Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Why did they kill?




Why did they kill?

Why did they kill?

According to Alex Hinton, the Democratic Kampuchea violence was genocide both in

the "strict sense" of the Genocide Convention such as the attacks on ethnic

minorities like Cham and Vietnamese and religious groups like Buddhist monks, and

in the broad sense such as "attempts to annihilate political and economic groups"

(Post, October 7, 2005).

Hinton's assertion is wrong in law and in fact.

There is no evidence the Khmer Rouge leadership had an intent to destroy any group

based on their race, ethnicity or religion. Admittedly, some members of ethnic and

religious minority groups died during DK, but dead bodies do not necessarily equate

with genocide.

On the Chams: The notable incident occurred in 1976 in which a high-ranking DK official

was killed and a few were injured in the Cham armed rebellion in Kampong Cham. As

a result, the Cham in that the area were dispersed and those responsible apprehended.

This was a military or security response rather than conduct based on race or ethnicity.

In addition, a lot of Chams, like other ethnicities, were part of the communist revolution

and worked for the top organs of the state from the National Assembly's Permanent

Committee (Mat Ly) to the top secret state security apparatus S-21, such as Yeu Math,

Ny Sman, Tam Math and Sim Mel. True, of 14,000 S-21 prisoners, about 40 Chams were

"processed" through the prison, and about 20 of these were executed. Nothing,

including their confessions, suggested they were killed because they were Cham. Like

many other prisoners, they were arrested and sent to S-21 because of being implicated

in alleged anti-revolutionary activities. Sim Mel, who was one of the S-21 interrogators,

was executed based on the fact that he, without permission, killed many prisoners

he interrogated. His victims included Meas Ke, a director of Prince Sihanouk's Cabinet,

and a fellow KR soldier, Keng Mam. These deaths caused Duch to suspect Mel and recall

him from interrogation duties and place him in an S-21 food production unit. Implicated

by a prisoner as a traitor, he was brought back to S-21, interrogated and killed.

In regions with high Cham populations, DK created a "Khmer-Islamic Educational

Training Unit" which was usually staffed by Chams and even had their own cooperative

centers. For instance, in the eastern region there was a "Khmer-Islamic Training

Unit" attached to Region 203. Mzas Loh and Mat Ly (who also became CPP high-ranking

officials), according to their biography, were a part of the Unit. Ysa Osman, a researcher

of the Documentation Center in his Oukobah (2002) found that KR committed genocide

against Chams but the evidence he collected, such as the act of prohibiting Islamic

practices, is not evidence of genocide.

On the Buddhist monks: Contrary to Hinton's assertion, there was no evidence to suggest

that the KR had a policy or intent to destroy Buddhist monks. The temples in all

main centers remained intact. Admittedly, a few wooden temples and big houses in

remote regions were dismantled in order to use the wood for building cooperative

centers, storage and primary schools.

Immediately after the DK takeover, monks were allowed to stay in the temples but

were told to produce food and cook for themselves. This was a main factor causing

them to disrobe and become farmers/workers like the rest of the society. Forced disrobing

and prohibition of religious practice are not crimes under the Genocide Convention.

True, some of them died from the harsh conditions, but this kind of death is not

genocide.

On the Vietnamese: They were allowed to leave the country without harm. About 400,000

left by the end of 1976, although an unknown number remained. When border conflicts

intensified in 1977, public anti-Vietnamese rhetoric began to emerge through state

media, but it was meant for the enemy over the border. Admittedly, there were a number

of Vietnamese killed in response to the coup plot in mid 1977. Again, this was a

response to a security threat and not because of their ethnic background. Ben Kiernan's

evidence of the central genocidal policy against Vietnamese was his interview with

a layperson who claimed to have seen a top secret "Directive from 870, (the

CPK Center)": (Pol Pot Regime, p269), that "instructed local officials

to arrest all ethnic Vietnamese..." In fact, there was no "Directive from

870" because the Office 870 did not issue either that alleged directive or directives

of that nature.

Alex Hinton is incorrect to claim that (1) killing of political and economic groups

is also genocide in the "broad sense" of the convention, and (2) that most

scholars of genocide agree.

The Travaux Préparatoires of the Genocide Convention demonstrate that destroying

groups based on political affiliation or economics was expressly excluded from the

convention. Although scholar Beth Van Schaack (1997) argues that destruction of political

groups constitutes genocide based on a higher law or jus cogens, even she did not

attempt to argue that politicide is a crime under the convention, in any sense. Her

problem is, however, that genocide is a treaty-based crime and as such the Vienna

Convention on the Law of Treaties applies. This convention does not allow "smart"

or broad interpretation of a treaty - either something is in the treaty or it is

out.

In the case of Cambodia, such incorporation of politicide would be contrary to current

jurisprudence on genocide and the terms of the convention. It would be a retroactive

move, an act that is prohibited by the 1993 Constitution and the Paris Accords 1991.

Bora Touch, Sydney

MOST VIEWED

  • PM: West unfair to Cambodia

    Prime Minister Hun Sen released a message celebrating the International Day of Peace on Monday, saying that some major powers and western countries had been systemically cooperating to put political pressure on Cambodia as they did in the 1970s and 1980s. Hun Sen said pressuring

  • ‘Bad news is an investor’s best friend’ – unlocking investment potential in Cambodia

    It is time to shop. Economic woes provide good pickings for investors if they know where to look The poem If, written by English Nobel laureate poet and novelist Rudyard Kipling for his son circa 1895, is widely perceived as fatherly advice for John who would

  • First ‘mobile kitchen’ in Cambodia enters service

    A catering company recently rolled out Cambodia’s first “mobile kitchen” – a $50,000 container capable of serving up to 200 people at a time. The kitchen is the brainchild of Seng Hok Heng Catering Services. At 4.4m-high, 6.8m-long and 2.4m-wide (expandable to 6.8m), the kitchen is equipped

  • Kingdom, China rebut basis for US sanctions

    The Council for the Development of Cambodia, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, and Tianjin Union Investment Development Group Co Ltd (Tianjin) have responded to US sanctions on Union Development Group Co Ltd (UDG), a Chinese-owned company currently developing the sprawling $3.8 billion Dara

  • PM requests Russia’s Covid vaccine

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has requested that Russia provide Cambodia with its Covid-19 vaccine after the former announced it planned on mass vaccinating its population next month. The request came on Thursday through the prime minister’s Facebook page as he met with Anatoly Borovik,

  • Influenza breaks out in eight provinces

    Nearly 600 people have been infected with influenza in eight provinces in the past month, Ministry of Health spokesperson Or Vandine said. The ministry is advising extreme caution. A report released by Vandine on Saturday said the Ministry of Health observed transmissions of influenza between August 15