Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - US denies draft bill swayed Muth probe

US denies draft bill swayed Muth probe

Alleged Khmer Rouge navy chief Meas Muth, a suspect in Case 003, reads a newspaper at his house in Battambang province in 2015.
Alleged Khmer Rouge navy chief Meas Muth, a suspect in Case 003, reads a newspaper at his house in Battambang province in 2015. Heng Chivoan

US denies draft bill swayed Muth probe

The United States Embassy has rejected allegations that language within a draft bill introduced by a US Senate committee last year sought to sway the investigation into alleged Khmer Rouge naval commander Meas Muth.

The draft language – which was later removed – was criticised in a decision by the court last week to proceed, at least for now, with the government-opposed Case 003 against Muth.

But in spite of the US denial, some, including the lawyers for the defence, contend that the “soft power” impact of the US should not be underestimated in a court that has been plagued by claims – usually directed at the Cambodian government – of outside interference.

The draft bill, sponsored by Republican Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina in July 2016, highlighted American interest in Muth by proposing to tie US contributions to his case, as he was “implicated in the 1975 Mayaguez incident”, which cost American lives.

The bill also endorsed a “plan to cease contributions” to the tribunal if Case 003 was closed.

The draft may have been a counterpoint to the Cambodian government’s open disdain for the case against Muth. Prime Minister Hun Sen, a former Khmer Rouge soldier himself, is overtly opposed to Cases 003 and 004 going ahead, and has threatened civil war would ensue if they did.

The final bill allocating funding to the court was passed in early May – the same week a “permanent stay” was proposed in Muth’s case – with the reference to Muth wiped clean from the final version.

Nonetheless, in their Friday decision to hold off on issuing a permanent stay, the judges for the first time expressed their concerns that the draft bill had put them in a double bind – indict Muth and face criticism for having “caved”, or dismiss the case and forego funding.

However, US Embassy spokesman Arend Zwartjes rejected that interpretation.

“The allegation that U.S. assistance is contingent upon issuance of any particular indictment is simply incorrect. As the order itself acknowledges, no such provision exists in U.S. law,” Zwartjes said in an email.

The US has so far contributed more than $32 million to the tribunal over the past decade, including a recent pledge of $1.5 million.

“If a single principle has guided us over that time, it is the belief that it is the responsibility of the court, not governments, to determine the fate of the Khmer Rouge defendants,” he said.

However, the idea that funds could be tethered to a certain outcome appeared firm in the judges’ minds. They wrote in the order “the only reasonable interpretation” to the draft was that the US could stop their funding altogether if they didn’t agree with the findings on Muth.

“It does not require much imagination to realise the position that the text of the original bill alone put us in,” they said.

“The version of the enacted legislation does not contain the same crude conditions as the bill but does at the end of the day do little to assuage our concerns.”

Muth’s defence lawyer, Michael Karnavas, noted that even a draft bill “does carry weight, and has the potential of interfering with judicial independence”.

“It carries the sting of soft – yet not-so-subtle – intimidation. It is hypocritical to think otherwise,” he said.

“The mere inference that funding is dependent on a particular result and not on the proper administration of justice . . . casts a dark shadow, which can, and often does, tarnish the integrity of the proceedings and the court in general.”

Expecting a guilty verdict in exchange for US investment in the tribunal does not “square with the rule of law”, he said, “but it does square with the proverbial golden rule: he who has the gold makes the rules”.

Tribunal observer Heather Ryan, of the Open Justice Society Initiative, said the language in the draft bill was “an unfortunate and inappropriate intervention by a funder of an independent court” that was fortunately recognised before the final bill.

“As with inappropriate statements from other sources, including the government of Cambodia, regarding the outcome of specific cases, hopefully the investigating judges can ignore the implications,” she said.

MOST VIEWED

  • Capital-Poipet express rail project making headway

    The preliminary results of a feasibility study to upgrade the Phnom Penh-Poipet railway into Cambodia’s first express railway indicate that the project would cost more than $4 billion and would take around four years to complete. The study was carried out by China Road and

  • Thai boxers to join SEA Games’ Kun Khmer event

    The Cambodian SEA Games Organising Committee (CAMSOC) – together with the Kun Khmer International Federation (KKIF) and Khmer Boxing Federation – have achieved a “great success” by including Kun Khmer in the upcoming biennial multi-sports event on its home soil for the first time, said a senior

  • Bullets to bracelets: Siem Reap man makes waste from war wearable

    Jewellery is often made from valuable gemstones like emeralds or diamonds and precious metals like gold or silver, or valueless things like animal horns. But a man in Siem Reap has approached the manufacture of delicate pieces from a different angle. His unique form of

  • Second Hungary business forum set for H2

    Cambodia has asked Hungary to provide GSP- (Generalised System of Preferences) Plus facilities for when the Kingdom sheds its least-developed country (LDC) label, as the two countries prepare to hold a second business forum in the second half (H2) of this year to expand trade

  • 61% of 2022 imports came from just 3 markets

    The three largest exporters to Cambodia – mainland China, Vietnam and Thailand – accounted for 60.94 per cent of the Kingdom’s total merchandise imports last year, at $18.245 billion, which was up 11.99 per cent over 2021, according to the General Department of Customs and Excise. Cambodia’s total imports

  • CPP sets out five primary strategic goals for 2023-28

    The Cambodian People’s Party (CPP) on January 29 concluded its two-day extraordinary congress, setting the party’s priority goals for 2023-2028. The ruling party’s congress was attended by more than 3,000 members from across the Kingdom, including the members of the permanent and central committees,