Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Robinson content with "full and frank discussions"

Robinson content with "full and frank discussions"

Robinson content with "full and frank discussions"

DESPITE giving assurances that the United Nations human rights office in Cambodia

could continue its work, Hun Sen refused to meet one of two visiting top UN rights

envoys and again lambasted their local office here.

Although High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson lauded her Jan 23 meeting

with Hun Sen as a "full and frank and, I believe, a positive discussion",

the Second Prime Minister appeared to be more focused on attempting to embarrass

UN rights staff than cooperating with them.

UN special representative for human rights Thomas Ham-marberg was also expected to

attend the meeting but was excluded at the last minute. Hun Sen said that Hammarberg

was absent because the envoy did not request a meeting with him, but Hammarberg told

the Post that Hun Sen had telephoned Robinson the night before the meeting and said

he would not meet her if Hammarberg was present.

"We talked, and decided it would be a shame for the UN if she left without seeing

him," Hammarberg said, although some other rights workers criticized Rob-inson's

decision to agree to Hun Sen's demand.

The High Commissioner secured Hun Sen's agreement for the mandate of the UN Center

for Human Rights in Cambodia to be extended - soothing fears that the government

was gearing up to close it down before the national elections scheduled for July

- although the atmosphere at their meeting was plainly less than friendly.

Robinson said later that she had "pressed Hun Sen very hard" over the lack

of investigation into killings after July's factional fighting. The Second Prime

Minister appeared "very uncomfortable" with her questions, she told a press

conference in Tokyo, where she flew after leaving Cambodia, on Jan 27, according

to Kyodo News Services.

Hun Sen, meanwhile, continued his efforts to discredit the UN Center's report on

the killings. At his meeting with Robinson he produced four men whom he said were

listed as dead or missing by the UN rights office.

Lashing out at Center workers, he said: "We could not have good cooperation

with the people who violate us, who abuse us or distort us."

Hammarberg quickly issued a statement to assert that one of the four men was not

listed at all in the UN report of post-July killings, and two were merely listed

as missing, but he acknowledged an error with the fourth man, who had been listed

as dead. Hammarberg said the man was the brother of two executed men and his name

was only listed because of a minor spelling error in his first name.

"I must say that I think it is surprising that a prime minister is parading

a person whose two brothers were killed as evidence that the report about these killings

was wrong," Hammarberg later told the Post. The UN report alleged at least 41


Analysts surmised that the UN envoy had been excluded from the meeting because he

was more thoroughly familiar with the report than was Robinson.

"I would have corrected his mistakes on the spot," Hammar-berg said, noting

that in a September meeting with the Second Prime Minister, he had been able to debunk

another parade of men whom Hun Sen claimed had been listed as dead.

However, he expressed no anger with Robinson for going ahead with the meeting without

him. "We are as one when it comes to the situation here," he told a Jan

24 press conference.

Hun Sen's latest attempt to discredit the Center comes on the heels of a contentious

incident in which municipal police grabbed former Funcinpec military policeman Chao

Sokhon - released from prison days earlier after the Court of Appeal overturned two

drug convictions against him - out of a UN vehicle as he was about to board a flight

at Pochentong airport on Jan 3.

The UNCHR lodged a formal complaint that their diplomatic immunity had been violated,

but the two Prime Ministers countered with a letter to Robinson and UN Secretary-General

Kofi Annan claiming Sokhon was a convict, and by escorting him to the airport, Center

workers "grossly interfered in the internal process of ... a sovereign state".

The Prime Ministers demanded that local rights officials be reprimanded, and that

they apologize or be replaced.

Yet one angry rights worker, who claimed that the Interior Ministry had issued a

passport to Sokhon just a few days before he tried to leave, responded: "I wouldn't

apologize... They can throw me out of the office."

Hammarberg said Kofi Annan had replied to the Prime Ministers' complaint by asking

them to investigate the case. "So I will do that and report to him, and the

Prime Ministers will have their response," he promised. Robinson told the press

conference that the Sokhon issue "was not raised" in her meetings with

government officials.

