Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Pay Dispute Undermines UNTAC Morale

Pay Dispute Undermines UNTAC Morale

Pay Dispute Undermines UNTAC Morale

A six month old dispute over the United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia

(UNTAC) military staff's pay has led to bitter exchanges, hate mail, and even death

threats, not to mention endless amounts of wasted paperwork and man hours which ought

to be devoted to the greater problem of bringing peace to Cambodia.

The dispute stems from the fact that the military staff working at U.N. headquarters

say that they are being discriminated against by not receiving Mission Subsistence

Allowance (MSA). UNTAC civilian staff and certain categories of military personnel

receive MSA, which involves a U.S. $130 dollars a day-having just been reduced from

U.S. $145-paid monthly directly into the recipient's bank account, giving the individual

the liberty to use it as he or she feels fit.

Agreements drawn up between the world body and the various countries contributing

troops specify two categories of military personnel: "formed military units"

and "military observers" (MOs) , with only the latter being eligible for

MSA. Falling into the first category the military staff have their accommodation

up to $79 per day paid by UNTAC administration and they are given $30 dollars a day

for food and expenses.

But the military staff at UNTAC HQ say they have been wrongly classified as part

of the "formed military units." This they claim, applies to their countries'

battalions. But they state they are working independently of the battalions which

are, in some cases, stationed up-country, hundreds of kilometers away, doing an entirely

different job. As further weight to their claim, they point to the fact that some

of their colleagues, such as the Austrians and previously, the Irish, don't even

have formed units serving with UNTAC. If anything, the military staff say, they belong

to same classification as the MOs who operate independently.

In a formal petition to the U.N. Secretary-General Boutros Boutros Ghali, seeking

redress of their grievance on the MSA issue and signed "UNTAC Military Staff",

one Austrian officer noted that he was recruited as a MO but was subsequently asked

to work at headquarters before rotating with a colleague and going on to do the original

job demanded. He said he had been told he would get MSA and then found out the opposite

was the case. Other staff have complained that they, for some inexplicable reason,

did receive the allowance and were told they would have to pay it back.

The MSA of U.S. $145 per day had been the subject of much criticism, with many observers

saying that it is vastly excessive in a country where the average annual income is

U.S. $170. To them, the military staff's complaint does not seem to merit much sympathy

especially given rather more pressing problems facing both UNTAC and Cambodians.

The staff, however, argue that trying to get MSA per se is not the issue. "The

issue is not to obtain $145 for Military Staff, we question the justification for

the magnitude of such a sum. Equity is the issue," one of the countless confidential

reports seen by the Post, stated. In another report, Australian Lt. Col. Healy stated,

"my own interest in this issue is tied up in one word-equity. We should not

be asking for $145 a day. If that can be justified for subsistence in Cambodia (and

I have some doubts about that) then that is what we should receive. If it is the

lower figure that I suspect it is, then we should be ready to accept that."

Referring to the fact that their accommodation is paid for by UNTAC administration

rather than by the officers themselves, Healy goes on to say, "We should never

accept having an inflexible, administrative, burdensome subsistence categorization

which financially disadvantages us, while others whose efforts are far less and whose

contributions are relatively insignificant, receive a substantial 'Cambodia Subsidy'.

Such discrimination is unjust, insulting and intolerable."

Adding insult to injury, as Healy noted and other staff complain, is that the civilian

staff, often working in the same office as their military counterparts, receive the

MSA. "There are people in charge of an office working sevens days a week but

the typist working five days gets it, it's not equitable," said one officer,

who claimed he never would have dreamed of talking to the press but that the situation

was so bad he felt he had to. Morale is totally undermined and productivity has been

seriously affected at a critical time in the peace process, he said. "If we

were a football team we would be losing every game."

The villain of the piece, the staff claim, is Director of Administration, Hocine

Medili who has been on the receiving end of hate mail and abusive telephone calls.

In an open letter to Medili, the staff outline their problem with the director. "You

must carry a large portion of the blame for the current situation. You took four

months before being convinced that the Military Staff had a complaint..and then grudgingly

sent a fax to New York. Now New York will probably take that time to set up a committee...The

committee will take about six months to look into this problem and will finally decide

that, since the UNTAC mission will be over by that time, present regulations will

remain," the letter stated.

