Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Revolving regimes leave one survivor muddled

Revolving regimes leave one survivor muddled

Revolving regimes leave one survivor muddled


Coping with rapidly-changing regimes and ideologies has been a matter of survival

for Cambodians over the past 30 years. For Samrith Phom, like many other Cambodians,

those regimes each extracted a heavy toll. But, as Chea Sotheacheath discovers,

Phom is finding peace and reconciliation just as bewildering as conflict and suffering.


Phom (left) has survived 30 years of war and five governments

Samrith Phom gestures to a pile of human bones, and says, "I wonder how it was

so easy for Khieu Samphan and Noun Chea to say the words 'sorry, sorry' for the deaths

of these people. Is that all?"

Here, at Sang, on the Kandal-Takeo provincial border - at the site of one of the

Khmer Rouge regime's former prisons - the bones of hundreds of people lie in silent,

broken and almost forgotten testimony to Pol Pot's victims.

Few people come here: the occasional genocide researcher, the odd television crew,

and people like Phom. She believes - but cannot be sure - that the bones of her husband,

killed at Sang prison during the Pol Pot times, lie here.

As she talks, a roaming dog crawls closer, grabs a human arm bone and lumbers off

with it for a gnaw. Phom looks the other way. Here, the bones of Pol Pot's victims

get no special treatment or, it seems, even respect.

"Why did Mr Hun Sen so easily agree with them [Khieu Samphan and Noun Chea]?"

Phom murmurs.

For her, Cambodia's new-found 'peace and reconciliation' provokes the same kind of

confusion and uncertainty which has plagued her all her adult life.

Samrith Phom is a typical Cambodian, if there is such a thing. Aged 48, she first

fled her home at age 19. She has endured the hardships and abuses of successive Cambodian

regimes: she remembers the rapes and cruelties of the US-backed soldiers of Lon Nol,

the atrocities of Pol Pot, the hardships of the People's Republic of Kampuchea.

Now, as she makes a living selling homemade cakes at a Kandal market, she believes

this current government is better than those of the past; people can do business

and have the freedom to travel. But politicians still fight each other, and she has

learned not to trust any of them. To her, the word politics means ''lying''.

As for ''justice'', she is unsure. Genocide investigators have interviewed her as

a possible witness for an international trial of former KR leaders, but she doesn't

really know what a trial is.

She doesn't want to travel abroad to testify at any international tribunal, she doesn't

think she really needs to; if anyone wants to know what the KR did, she can just

bring them here to Sang, to see the skulls and bones.

Our boat is long; their boat is short - we cannot turn as fast they can, is a Khmer

saying which compares the political flexibility of Cambodian leaders with that of

their citizens. Successive Cambodian regimes have demanded swift and often vicious

changes to society, with ordinary people struggling to keep pace.

Phom understands the saying well. Her tumultuous ride through the regimes of modern

Cambodian history began in the Lon Nol times, when she was still a teenager.

She and her husband abandoned their homeland of Boeng Kya village, in Kandal Stung

district of Kandal province, responding to the King's call to the jungle in 1970

after Lon Nol's government toppled the monarchy.

Aged 19, Phom and her husband Doung Sa-Moeun had to chose between following the US-backed

Lon Nol regime, or the Viet Cong-supported Khmer Rouge.

They loved the King and they hated Lon Nol and the Thieu (South Vietnam) regime,

whose soldiers raped woman and children, ''fished'' for cows with their helicopters,

destroyed humble fields with their tanks and arrested local villagers suspected of

Viet Cong affiliations.

"We ran to join the Khmer Rouge in the jungle because we believed that the Khmer

Rouge were kind and peaceful,'' Phom recounts. ''If we stayed in the village we would

have been mistreated by the Lon Nol soldiers everyday."

To begin with, Phom found peace in a KR jungle community in Phum Kampem, Baset district

of Kompong Speu, the first ''liberated zone'' in the rebels' Southwest Zone. Around

1973, the community was divided into cooperatives, in line with Maoist philosophy,

and private property was banned.

Phom, like many others, was happy to give up her worldly goods and rely on the support

of ''good friends in poverty''. Many in Phum Kampem were satisfied to sacrifice their

lives, and their husbands, sons and daughters, to join the KR soldiers and support

their King against United States aerial bombings and Lon Nol's ground attacks.

In April 1975, the KR seized control of the whole country. Phom and her husband were

happy to return to their home village in Kandal. They were ''old people'' - trusted

and supposedly ideologically purer because they were veterans of the ''liberated

zones''. Her husband was appointed as village chief, overseeing both ''old people''

and the ''new people''.

But the KR's political philosophy was strict, the search for 'enemies' of the revolution

was endless, and Phom and her husband began to wonder where their King was?

''We sacrificed everything for 'Angkar' [the KR ''organization''], we wore a ton

of Americans bombs on our heads, for Samdech Euv [the King]. But when Phnom Penh

was captured, we never saw Samdech Euv.''

Phom had been willing to make sacrifices for the KR and the King, but the 'disappearance'

of her husband was a penalty she never expected or understood.

"I was in pain. They killed my husband. And then, they took me and my baby to


More then 20 years on, Phom still doesn't know what happened to her husband. All

she knows is he was called for 'reeducation' and never returned. She firmly believes

he was detained at Sang prison, where she herself was later kept, and later killed.

Some time after her husband disappeared, local officials came to collect her to go

and see her husband, or so she was told. She went with the officials on an ox-cart,

taking her baby boy with her.

