Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Rights climate grim, despite PM's words

Rights climate grim, despite PM's words

Rights climate grim, despite PM's words

DESPITE promises from Second Prime Minister Hun Sen that he will do his very best

to oversee free and fair elections in July, and step down if he loses, it is hard

to find many people other than his underlings who wholeheartedly believe him.

"You can say it as many times as you want, but it isn't translating into action

at the local level," said one human rights worker. "People don't believe

the government anymore, not even when they show good faith."

Speaking to reporters after meeting with King Norodom Sihanouk in Siem Reap on May

2, Hun Sen promised to "strive to make the forthcoming elections as free and

fair as possible".

His comments came three days after his first major speech since emerging from a lengthy

mourning period for his deceased mother, in which he said he was on an electoral

"mission" to have free, fair and credible election.

During an April 29 "Peace Day" rally in front of 5,000 people at Olympic

Stadium, Hun Sen also promised to peacefully transfer power to any victorious political

party or arrange a coalition government with a plethora of parties if the CPP wins.

But with less than three months to go before elections, Hun Sen's pledges are ringing

hollow to the opposition, diplomats and rights workers.

"We are still getting reports of abuses and intimidation. People are still afraid.

That hasn't changed. If you talk to grassroots political activists, it is quite frightening

to see how scared the people are," one rights worker said.

Even the arrest of suspects in three murderous attacks which may have had political

or racial motivations are being doubted, according to several rights workers.

"It is amazing to see how little faith the people have in the government,"

said one.

Even within Hun Sen's own party, officials fearful of a crackdown on CPP moderates

being squeezed for "talking too much", warned it could spell the end of

real opposition. "If you want to shut every mouth in your own party, how will

you treat the opposition? Many of them will be killed!" said a CPP official.

"The international community, they have closed one eye. They will not close


One source of widespread pessimism in the run up to elections has been a CPP grassroots

campaign to assure a hearty vote for the party come election day.

Critics say the party's orchestrated cell network is open to loose interpretation

by "group leaders" who are often in a position to intimidate voters.

A grassroots procedural guidebook asks group leaders to take responsibility for about

10 voters in an area, advise them "how to love and support the party",

lead them to register to vote and ensure that all members go to vote, know how to

vote and "are sure to vote for the CPP".

It is the last part of the instructions that particularly worries rights workers

and electoral observers who say it is a recipe for intimidation.

"This particular issue of thumb printing has been reported to the National Electoral

Commission and I assume they will do something," said Thomas Hammarberg, the

UN Secretary General's special representative.

"No one denies the right to recruitment drives, but it is important that this

is done in a way which would not amount to coercion... that line is thin and requires

sensitivity not to use their local authorities to imply pressure," Ham-marberg

said in a May 4 interview.

He also called on those in power to continue to make it clear to the people that

their votes will be secret and he encouraged the counting of votes on the widest

level possible to guarantee the safety of voters.

"There are strong arguments for protecting the ballot boxes and probably moving

them to the district level... Again, if there is a spirit of generosity [this should

be resolved]," he said.

One NEC member said he has heard reports of voter intimidation, but that no evidence

or complaints have yet been brought before the commission.

He said however, a negative message from up high has "made people fearful".

"It isn't free, isn't fair, if it is not secret," he said. "They do

want to participate, but they don't want to jeopardize their families."

Others also appear to have reservations about Hun Sen's election-related promises,

including the United Nations, which agreed to send more than 300 electoral monitors

and observers to Cambodia - but with conditions.

If UN staff are not safe as they travel around with political candidates, or have

their movements restricted, Hammarberg said, the UN election monitors will pull out.

One diplomatic source said that the current environment is not acceptable but that

there is still time for authorities to put Hun Sen's words into action. "It

depends when you date the election climate from. If you date it from when he said

that, the verdict must still be out. [But] it is clear we have been in the campaign

period for a long time already. There is clear cause for concern. Political parties

have [already] faced numerous incidents of political violence."

While Hun Sen said that King Norodom Sihanouk appeared satisfied with electoral preparations

up until now and "expressed his wish to stay in... Cambodia until after the

election", there are signs of the King's discontent.

The King , who has been asked by the international community to help create a stable

political climate, is reported to be "resigned to fate", despite Hun Sen's

electoral promise.

Opposition politician Sam Rainsy called the King "fatalistic" after his

own April 30 audience with the monarch.

The King has met with many diplomats and political figures in recent weeks to assess

the situation and he has repeatedly commented in his monthly bulletin that the elections

will not meet any reasonable criteria.

"The King has very few illusions about the free-ness and fairness of elections,"

said Rainsy, who refuted the rosy assessment that Asean diplomats said the King had

in regards to elections.

Rainsy said the monarch is effectively paralyzed by his fear of blame - either for

sanctioning phony elections or for elections not taking place at all.

