Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Could data help warn us of dengue outbreaks?

Could data help warn us of dengue outbreaks?

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Doctors treat a patient at the Kantha Bopha hospital in Phnom Penh. post pix

Could data help warn us of dengue outbreaks?

In the Philippines more than 622 people – most of whom were children under five years old – have died from dengue so far this year.

The country is seeing more than 5,100 new cases each week.

In at least one province, tents are serving as makeshift treatment centres to deal with the crush of patients.

The Philippines declared the outbreak a National Epidemic in August.

The Philippines isn’t alone.

In Bangladesh, the dengue outbreak is the country’s worst ever.

The sheer number of dengue patients – some days there are more than 2,000 new cases in just a 24 hour period – is placing immense strain on health systems.

There’s been a shortage of the quick-test kits that are able to detect early stages of dengue. Demand for blood and platelets is reportedly outstripping the supply at many donation centres.

In Cambodia, representatives of one hospital say the outbreak has the potential to be the worst they have seen since the hospital opened 20 years ago.

Angkor Hospital for Children has treated more than 2,937 dengue patients thus far in 2019 – 42 per cent more than the same period in 2012, which was previously the hospital’s worst dengue year on record.

And the cases are more severe than normal.

“Usually with dengue, the severe cases are around 10 per cent of admissions,” Dr Ngeth Pises, Angkor Hospital’s medical director, told Asia News Network.

“But this year, more than 50 per cent of cases have been hospitalised. We have seen more serious cases than ever.”

The hospital is running out of room for patients, and has resorted to setting up mattresses on hallway floors.

Not all dengue years are this bad.

One of the key hallmarks of the disease is that peak outbreak years come in cycles, usually around three to four years apart.

But scientists don’t fully understand why that is or, even more crucially, how to predict when and where a major outbreak is coming.

And that means that even where dengue has long been endemic, places like the Philippines, Bangladesh and Cambodia can be caught off guard.

That’s partly to do with the unique ways the dengue virus works.

But it’s also partly because of issues with our data collection – to predict dengue, we need better data and more of it.

Mathematical modelling

Richard Maude is the head of the Epidemiology Department at Mahidol-Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit.

His Bangkok-based team provides support to the governments in Thailand and Myanmar, and indirectly in the Philippines.

One of the forms that support takes is mathematical modelling.

The team is using new approaches to account for variables that have otherwise been difficult to account for – the movement of people, for example – to develop models intended to predict future dengue outbreaks.

To create a Thailand-specific model that takes humans and their comings and goings into account, Maude and his team turned to the data-creation devices we all keep in our pockets – our mobile phones.

Maude’s team took data from Thai phone users that has been scrubbed of identifying information, turned that information into matrices of

how much people are moving and plugged it into a model that cross-

references that data with the locations where the dengue virus has cropped up over time.

The real measure of success for a model like this one, Maude said, is that “these predictions have to be good enough that the government could then use it to make a plan, to act on the predictions”.

If governments know when a bad year is coming, for example, they might be able to prevent the shortages of dengue tests and hospital beds that are happening right now in Cambodia, Bangladesh and the Philippines.

But there’s a lot of work that still has to be done before a model like this one can be used in that way.

“The performance of these predictive models is good in some locations and it’s not so good in others, and you end up with lots of different models that work in different areas,” Maude said.

So far, “there is no single predictive model that will accurately predict dengue”.

“One of the reasons for that,” Maude explained, “is because there are multiple different factors affecting the likelihood of having a dengue epidemic and those factors are not necessarily well understood.”

And, complicating the matter further, factors that logically should indicate increased risk of dengue don’t always work in predictable ways.

For example: “We know you can get large numbers of dengue mosquitoes [in this case Aedes aegypti] and then not have lots of dengue in some places, it doesn’t always follow,” Maude said.

Maybe the biggest problem holding these predictive models back is the data.

“We know about rainfall driving mosquito numbers, we know that people spread dengue when they travel around,” Maude said.

“But there’s also things that we are not able to include – like immunity to dengue over time in the population.”

Immunity

Data about population immunity are critical to predicting how dengue will circulate through a community, as well as how severe those cases will turn out to be.

