

country as they please, reminiscent of their rule in the 1980s," said Sam Rainsy

Party parliamentarian Son Chhay. "Particularly their control of every government

institution - from the police to the judiciary to all levels of administration."

Other analysts have said the CPP simply evolved its tactics over the past year, and

has altered its famously heavy-handed political approach.

"The CPP is learning. They're getting much smarter in terms of campaigning and

speaking the language of democrats," said Ou Virak, general-secretary of the

Alliance for Freedom of Expression. "Now the CPP is learning the language, so

it will be more difficult for the opposition and smaller parties to offer something


Thun Saray, director of human rights NGO Adhoc, told the Post that political tension

eased over the course of 2006, but the reason was the CPP's choice of targets.

"In 2005 the conflict was between the Prime Minister and the opposition and

some civil society leaders and human rights activists," Saray said on December

28. "But in 2006 the conflict was between the CPP and its coalition party. The

division of Funcinpec meant less tension with opposition lawmakers and activists."

According to Saray, pressure from rights groups and the diplomatic community was

much greater when, just one year ago, four civil society leaders were jailed for

defaming Hun Sen.

"The [disputes] with Prince Ranariddh drew much less attention," he said.

"Another factor is that the opposition, I think, has changed their approach

to one of working together with the CPP. They don't confront as much as in previous

years. For me I am concerned about the imbalance between the CPP and non-CPP parties.

There are no checks and balances."

Even Rainsy, whose return on February 10 from self-imposed exile signaled a softening

of the ruling party's hard-line stance, admits to a warmer relationship with Hun


"These days it's modus vivendi: we tolerate each other," Rainsy said. "We

don't like each other but we tolerate each other. We've agreed to disagree on issues

and the ways to resolve issues facing the nation."

Saray is concerned that such compromise may weaken the opposition.

"The problem is how long the SRP can maintain popularity with their own people

using this new approach," he said. "Before there was some room for the

opposition and the Funcinpec party to work in alliance as a counterweight to the

CPP. Now there is no room."

Government spokesman and CPP Minister of Information Khieu Kanharith said a booming

economy, a developmental largess program and rising standards of living explain the

popularity and confidence of the ruling party.

"The CPP will absolutely win the elections," he told the Post on December

28. "The biggest impact on the political situation is the economy, and the economy

has increased. The per capita income has increased to $500 compared to 1993 when

it was $190."

Kanharith also said rice exports are on the rise, inflation was less than 5 percent

and that the CPP has spent at least one million riel in each of the country's communes

on infrastructure projects such as irrigation, water pumps and construction.

"The big change in the political situation is the from the two-thirds majority

to 50-plus-1," Kanharith said. "We know now there will be no political

deadlock after the elections and we know all political parties will participate in

the coming elections. Therefore, the situation is all good."

Monh Saphan, Funcinpec parliamentarian, agreed that the simple majority law was significant,

but was less enthusiastic about his party's future.

"The amendment to the Constitution was the biggest political event of 2006,"

Saphan said. "The new formula needed to form a government will make all political

parties consider making serious challenges to take control of government. The royalist

party still survives. As long as there is Funcinpec there will be a royalist movement."

Rainsy, whose SRP has benefited the most from the splintering of Funincpec, disagrees.

Characteristically, he's bullish about his party's future, and some observers concur.

"The two big factors in 2006 were the disintegration of the royalist movement

- they will totally disappear from politics - and the emergence of the SRP as the

only challenger to the CPP," he said. "You will see this clearly in 2007

and decisively in 2008. Last year was a turning point. You don't see the result yet,

but it is a major change in the political landscape."

Comfrel's Panha believes there has been much reform and improvement in SRP, but said

he'll wait to see what happens next.

"I can see improvement in the SRP. They're doing quite well at the local level,

its' amazing from an opposition party with limited finances," said Virak. "I'm

interested in how the SRP is going to handle the long arms of the ruling party. The

CPP has used its divide and conquer tactics repeatedly. How are they going to handle

that? Will they stick to their principles without being blackmailed?"

But Kanharith says the CPP is not worried about the emergence of any opponent‚ but

with a caveat.

"We welcome a serious challenge from the SRP. As Samdech Hun Sen has said, we

would rather have a strong enemy than to have a weak friend," he said. "But

the SRP must be fair in competition. Their party always criticizes the CPP as being

a Vietnamese party. We are all Khmer, why don't we just love each other?"

According to Virak, who's assessment of 2006 may come the closest to the mark, the

more Cambodian politics change, the more they remain the same.

"This has been very an interesting year. Lots of games and dirty politics, lots

of ups and downs with the opposition and troubles with Funcinpec," said Virak.

"It's been quite interesting to see how much of a role the CPP plays in the

internal workings of other parties. It appears that Hun Sen was in full control of

the fortunes of Funcinpec, and now it appears he has some role in the Sam Rainsy

Party as well. It just goes to show: politics are still politics and there are lots

of dirty things going on. But now it's harder to tell who is clean and who is dirty."


  • Diplomatic passports issued to foreigners to be annulled

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation will move to annul diplomatic passports issued to those not born in Cambodia. Analysts say the move may be in relation to reports that former Thai prime minister Yingluck Shinawatra used a Cambodian passport to register as

  • The hairy little heroes saving many lives in rural Cambodia

    IN RURAL Siem Reap province, rats dare to tread where no person will, as these hairy little heroes place their lives on the line each day for the good of the local community. The rodents are the most important members of a special team, leading

  • Hun Sen warns Irish MP of EBA ‘mistake’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Saturday told former Irish premier Enda Kenny, still a member of the EU nation’s parliament, that the 28-nation bloc should not make a “third mistake” regarding Cambodia by using the preferential Everything But Arms (EBA) agreement to “take 16 million

  • Hun Sen’s China visit ‘a good opportunity’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen’s visit to Beijing on Sunday to discuss economic and trade issues presents a good opportunity for the Kingdom to strengthen Chinese ties and counter punitive measures by the West, an analyst says. The prime minister’s four-day official visit to