Robinson, however, won Hun Sen's assurances that the Center could stay in Cambodia.

"The Center has a two-year mandate and both Prime Ministers agreed to extend

the mandate," Hun Sen spokesman Prak Sokhonn confirmed, adding that the length

of the extension had not been decided.

The UN has requested a two-year renewal when the current agreement with the government

expires in March, according to Hammarberg.

Robinson also secured agreement that the government would accept a UN expert to assist

in the official investigations of 1997 political killings.

"This is my concern as High Commissioner - that the investigation of the events

... be very clearly examined and I think there are aspects of it that can be particularly

identified as warranting examination," she said, citing the case of executed

Secretary of State for Interior Ho Sok.

Hammarberg added that the expert could also aid in investigation of the unsolved

March 30 grenade attack on a Khmer Nation Party demonstration. Hammarberg and Robinson

briefly visited the attack site, laid a wreath and spoke to survivors.

Robinson also paid a visit to the Tuol Sleng genocide museum, formerly a torture

center during the 1975-79 Khmer Rouge regime. "There has been an inexcusable

delay in realizing how much this country has suffered, and a need for more concern

at the international level," she said, adding that the government welcomed a

proposed UN team of experts to examine evidence against the Khmer Rouge.

Among other positive developments during the two rights envoys' Cambodia visit was

the release of two women, allegedly linked to the Funcinpec resistance, held without

charge for three weeks by military in Koh Kong. Hammarberg accompanied a human rights

delegation to the southern province to secure their release.

While there, he also raised with local authorities the large human trafficking problem

in the province. "It was clear that some police were involved in this, so we

wanted to be certain that they actually had a crackdown," Ham-marberg said.

"We will continue to monitor this. We have made our point - that this needs

to be remedied - with some force."

He added that governor Rong Plamkesan had assured him that human rights NGOs would

be welcome in his province. Previously, the governor had reportedly threatened to

ban rights workers from Koh Kong.

Rights workers, claiming increased intimidation in Cam-bodia's provinces, called

for greater monitoring of rights abuses and protection of investigators.

The international NGO Human Rights Watch said Jan 21 that "the human rights

situation is dire enough in Cambodia to warrant as much monitoring, domestic and

international, as possible".


  • WHO: Covid in Cambodia goes into new phase

    The World Health Organisation (WHO) in Cambodia said that Cambodia has reached a new phase of the pandemic with “decreasing case numbers, high vaccination coverage and a more transmissible circulating variant threatening a hidden surge”. In a press release on September 6, the WHO said that

  • Purging Sihanoukville’s past with a new masterplan

    Amid illicit activities, haphazard development and abandoned projects, the coastal city of Sihanouk province needs a reset to move forward. A new masterplan might be the answer to shake off its seemingly mucky image to become the Shenzhen of the south Gun toting, shootouts, police

  • 'Pursue your goals, reach out to me': Young diplomat tapped as envoy to South Korea

    Chring Botum Rangsay was a secretary of state at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation before being designated as the new Cambodian ambassador to South Korea. According to her official CV published on the foreign ministry’s website, she started her first government

  • School reopening ‘offers model for other sectors’

    World Health Organisation (WHO) representative to Cambodia Li Ailan said school reopening process should be used as a role model for reopening other sectors currently mothballed by the Covid-19 pandemic. Li strongly supports the government’s decision to reopen schools, saying it is a decision

  • Tourism concerns laid bare

    To ensure the success of plans to reopen the tourism market for international visitors, Cambodia must pay utmost attention to two primary determinants – the ongoing paradigm shift in domestic tourism services towards the ‘new normal’, and the factors influencing choices of destinations among foreign holidaymakers.

  • Covid jab drive for 6-11 age group to begin Sept 17

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has permitted Covid-19 vaccinations for over 1.8 million children aged 6-11 across the country from September 17 in order for them to return to school after a long hiatus. Hun Sen also hinted that vaccinations for the 3-6 age group will follow in