Patients who recover from an infection of one dengue serotype will have lifelong immunity against that particular strand of the virus.

But subsequent infection by other serotypes increases the risk that person will develop severe dengue.

But, unhelpfully, data about immunity just aren’t collected routinely enough to be accounted for in these models.

Likewise, reliable data about the prevalence of dengue’s four unique strains, or serotypes, are hard for researchers like Maude to come by.

In fact, according to Maude: “Most countries only have a minority of people who have information on what serotype they have. That’s limited trying to develop models using that data up to now.”

Data about climate – temperature, rainfall, et cetera – can be spotty and, on a very basic level, the data about dengue cases aren’t always reliable.

The number of cases can be overstated – in health systems that choose to treat dengue-like symptoms without actually testing for dengue – and understated – in places where people have the virus but don’t seek treatment.

Maude is quick to point out that gaps in the dengue data aren’t necessarily the fault of any one country’s dengue control programme.

“It’s the whole health system and the population that are responsible for that data,” Maude said.

To get complete and accurate data, Maude says scientists are, in essence “relying on huge numbers of people to do something consistently”.

A big ask, even in the best conditions.

There’s just no incentive for every single doctor to report every single case of dengue.

As Maude puts it, data collection “is just more work”.

Are any countries already using prediction models to anticipated dengue outbreaks?

The only government Maude is aware of that’s already putting predictive models to use is Singapore.

One model developed in Singapore with the help of machine learning was able to forecast major dengue outbreaks in 2013 and 2014 more than 10 weeks in advance, allowing the government to prepare hospital beds, diagnostic kits and deploy extra personnel for on-the-ground mosquito control and community outreach.

The city-state has used information from this predictive model in part to mobilise information campaigns to ramp up awareness of dengue when the data forecast a bad year.

“The model allows us to confidently warn the public that there could be an outbreak coming,” said Dr Ng Lee Ching, who is the director of Singapore’s National Environment Agency, in a 2016 journal article on this particular predictive model.

“It’s very difficult to be alert at all times. You get fatigued. The public messaging can’t be done all the time, [so] the model suggests when to intensify our message or to mobilise the community.”

But Singapore has a few key advantages – very high quality data about a very small geographical area.

In the case of other countries, “how well [these models] work depends on what the data in each country look like, what’s available and the format of that information”.

Until data availability and data accuracy improve, innovations in the prediction space will be slow to come.

Quinn Libson/Asia News Network

MOST VIEWED

  • Draft law on state of emergency pending finalisation

    Prime Minister Hun Sen will lead a top-level meeting on Tuesdays to review the draft law on imposing a state of emergency. Meantime, he has decided to close all casinos in Cambodia effective April 1. In the press conference after the National Assembly met today, Hun

  • State of emergency on table amid pandemic

    Prime Minister Hun Sen, his deputy prime ministers and legal team will meet on Tuesday to review the draft law on declaring a state of emergency, as Covid-19 cases rose to 107 in the Kingdom on Monday. Speaking at a press conference after a parliament meeting

  • Stranded passengers petition UK for help

    Some 10,521 people have signed an online petition calling on British Prime Minister Boris Johnson and relevant officials to fly nearly 200 passengers out of Cambodia. The petition is targeted at 15,000 people. Most of the passengers are British nationals, who are stranded in Cambodia after airlines cancelled

  • No word on state of emergency

    The National Assembly (NA) said it will postpone all unnecessary meetings in line with guidance from the Ministry of Health and the World Health Organisation (WHO) amid the Covid-19 pandemic. However, it did not say when or how it will debate the “state of emergency”

  • Many in limbo as tension heightens

    As the Kingdom restricts travel and prepares for a state of emergency, some foreigners in Cambodia are scrambling for a way home. Foreign embassies in Phnom Penh are making efforts to get their citizens out, but cancelled flights have become common due to the coronavirus

  • Covid-19 Pandemic: Force majeure and legal consequences

    Is the Covid-19 pandemic considered an event of force majeure? The World Health Organisation declared the novel coronavirus (Covid-19) outbreak a pandemic on March 11. Following this declaration, the Ministry of Health and other ministries have taken various legal and administrative measures to prevent the rapid