She now believes that she was being taken to an area east of the prison, where executions

were carried out. But as the cows pulling the ox-cart passed the prison, they trudged

inside the compound, rather than continue off to the east as they were directed.

The guards couldn't be bothered forcing the cows back; they let Phom and her baby

stay at the prison - their lives were saved by two stubborn cows.

Phom is unsure how long she stayed at the prison, but thinks it was for more than

a year. The food was meager, the inmates slept on bare earth, and the discipline

was strict. She never saw anyone killed but at night trucks used to come to take

people away. They did not return.

The Vietnamese invasion of late 1978 saw the prison guards run away. The inmates

debated whether to follow them; they had been fed horror stories about how the Vietnamese

would kill them all.

"I had no idea of where I should go. If I followed the Khmer Rouge I would be

killed because I am a prisoner of the Khmer Rouge. If I went to the Vietnamese side,

I thought I would also be killed," she recounts.

Eventually, she decided to flee - toward the approaching Vietnamese forces.

Several months after the Vietnamese invasion, Phom returned with her son, who had

survived prison along with her, to their home village to face life under the new


To her Vietnamese-supported village chief, she was an ''old person'' - a Khmer Rouge

veteran who was not to be trusted. She missed out on food rations given to the villagers,

and was forced to scavenge for food. Once, caught collecting rice stalks dropped

by other villagers during harvest time, she was called before the village chief and

reprimanded as a thief.

The Maoist-style communism of the KR was replaced by the Leninist-style communism

of the Vietnamese. The population was still divided into cooperatives and labor groups,

but families were allowed to live together.

To be strong, respected and have enough food, you had to be part of the system. Soldiers

were respected, so Phom thought it was a good idea to have one in the family, and

she was still angry at the KR for killing her husband - so she sent her son off to

join the army.

Her son fought against the anti-Vietnamese resistance guerrillas around Samlot, an

old bastion of the KR. When he returned, he had lost one of his legs to a landmine.

Having lost a husband to one regime, and her son's leg to another, Phom has many

questions in her mind - questions that she has no answers to. ''I have no words to

say,'' she says.

As for justice, she is unsure of how it can be achieved. Late last year, some people

- from the genocide-researching Documentation Center of Cambodia - came to see her.

The Documentation Center hopes that she could be a witness at a KR international

tribunal, but she says she is not sure about that.

She wonders why there should be a trial now, so many years later. Recalling that

she joined the KR at the call of the King, she wonders who is guilty and who is not.

She wants to know if the countries who supported the KR, or those who supported other

factions which brought war to Cambodia, will be on trial too.

She says she will not go overseas to attend a trial, but she is happy to take people

to the former site of Sang prison to see the bones there. As for herself, she says:

''I think it is difficult for me to point out the men who killed people because I

never saw them kill people with my own eyes.''

Today, some of the former guards at Sang still live in her village; she sees them

pass by on their motos.

''Soon after Pol Pot lost, I was so angry. I tried to find out who killed my husband

but I have never found out.''

But now she says that she doesn't hate or blame anyone. She implies that to ask too

many questions about the former guards who still live in her area is to invite conflict,

and Cambodians have had enough conflict.

Today, she prefers to believe only in Buddhism. ''I don't believe the politicians

any more. I believe only the Buddha.'' She regularly visits her pagoda to pray that

her next life will be better than her current one. And she is a strong believer in

the Puth Tumneay, a collection of ancient Buddhist fables that predict the future.

For instance, she explains, the Puth Tumneay speak of black crows (the KR, she believes)

who drop figs (propaganda) which look attractive but are really rotten inside. People

find and eat the figs, but it is only later that they learn that the food is bad

for them.

"You see!, the Puth Tumneay is really correct. The political situation in Cambodia

has followed the Puth Tumneay. So who we should blame?," asks Phom.


  • Chinese tourists 2.0 – Coming anytime soon?

    Regional tourism is grappling with the absence of the prolific travellers and big spenders – the Chinese tourists. Cambodia, which has welcomed over two million Chinese tourists before Covid-19, is reeling from the economic loss despite being the first to fully open last November ‘To put

  • PM reflects on shoe throwing: Free speech or act of violence?

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on May 17 questioned whether a man who threw a shoe at him while he was in the US was exercising freedom of expression or if it was an act of hostility. Hun Sen was referring to an incident last week when

  • Hun Sen: Stop Russia sanctions

    Prime Minister Hun Sen said sanctions against Russia as a result of its military offensive in Ukraine should be stopped as they have produced no tangible results, and predicted that a global food crisis would ensue in 2023 as a consequence. Speaking to an audience at

  • Prime Minister Hun Sen warmly welcomed by president Biden

    Prime Minister Hun Sen, as ASEAN chair, and other ASEAN leaders were warmly welcomed by US president Joe Biden as the ASEAN-US summit May 12-13 kicked off today in Washington. “This evening, I welcomed ASEAN leaders to the White House for the first time in

  • Prime Minister Hun Sen invites US president to attend summit in Cambodia

    Prime Minister Hun Sen personally invited US President Joe Biden to attend the ASEAN-US Summit which is set to be held in Cambodia in November, as ASEAN and the US are expected to upgrade their strategic partnership to a ‘comprehensive strategic partnership’, according to Prime

  • Pub Street on the cards for Battambang

    The Battambang Provincial Authority has announced that it is considering establishing a Pub Street in the area around the heritage buildings in Battambang town in a bid to attract more tourists. Battambang provincial governor Sok Lou told The Post that the establishment of a Pub