Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Why were bullets fired at workers?

Why were bullets fired at workers?

Why were bullets fired at workers?

Three days after a 24-year-old mother was shot in the back while fleeing a violent

police crackdown on a garment worker protest, an air of intimidation still surrounds

the small village outside the Suntex factory group compound.

On October 19, military police remained on patrol with riot shields, electric batons

and automatic weapons, angrily dispersing any gatherings of more than three people

that formed. Local motodop drivers had been forced from their usual locations, and

groups of young garment workers, laid off after the protests, scattered when the

armed patrols approach. Phnom Police Chief Touch Naruth confirmed that he has 40

intervention police and a fire engine stationed at the site over concerns that the

1,020 fired employees would torch the building.

The usually quiet industrial area on Veng Streng Road, just south of Phnom Penh,

retains the pall of a battle zone-and residents, activists and international labor

officials are demanding to know why bullets and batons were required to quell what

began as a dispute over work contracts.

Meanwhile, the factory's owner, as well as garment industry and government officials,

are scrambling to provide explanations for what Neil Kearney, general secretary of

the International Textile, Garment and Leather Workers' Federation, has called "appalling

police brutality."

On the evening of October 16, a call from the management of Suntex's Bright Sky factory

brought a hundreds-strong swarm of military police who descended on the compound

to pacify protesting Bright Star workers. At the time, the managers claimed the group

was becoming unruly and damaging factory property.

"At about 6 pm I called [Free Trade Union President] Chea Mony and said the

workers aren't working. I asked him to come and take a look," said Bright Sky

manager Albert Tan, an ethnic Chinese Singaporean citizen who has been in Cambodia

for ten years. "Then things got worse, so I called GMAC [Garment Manufacturer's

Association of Cambodia], the Ministry of Labor and the police."

Tan told the Post that after several hours the protesters who did not depart peacefully

were pushed out of the compound by the police using riot shields.

According to Tan, protesters then hurled bottles and rocks into the compound. The

projectiles prompted the police, with a single whistle call to warn the crowd, to

burst from the compound firing AK47s into the air above the mob. But, protesters,

union officials, residents and food vendors outside the factory told the Post that

the police also shot directly into the crowd. And Chi Samon, president of the Free

Trade Union at Bright Sky, provided a completely different account.

"Military police and police started shocking and shooting workers from 8:30

pm to 11 pm. Before this about 20 to 30 workers were locked inside the factory while

about 3,000 were outside the factory gates. The workers outside knocked on the door

for the factory because they were afraid the police were beating them," said

Samon, who also led a March protest at Bright Sky that also resulted in violence

and police intervention. "Three people were shot-one in the stomach, one in

the leg and the other in the foot. And about 40 were shocked by the electric batons.

To tell the truth, the workers did not throw rocks at the police because there are

no rocks there. The workers were striking peacefully."

But Ken Loo, secretary general of GMAC, called the use of force "appropriate

and necessary," and suggested that garment workers can be threatening and rebellious.

"Protesters aren't as peaceful or coy as the unions might like you to believe.

It's easy for workers to say they are afraid of police, but are they really as innocent

as they seem?" Loo said. "These workers can be pretty menacing at times.

You would think that they, as young girls are meek and mild, but the reality is that

in the factory it is not only young girls. There are plenty of male counterparts

and Cambodian crowds are easily incited."

Speaking from her bed in Preah Kossamak Hospital surrounded by her family and three-year-old

daughter, garment factory worker Muth Savy explained that she was working a night-shift

in the Rainbow Factory, next door to Bright Sky.

"When I came out of the factory, I saw police and Flying Tiger police shooting

over the workers and hitting them with electric batons," said Savy. "I

was very frightened, so I hid at the factory gate. But then the police started shooting

lots of bullets, and I got really frightened, so I decided to run home. When I was

running I felt something in my back. I ran for another 20 meters and then fell to

the ground. I got up again, but now I felt a lot of pain, so I ran into a house next

to the compound."

Savy had to ask the owner of the house what had happened to her.

"When I looked at her back, I saw there was a hole in it," said the owner

who refused to give her name, as did all other villagers and workers spoken to by

the Post.

"Many factory workers were brought unconscious to my house after they had been

shocked with electric batons."

A food seller outside the compound gate, who would not speak to the Post until a

military police patrol had passed, said protesters outside the compound saw police

inside the compound beating female workers until they bled.

Bright Sky's Tan said however that it was the protesters throwing rocks and bottles

into the compound that caused the police to leave the compound and start shooting

into the air. Tan presented a company video of the protest as evidence. Although

mainly dim and unclear, it showed objects hurtling over the wall into the compound,

landing on police and security guards.

According to Tan, Rainbow Factory has agreed to pay all medical expenses, has already

compensated Savy's family $500 and will will pay her full salary for the next three


Khieu Sopheak, spokesman for the Ministry of Interior, said October 19 that authorities

do not believe Savy was shot by the police, but by another group instead. He conceded

that nothing could be assumed until the police inquiry concluded.

"We are now still continuing the investigation over the shooting," said

Naruth. "We'll investigate where the bullet came from, what kind of bullet it

was and who the gun belonged to."

The Cambodian Human Rights Action Committee (CHRAC) has blasted the violent police

tactics used to calm what the group has called "a peaceful strike made by garment

factory workers while they were asserting their rights for better working conditions."

"CHRAC maintains that the action committed by the armed forces seriously violates

human rights as well as national and international laws, especially curtailing the

freedom of expression of the workers," reads a statement released by the CHRAC.

But such strong talk is little solace to Savy's father, Trov Lun.

"We are from the provinces and plant rice to make a living. In my district police

come to help and arrest criminals," he said. "But here in Phnom Penh police

are very cruel. Why would they shoot innocent people like my daughter? How can we

learn to be better people with such a bad example as that?"


  • UN bodies call for drug centre closure

    Thirteen UN entities on Monday issued a joint statement calling on countries in Asia and the Pacific to close all compulsory drug detention and rehabilitation centres to prevent the spread of Covid-19 and other diseases and some forms of human rights violations. The group includes

  • Man on run after family murder

    A mother and daughter were found dead amid a pile of burnt rubble after a house in Thma Koul district’s Bonsai Treng commune in Battambang burned down at 1:40am on Sunday. District police chief Phong Sopheap told The Post on Monday that Kim Thoeun, 52,

  • Racism a ‘chronic disease’ in the US

    China said on Monday that the ongoing civil unrest in the US highlighted its severe problems of racism and police violence, and exposed Washington’s double standards in supporting Hong Kong’s protesters. “Black people’s lives are also lives. Their human rights must also

  • VN PM targets prosperous status for key southern economic region by 2035

    Vietnamese Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc on Saturday asked the southern key economic region to strive to become a powerful and prosperous region by 2035, 10 years ahead of the deadline for the same goal for the whole nation. He made the remarks while chairing a meeting

  • Thai MPs push $60B Covid-19 aid package through Parliament

    A covid-19 financial aid package sailed through Thailand’s House of Representatives on Sunday but opposition Members of Parliament (MPs) attacked the 1.9 trillion baht ($60 billion) aid as mostly benefiting big businesses. After five days of debate, the lower house voted in favour of the package

  • Indonesia backtracks on decision to relax wood export terms

    Indonesia has backtracked on a decision to relax export requirements for timber products months after issuing a deregulation policy that environmental groups criticised for threatening to put sustainable timber trade at risk. On May 11, the Ministry of Trade issued a regulation annulling its previous regulation