Force Commander General Sanderson acknowledged six months ago that the morale problem

had reached a crisis point. According to documents given to the Post, Sanderson was

sympathetic to the staff demands but it appeared he was constrained by New York's

dictates. However, he too was the recipient of an anonymous threatening letter. It

claimed the general hadn't tried hard enough on the men's behalf and went on to state,

"There may be cases of physical assault on some VIPs including senior civilian

officers. There may be incidents like killings also." The letter also claimed

that "nobody was working seriously except Australians" and threatened strike

action. To try and solve matters in a more disciplined and civilized manner, the

staff decided in November to set up a Military Staff Association. This, however,

did not meet with Sanderson's approval and was aborted, officers said.

Tempers were further raised when the "added discrimination" of new regulations

were introduced requiring military staff to live at least five to a house and requiring

officers below the rank of major to share hotel rooms. The car belonging to the "unfortunate"

lady in charge of overseeing these accommodation regulations was found burnt out,

one of the staff stated. Akashi called an emergency meeting and asked Sanderson to

ensure such incidents never took place again and hoped the problem would end there.

Sanderson left saying the root of the problem (MSA) remained the same as when he

entered the room, the staff officer said. It later transpired that a mechanical fault

had caused the fire, but the officer said the incident was an indication of how serious

the issue had become.

"If morale was a major problem months ago, you can imagine how some people feel

now," one affected staff member stated. Months ago the U.N. Under-Secretary

for Peace-Keeping Operations, Marrack Goulding told a diplomat at the U.N. in New

York that the situation in UNTAC was like "a powder keg ready to go off."

But despite the perceived short fuse, New York put the issue on the back burner.

In a fax to Sanderson dated Jan. 19, Goulding stated that there was going to be a

global review of MSA arrangements. But as the staff's open letter to Medili suspected,

the issue was not going to see a quick solution. "This process will take some

time and it would be wrong for me to give you the impression that solutions will

be quickly or easily found... I realize that this is not the reply which you would

have liked to receive...We look to you to control what you describe as a "volatile"

situation and to ensure that the officers concerned continue, as they have admirably

done so far, to carry out their duties in spite of the dissatisfaction with the financial

arrangements which they consider discriminatory," Goulding told the general.

Sanderson, however, recently acknowledged that not everyone was carrying out their

duties in an admirable fashion. "There are some in the headquarters who are

being carried by the rest. The honorable thing would be for them to go home,"

he said. While he admitted that the military staff should not be seen as part of

their contingents, he stressed that the soldiers should not concern themselves with

the problem and thereby possibly undermine the success of the mission but should

leave the matter for their individual government's attention-as was the case with

the Irish who ended up withdrawing their HQ staff-or raise the matter with the U.N.

in New York. "While I see some injustices in the regulations, changes have to

be made in New York. This is an issue between (military staff's) nations and the

U.N.," he said. Other non-UNTAC observers commented that while the staff may

have a righteous grievance, it paled somewhat compared to what the average Cambodian

had to tolerate.


  • Joy as Koh Ker Temple registered by UNESCO

    Cambodia's Koh Ker Temple archaeological site has been officially added to UNESCO’s World Heritage List, during the 45th session of the World Heritage Committee held in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on September 17. The ancient temple, also known as Lingapura or Chok Gargyar, is located in

  • Famed US collector family return artefacts to Cambodia

    In the latest repatriation of ancient artefacts from the US, a total of 33 pieces of Khmer cultural heritage will soon return home, according to the Ministry of Culture and Fine Arts. In a September 12 press statement, it said the US Attorney’s Office for the

  • Cambodia set to celebrate Koh Ker UNESCO listing

    To celebrate the inscription of the Koh Ker archaeological site on UNESCO’s World Heritage List, the Ministry of Cults and Religion has appealed to pagodas and places of worship to celebrate the achievement by ringing bells, shaking rattles and banging gongs on September 20. Venerable

  • Kampot curfew imposed to curb ‘gang’ violence

    Kampot provincial police have announced measures to contain a recent spike in antisocial behaviour by “unruly’ youth. Officials say the province has been plagued by recent violence among so-called “gang members”, who often fight with weapons such as knives and machetes. Several social observers have

  • PM outlines plans to discuss trade, policy during US visit

    Prime Minister Hun Manet is set to meet with senior US officials and business leaders during his upcoming visit to the US for the UN General Assembly (UNGA), scheduled for September 20. While addressing nearly 20,000 workers in Kampong Speu province, Manet said he aims to affirm

  • Manet touches down in Beijing for high-level meetings

    Prime Minister Hun Manet arrived in Beijing on September 14 for his first official visit to China, where he is slated to attend the 20th China-ASEAN Expo and meet other leaders including Chinese President Xi Jinping. Upon his arrival, Manet laid a wreath at the Monument