Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Secretariat relying on flawed report: expert

Secretariat relying on flawed report: expert

Secretariat relying on flawed report: expert

T HE core study prepared for the Mekong Secretariat on hydroelectric dams was done

"as if it were a simplistic plumbing problem," a United States consultant

said earlier this year.

Hydrology expert Dr Philip Williams of California, in a report prepared for International

Rivers Network (IRN), also said the authors of the Secretariat's 1994 report ignored

advise from their own fishery biologists.

The report concluded that power development on the lower Mekong was viable.

Its author was a dam construction consultant, Williams said.

He said the report was flawed in methodology and economic analysis, was biased and

incomplete, and had unjustified recommendations.

The report - which the Secretariat has been relying on to make its decisions - discussed

"viability" only in economic terms, and left ecological damage as no more

than a "consideration," he said.

The study did little to "avoid or minimize impacts" of the dam projects,

as it was supposed to do, he said.

"Instead, a selection of dam locations and heights are based more on engineering

criteria, with the number of relocated people a secondary consideration," he

said.

Most importantly, say environmentalists, the report does not include any cost on

the destruction of fisheries, agriculture, and increased costs for public health,

water treatment and infrastructure.

"The only environmental costs... are the three percent project costs for "mitigation"

and community development and $5,500 per displaced person," Williams said.

The report's assessment of electricity revenues were uncertain, he added.

The report said that environmental impacts of a staircase of dam projects would "not

be severe."

Williams said: "... a staircase of dam projects... would directly destroy 1,400

kilometers of riparian and riverine ecosystems of the world's 10th largest river,

and would fundamentally alter its entire hydrologic and ecologic system."

"This opinion would clearly not be shared by any credible ecologist and in fact

is at variance with the opinions of the consultant team's own fisheries biologists

who... 'stress that data now available are insufficient to support any analysis of

the impact of the projects'," he said.

Williams also said that the report gave a biased, low estimation of how many people

would be forced from their land because of upstream dam constructions.

"A more reasonable conclusion than that of the report's would have been: 'In

view of the potential for severe adverse social, environmental and economic impacts;

prior to implementation of major dam projects in the Mekong Basin it is essential

that a thorough independent and objective watershed analysis be carried out. Such

an analysis would be directed towards developing a complete understanding of the

hydrology, geomorphology, ecology and social geography of the river system, and evaluating

all existing beneficial uses of the river'," Williams wrote.

MOST VIEWED

  • NY sisters inspired by Khmer heritage

    Growing up in Brooklyn, New York, Cambodian-American sisters Edo and Eyen Chorm have always felt a deep affinity for their Cambodian heritage and roots. When the pair launched their own EdoEyen namesake jewellery brand in June, 2020, they leaned heavily into designs inspired by ancient Khmer

  • Schools drawn into Manet degree row

    Prime Minister Hun Sen stepped into the Hun Manet-Sam Rainsy war of words over the validity of Manet’s degree from the US Military Academy at West Point, set off by Rainsy’s claims that Manet had received a “second-class degree” or “honorary degree”. Hun

  • Cambodia records first Omicron community case

    The Ministry of Health on January 9 reported 30 new Covid-19 cases, 29 of which were imported and all were confirmed to be the Omicron variant. The ministry also reported 11 recoveries and no new deaths. Earlier on January 9, the ministry also announced that it had detected the Kingdom's

  • The effects of the USD interest rate hike on Cambodian economy

    Experts weigh in on the effect of a potential interest rate expansion by the US Federal Reserve on a highly dollarised Cambodia Anticipation of the US Federal Reserve’s interest rate hike in March is putting developing economies on edge, a recent blog post by

  • PM eyes Myanmar peace troika

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has suggested that ASEAN member states establish a tripartite committee or diplomatic troika consisting of representatives from Cambodia, Brunei and Indonesia that would be tasked with mediating a ceasefire in Myanmar. The premier also requested that Nippon Foundation chairman Yohei Sasakawa

  • Kampot tourism quay ‘90% done’

    Construction on Kampot International Tourism Port – a 4ha quay in Teuk Chhou district about 6km west of Kampot town – has fallen off track, reaching 90 per cent completion, according to a senior Ministry of Tourism official last week. The project is now planned to be finished