Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - UN rapporteur Rhona Smith defends approach



UN rapporteur Rhona Smith defends approach

Prime Minister Hun Sen and UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Cambodia Rhona Smith shake hands at the peace palace during a 2015 meeting in Phnom Penh. AFP
Prime Minister Hun Sen and UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Cambodia Rhona Smith shake hands at the peace palace during a 2015 meeting in Phnom Penh. AFP

UN rapporteur Rhona Smith defends approach

UN Special Rapporteur Rhona Smith has responded to growing concerns among the human rights community that she is not fulfilling her mandate.

In the immediate wake of Kem Ley’s murder, the Post reported on growing frustration among national and international NGO representatives over what they view as Smith’s silence over serious human rights issues.

In a statement on Friday, Smith emphasised that her mandate was to provide technical assistance to the Cambodian government and insisted that while she understood civil society’s “desire to see a more vocal special rapporteur”, she “would not want for attention to myself to detract from the main issues of the day”.

In a lengthier emailed response, Smith avoided discussing specific instances in which her perceived silence had been called out, such as the jailing and prosecution of civil society members and opposition activists and lawmakers.

She addressed criticisms that the only public statement she issued over Kem Ley’s murder was co-signed by four other special rapporteurs – whose mandates are not specific to Cambodia – and came three days after his death.

“This imminent joint statement was also the reason for me not issuing a solo statement on Monday, though I replied to the press queries I received,” Smith wrote. “In my opinion, a joint press release reflected the grave concerns of several rapporteurs and was an appropriate response to such a serious high profile death.”

Smith closed by saying she is engaged in dialogue with the government on “a number of issues” and has “generally received responses from the government to all my queries.”

“There have, however, been no responses over the last year to letters of allegation and urgent appeals,” she wrote, referring to the tools available to rapporteurs to raise issues of concern with governments.

Human rights consultant Billy Tai speculated as to whether this remark hinted at a change of strategy.

“It’s as though they’ve been trying to create dialogue and they didn’t succeed, so what can they do now? We’ll have to wait and see,” he said. “I think it is very important for the rapporteur to be seen to be doing something and I don’t think she’s doing that very well.”

Rupert Abbott, the former deputy Asia director of Amnesty International, said a public back and forth on the controversy would be unhelpful, but that he hoped the message had gotten through that “a more accessible, active and vocal special rapporteur on Cambodia is needed now more than ever”.

Human Rights Watch deputy Asia director Phil Robertson – who previously said he had raised concerns with Smith to no avail – was more blunt, describing Smith’s performance in emailed comments as a “triumph of the UN form over serious human rights content”.

“While there is a technical assistance element in her mandate, she should not prioritize it over the need to monitor and speak out about the worsening human rights situation in Cambodia,” Robertson wrote. “Sadly for the people of Cambodia, so far she’s demonstrated that she’s not ready for the kind of challenges that this mandate involves.”

MOST VIEWED

  • Municipal hall releases map detailing colour coded Covid risks by commune

    Phnom Penh municipal governor Khuong Sreng released an official map detailing the red, yellow and dark yellow zones within the city under the new lockdown orders for Phnom Penh announced on April 26. The designation of red, dark yellow and yellow corresponds to areas with high,

  • Inter-provincial travel ban lifted; Phnom Penh and Takmao not exempted

    The government on April 25 decided to lift the inter-provincial travel ban and the closure of tourist attractions across the country, effectively immediately. The travel ban and closures of all resorts were imposed on April 6 and 17 respectively in a bid to curb the spread of Covid-19,

  • Phnom Penh unveils rules for post-lockdown transition

    The Phnom Penh Municipal Administration issued a set of detailed guidelines for the seven days to May 12 after the capital emerges from lockdown at the onset of May 6. In the 14-page document signed by municipal governor Khuong Sreng released on the evening of May 5, the

  • Phnom Penh, Takmao lockdown extended for another week

    The government late on April 26 announced an extension of lockdown in Phnom Penh and adjacent Takmao town in Kandal province for another seven days – or longer if residents do not comply with Covid-19 preventive measures and the community outbreak does not subside – until May 5. According

  • Gov't mulls extension of Phnom Penh, Takmao lockdown

    The Inter-ministerial National Commission for the Control and Enforcement of Lockdown held a video conference meeting on April 25 to review a draft document on the extension of lockdown in Phnom Penh and adjacent Kandal province’s Takmao town. The meeting was chaired by Minister of

  • Gov’t issues guidelines as lockdown nears end

    The government has issued a five-page set of instructions to be enforced when the three-week lockdown of Phnom Penh and adjacent Takmao town in Kandal province ends on May 6. According to an announcement signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen on May 4, the instructions cover a