Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Smart calls for tax transparency

Smart calls for tax transparency

A woman stands under a Cellcard umbrella next to a Smart promotional billboard yesterday in Phnom Penh.
A woman stands under a Cellcard umbrella next to a Smart promotional billboard yesterday in Phnom Penh. Pha Lina

Smart calls for tax transparency

The annual presentation of mobile operator Smart Axiata’s sustainability report yesterday highlighted the company’s tax compliance and contributions, while suggesting more could be done to improve transparency and level the playing field in the telecom sector, where a price war has been escalating since the start of the year.

According to its 2015-2016 sustainability report, Smart generated $262.8 million in revenue in 2016, up by 46 percent since two years earlier in 2014, with its subscriber base growing by 24.6 percent to 8.1 million during that time.

The company’s presentation claimed that by calculating all relevant business activity, Smart contributed $313 million to the Cambodian economy last year, roughly equalling 1.6 percent of GDP.

Thomas Hundt, CEO of Smart Axiata, stated that his firm was one of the largest taxpayers in Cambodia, paying over $65 million in taxes last year, while abiding to international accounting and reporting principles as Axiata, its Malaysian parent company, is a publicly listed firm.

“[Smart] is amongst the largest taxpayers in the country, standing at a whopping contribution of 3.6 percent of national tax income last year,” he said during the presentation to an audience that included high-ranking government officials. “That is clear evidence that Smart has always taken our national responsibilities very seriously – something our customers and shareholders can be proud of.”

He added, however, that Smart’s level of transparency and accountability was not something applied universally across the local telecom sector, which includes six network operators: Smart, Metfone, Cellcard, qb, Seatel and Cootel.

Smart is the only Cambodian mobile operator to post its financials and tax obligations, although Viettel, the Vietnamese army-owned parent company of Metfone, often provides some figures on its Cambodian operations.

“At this moment I would like to highlight the importance and desire for transparency, and certainly also a level playing field amongst all industry players that is not given to the full extent at this moment,” Hundt said.

A price war has been brewing since the beginning of the year, with some network operators offering deep discounts for on-network voice and data services. In January, the telecom regulator called CamGSM, the operator of Cellcard, in for questioning over concerns of predatory pricing after the firm offered an exchange of $1 for $100 worth of voice and data coverage.

Smart responded two weeks later by offering heavily discounted promotional rates that offered subscribers to exchange $1 for $125 worth of voice and data service, while Seatel soon rolled out its own promotional offer to exchange $2 for $2,000 worth of calls and $1 for 2.7 gigabytes of data.

While the Telecommunications Regulator of Cambodia (TRC) has held numerous industry meetings in an effort to end the heavily discounted deals, none of the operators have relented, insisting that the offers are commercially viable while launching even deeper discounts.

Ieng Sunly, undersecretary of state at the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF), said the government has legitimate concerns about how much revenue the sector will generate this year.

“While affordability is an important aspect to accessibility of services in Cambodia, it should not come at the cost of impacting the sector and government negatively,” he said. “However, we of course have no intention to harm the operators in Cambodia so we are trying to negotiate with them to see what is best to balance national income.”

While Sunly encouraged other telecom operators to follow Smart’s lead in operating transparently and paying the appropriate levels of tax, he stopped short of calling out other operators for non-transparent business practices.

“When we talk about equality for the operators in Cambodia, especially regarding tax, I encourage Smart to not care about other operators if they do not pay on time or don’t follow the regulations because we are doing the best we can for the industry,” he said.

Kan Channmeta, secretary of state at MPTC, encouraged operators to adopt transparent corporate governance practices to ensure a level playing field across the sector.

“We want transparency from both the government and companies so that we can see the benefits the industry has on the economy and for creating jobs,” he said. “More companies should have events like this to show how they operate transparently.”

The original version of this article mischaracterised Smart CEO Thomas Hundt's remarks by saying he claimed authorities were “complicit” in allowing an unfair playing field to flourish in the telecom sector. While the company suggested the sector did not have a level playing field, it was not directly stated that authorities were “complicit” in this. The company has since indicated that its presentation did not state or imply criticism of the government, but rather “promoted the importance of a level playing field and transparency amongst our peers”. The Post has reworded the article’s lead in this version to more accurately reflect this, and apologises for the error.

MOST VIEWED

  • South Korea’s first lady brings hope to ill boy

    South Korea’s first lady Kim Keon-hee – wife of current president of the Republic of Korea, Yoon Suk Yeol – met with a 14-year-boy with congenital heart disease during her trip to the Kingdom for the ASEAN Summit. After their meeting it was announced that the

  • Hun Sen gets Covid, shuns G20, APEC summits

    Prime Minister Hun Sen said he has tested positive for Covid-19 in Indonesia, where he is slated to attend the G20 summit in his capacity of the ASEAN chair. In a social media post addressing the Cambodian public, he said: “Before leaving Cambodia, I always

  • Moody’s sets outlook rating to ‘negative’ for Cambodia

    US global rating agency Moody’s Investors Service Inc on November 15 announced that it downgraded Cambodia’s outlook from “stable” to “negative” and maintained its B2 local and foreign currency issuer ratings. “The negative outlook reflects a deteriorating external position as illustrated by the severe

  • Hun Sen’s Covid infection caused by ‘weakened antibody’ after summit

    Prime Minister Hun Sen said exhaustion from heavy workload before and during the recent ASEAN Summit may have led to him contracting Covid-19 due to his weakened immune system, while rejecting speculations that the infection was caused by leaders of some countries who did not

  • Korean first lady paves way for ill boy’s surgery

    A 14-year-old boy with congenital heart disease who was lucky enough to meet with South Korean first lady Kim Keon-hee may get the chance of a lifetime and receive surgery and treatment at Asan Medical Center in Seoul, South Korea. After seeing his plight, many

  • Kingdom’s rice crowned world’s No1

    Cambodia’s Phka Rumduol jasmine variety has been crowned the World’s Best Rice for the fifth time at the TRT (The Rice Trader) World Rice Conference in Phuket, Thailand on November 17, according to leaders of the Kingdom’s apex rice industry body. Phka Rumduol