Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Stronger surrogacy law anticipated

Stronger surrogacy law anticipated

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Australian national and surrogacy agent Tammy Davis-Charles hides her face as she is escorted from the Phnom Penh court. Hong Menea

Stronger surrogacy law anticipated

All forms of surrogacy are banned in Cambodia as the government continues to mull draft legislation to further restrict or end the practice entirely by next year.

Cambodia’s National Anti-Human Trafficking Committee vice-chair Chou Bun Eng told Al Jazeera that the government is “still thinking about how to make the new law or the amendment to the law consistent with the existing law”.

Bun Eng also said the new legislation aims to encompass every aspect of surrogate practice including in vitro fertilisation, sperm banks and the sale of breast milk.

Sam Everingham, the founder of Families Thru Surrogacy, a not-for-profit Australian organisation which aims to inform contracting parents about issues related to surrogacy including best practices, said he anticipates that the government will ban surrogacy as a whole.

“We’re hoping Cambodia moves to put some laws in place to overcome this uncertainty. It would be good for all parties to have some laws in place. In the current legal vacuum, it’s very hard for people to know what’s happening and what’s going to happen,” he said.

The government issued a prakas banning commercial surrogacy (while allowing altruistic practices), as reported by The Post in November 2016.

However, after the high-profile Tammy Davis Charles arrest in Phnom Penh weeks later uncovered an underground network of fertility agencies, clinics, impoverished surrogate mothers and Chinese nationals who contracted their services, the government banned the practice while it worked to ratify the law to curb abuse.

High Commissioner for Human Rights in Cambodia (OHCHR) country representative Simon Walker said: “In Asia, there’s been a transformation in the [global surrogacy] phenomenon because of changes in legislation. As bans moved from one country to another, interest has moved [with them].

“India banned [commercial] surrogacy, then Thailand banned it and it moved to Cambodia. Cambodia banned it and it moved to Laos . . . so we see a migration of demand in Southeast Asia.”

‘Very different approaches’

Davis Charles operated a fertility clinic in Bangkok before shifting her services to Phnom Penh. Thailand banned commercial surrogacy in 2016 and does not allow foreigners to engage in “altruistic” services.

Meanwhile, India which took a near identical approach to the issue as Thailand, passed The Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill 2016 this month.

Under the law, only prospective heterosexual Indian parents who have been married for five years may commission a “close relative” of the couple without financial compensation (except medical bills).

“There are very different approaches and not necessarily a clear thread of logic from country to country. It’s difficult to say what will happen in Cambodia. There’s no human rights position as such on surrogacy. There’s no right to surrogacy – no right to protection from surrogacy. So we look at a series of human rights [cases] in relation to the main people involved,” Walker said.

Everingham, who has two children of his own via international surrogacy, said the only position that makes sense is to entirely ban both compensated and non-compensated forms of surrogacy.

“It doesn’t really seem viable to have an altruistic model in Cambodia when most of the Cambodian population doesn’t even understand surrogacy,” Everingham said.


  • 12th Cambodia int’l film festival to see return of Hollywood star

    Phnom Penh is set to come alive with the magic of cinema as the highly anticipated 12th Cambodia International Film Festival (CIFF) takes centre stage. Boasting an impressive line-up of 188 films from 23 countries, including captivating shorts, feature films, documentaries and animation, the festival promises an

  • Brawl marrs football final as Indonesian take gold in seven goal thriller

    The Indonesian men's U22 men national football team were crowned champions of the 32nd SEA Games in Cambodia, defeating Thailand 5-2 in extra time on May 16 at Olympic National Stadium in Phnom Penh. The match was marred by an ugly incident that occured in the 91

  • Bareknuckle champion wants Kun Khmer fighter

    Dave Leduc, who is the current openweight Lethwei boxing champion in Myanmar, has announced that he will travel to Cambodia this year to challenge SEA Games gold medallist Prum Samnang any time that is convenient, after their planned match later this month in Slovakia was

  • Candlelight Party disqualified from July general election

    The National Election Committee (NEC) has disqualified the Candlelight Party (CP) from contesting the upcoming general election, citing a lack of valid documentation. NEC spokesman Khorn Keomono said the CP failed to fulfil one of the three main requirements: including original documentation proving their registration

  • Thong Khon calls for orderly SEA Games closing ceremony

    Thong Khon, Minister of Tourism and permanent vice-president of the Cambodia SEA Games Organising Committee (CAMSOC), calls on all people who have received tickets to the May 17 closing ceremony of the biennial multi-sports extravaganza at the Morodok Techo National Stadium to ensure that the event

  • 1.4 billion dollar Phnom Penh-Bavet expressway due in four years

    The Government, through the Ministry of Public Works and Transport, has officially signed a public-private partnership agreement with a private company for the construction of a Phnom Penh-Bavet Expressway project that will connect the capital to Svay Rieng province. The budget for the project is