"The King said: 'If I support July 26 and those elections are unacceptable,

I will be held responsible," Rainsy said. The same goes for an election delay,

which might prevent them from ever happening. "So he will just follow the man.

He will not do anything."

The King has shown some signs of hope, though. In an April 8 letter to UN Secretary

General Kofi Annan which was reprinted in the royal bulletin, the King thanked the

UN for accepting Cambodia's request to coordinate and observe elections.

"The presence of such observers constitutes a guarantee for the good unfolding

of the voting operation," he wrote. "In doing so, the UN, in the person

of its very eminent Secretary General, offers confirmation of the importance it attaches

to free, democratic, credible and fair elections."

Others suggested, however, that the relatively small UN presence will not be enough.

"When you go far into the provinces...you find people saying they don't think

they can vote without UN observers [ present]," one electoral observer said,

suggesting that there will not be enough to make them feel comfortable.

The observer, who has experience monitoring elections in other countries, expressed

pessimism about the chances of a credible vote, saying all the signs are present

for a "pretty bad election".

"Nobody seems to believes the Second Prime Minister will accept the results

if he loses."

Amid the tense electoral climate, a second UN memorandum on executions that remain

uninvestigated will be released. The report, which is now scheduled to be given to

the government in the coming days and made public two weeks later, is an update both

on a previous report on 41 "confirmed" executions following the July coup.

Thomas Hammarberg declined to say how many new victims would be listed in the report

- rights workers have cited a total of more than 100 cases since early July - but

pointed out that "the longer people have disappeared, the more likely it is

that they have been killed".

He said the report should paint a broad picture of the human rights climate at the

moment. "It's a collation of where we are now, since early July, which underscores

again the need for investigation.

"The point is not that the cases are new, the point is, for god's sake start

with the investigation!"

One rights worker in Phnom Penh pointed out that many cases will not be included

in the UN rights report as their reach is limited to areas where it is safe enough

for their staff to gather information.

"It is scary because no one knows how many [more] executions there are. A lot

of executions go unreported because people don't know how to report them or where

to report them, or they are afraid, or they live in remote areas where they can't

report them. We stumble onto many cases, so there must be many cases we don't stumble


Opposition political figure Sam Rainsy commended the UN center for its work and said

it must be extremely careful in dealing with the government.

"I realize the UN center is conducting a difficult task. You cannot be accurate

100 percent in this environment. People are afraid to speak. There is intimidation.

There are many pseudonyms...

"In this environment it is very difficult. What they have done so far is commendable.

They should be careful. The government is watching and waiting and looking for mistakes.

We have to have balance, even if there is a small mistake, it doesn't mean 99 percent

is not right," said Rainsy who is awaiting the results of an investigation into

the deaths of two supporters killed in February and March in Kampong Cham.

"There is killing [almost] every day," he said, noting the pervasive climate

of fear.

"Everybody is afraid. They spy on each other in the ministry. The secretary

will spy on the minister. The head of cabinet can spy on the minister. It is the

Khmer Rouge tradition. This is the kind of culture I want to get rid of. People,

out of fear, can be scared out of doing or saying the right thing."


  • PM imposes nationwide Covid restrictions, curfew over Delta scare

    Prime Minister Hun Sen late on July 28 instructed the municipal and provincial authorities nationwide to strictly enforce Covid-19 measures including curfew for two weeks from July 29 midnight through August 12 to stem the new coronavirus Delta variant. The instruction came shortly after he issued a directive

  • Two luxury hotels latest quarantine options for inbound travellers

    The Inter-Ministerial Committee to Combat Covid-19 has designated two luxury hotels as alternative quarantine options for travellers who wish to enter Cambodia through Phnom Penh International Airport – Sokha Phnom Penh Hotel & Residence and the Courtyard by Marriott Phnom Penh. In a notice detailing guidelines issued

  • Provinces on Thai borders put in lockdown amid Delta fears

    The government has decided to place several border provinces in lockdown for two weeks in a bid to prevent the new coronavirus Delta variant spreading further into community. According a directive signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen late on July 28, the provinces include Koh Kong,

  • Delta spreading in Kingdom

    Cambodia has so far detected more than 200 cases of the highly contagious coronavirus Delta variant, with 109 found on July 31 and August 1. The Ministry of Health has expressed deep concerns that the variant may have already reached communities and be spreading as some of the cases

  • China denies Mekong hacking

    As the US and its allies joined hands last week to expose what they allege to be China’s Ministry of State Security’s malicious cyber activities around the world, the attention also turned to Cambodia with the US Department of Justice claiming that four

  • US' Johnson & Johnson Covid-19 vaccines arrive

    The first batch of 455,000 doses of the Johnson & Johnson Covid-19 vaccine donated by the US touched down in Phnom Penh on the morning of July 30. They are part of the total 1,060,100 doses the US has pledged to provide to Cambodia through the World Health Organisation-led (