Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - I see your counterpunch and raise you several shots to the foot


I see your counterpunch and raise you several shots to the foot

I see your counterpunch and raise you several shots to the foot

A man looks at a map of Democratic Kampuchea made by skulls and bones
A man looks at a map of Democratic Kampuchea made by skulls and bones. Photograph: REUTERS

Doing the rounds of the Post’s email server this week was an article in the latest edition of Counterpunch, the United States’ go-to online newsletter for burnt-out lefty curmudgeondom. Penned by Israel Shamir—known for his Chicken Little warnings about the dreaded Jews being responsible for everything from the dreadful standards of daytime television to the use of high-fructose corn syrup in soda—“Pol Pot Revisited” takes what could be described as a rosier view of the Khmer Rouge era than what the general consensus dictates.

“Surprisingly,” Shamir writes, “Cambodians have no bad memories of that period. This is quite an amazing discovery for an infrequent visitor.”

Oh really? I guess those civil parties at the tribunal are just trolling proceedings for their own amusement. We’d be curious to know who Mr. Shamir’s been speaking with. Has he been catching up with Nuon Chea over panini and lattes in the ECCC cafeteria? Do his brief Cambodian sojourns take place exclusively in a few isolated villages in Anlong Veng? Has he been channelling the ghost of Ta Mok through a ouija board?*

Sadly, we don’t know, as Shamir has decided to be coy about his sources – presumably in the fear that government cadres would come for them in the middle of the night, lock them up in an abandoned school, subject them to weeks of beatings, torture and coprophagia before making them sign false confessions and shooting them in a field on the outskirts of the capital. Whoops! We’re confusing our regimes again.

We must admit we were swayed when Shamir provided conclusive proof that the KR genocides were either inept or out-and-out fabrications: he alerted us to the fact that the population of Cambodia has doubled since 1970. We eagerly await his next Counterpunch article, “Population of Europe has increased by a factor of six since 1939, therefore World War II never happened.”

There are certain things you can do as an outsider in Cambodia. You can ask, if the world is supposedly committed to justice here, why hasn’t Henry Kissinger been strung upside down in a public square and given the Mussolini treatment? You can lament the rapacious capitalism of the last two decades and you can be outraged at its excesses. You can despair at the development programs and businesses which have institutionalised the presence of western carpetbaggers, making their services indispensable and perpetuating a gravy train instead of gradually handing over knowledge and control to locals.

Then, there are those that dare to dream, as Shamir does. If you’re one of the people who never met an anti-Western putsch you didn’t like, and if you had a casual disregard for overwhelming empirical evidence, you could go down the Chomsky route. After all, it wouldn’t be the first time some blowhard decided to speak on behalf of the people of this country.

No doubt everyone with fond memories of tilling the earth with the proverbial gun in their back for a bowl of rice a day** will be toasting the name of Israel Shamir tonight. Finally, some authoritative balance in the whole debate over whether or not the Khmer Rouge regime was pathologically fucking insane!

*One line in the article reads: “In order to listen to the other side, I travelled to the Killing Fields of Choeung Ek, the memorial where the alleged victims were killed and buried.” So we’re assuming Shamir at least has some rudimentary ability in speaking to the dead.

**Except the days they exported most of the rice harvest to China in exchange for assault weapons, amirite?

For more information about this article please contact our 7Days editor Sean Gleeson at: [email protected]

MOST VIEWED

  • Second Hungary business forum set for H2

    Cambodia has asked Hungary to provide GSP- (Generalised System of Preferences) Plus facilities for when the Kingdom sheds its least-developed country (LDC) label, as the two countries prepare to hold a second business forum in the second half (H2) of this year to expand trade

  • Capital-Poipet express rail project making headway

    The preliminary results of a feasibility study to upgrade the Phnom Penh-Poipet railway into Cambodia’s first express railway indicate that the project would cost more than $4 billion and would take around four years to complete. The study was carried out by China Road and

  • Thai boxers to join SEA Games’ Kun Khmer event

    The Cambodian SEA Games Organising Committee (CAMSOC) – together with the Kun Khmer International Federation (KKIF) and Khmer Boxing Federation – have achieved a “great success” by including Kun Khmer in the upcoming biennial multi-sports event on its home soil for the first time, said a senior

  • Bullets to bracelets: Siem Reap man makes waste from war wearable

    Jewellery is often made from valuable gemstones like emeralds or diamonds and precious metals like gold or silver, or valueless things like animal horns. But a man in Siem Reap has approached the manufacture of delicate pieces from a different angle. His unique form of

  • 61% of 2022 imports came from just 3 markets

    The three largest exporters to Cambodia – mainland China, Vietnam and Thailand – accounted for 60.94 per cent of the Kingdom’s total merchandise imports last year, at $18.245 billion, which was up 11.99 per cent over 2021, according to the General Department of Customs and Excise. Cambodia’s total imports

  • CPP sets out five primary strategic goals for 2023-28

    The Cambodian People’s Party (CPP) on January 29 concluded its two-day extraordinary congress, setting the party’s priority goals for 2023-2028. The ruling party’s congress was attended by more than 3,000 members from across the Kingdom, including the members of the permanent and central committees,