Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Superheroes vs cinema? Scorsese ‘art’ row divides Hollywood

Superheroes vs cinema? Scorsese ‘art’ row divides Hollywood

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Robert Downey Jr accepts the Choice Action Movie Actor award for Avengers: Endgame at the Teen Choice Awards 2019 on August 11 in Hermosa Beach, California. (inset) Martin Scorsese attends the SFFILM premiere of The Irishman on Tuesday at the Castro Theatre in San Francisco. AFP

Superheroes vs cinema? Scorsese ‘art’ row divides Hollywood

Martin Scorsese’s dismissal of Marvel films as “not cinema” has split Hollywood and moviegoers, sparking reactions from full-blooded support to accusations of hypocrisy and elitism.

The Oscar-winning American-Italian director penned a New York Times op-ed this week in which he argued that superhero blockbusters lack the sense of risk, mystery and complex characters vital to the “art” of filmmaking.

Marvel films are “market-researched, audience-tested, vetted, modified, revetted and remodified until they’re ready for consumption,” wrote the Goodfellas director.

“They lack something essential to cinema – the unifying vision of an individual artist,” Scorsese added, fuelling a controversy he initiated in a magazine interview last month.

Fellow luminaries such as Francis Ford Coppola, Ken Loach and Fernando Meirelles have backed Scorsese, with Coppola even calling the record-breaking Marvel franchise “despicable.”

Top Hollywood film critics have also endorsed the auteur’s position.

“Scorsese is basically a film climatologist, pointing out a sinister change we can all see with our own eyes,” tweeted David Ehrlich, senior film critic of Indiewire.

“Glad he said this, sad he had to,” he added.

But the rejection of film’s highest-grossing franchise has provoked debate in Hollywood about what constitutes “art”, and who gets to define it – not least because of Scorsese’s admission that he has only “tried to watch a few of them”.

“That’s just not good enough – you can’t dismiss an entire genre as uncinematic without watching them,” said Tom Nunan, an Oscar-winning producer and professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) School of Theatre, Film and Television.

“People have always been vocal when they see change going on and it makes them uncomfortable,” Nunan (Crash, 2006) said, pointing to the arrival of 1970s smash hits like Jaws and Star Wars.

“No one has ever had the nerve to just dismiss the arena – blockbuster-worthy films – as uncinematic.”

‘Knee-jerk reaction’

Bob Iger, CEO of Marvel parent company Disney, last month described Scorsese’s original comments as “so disrespectful to all the people that work on those films.”

“Anyone who has seen a Marvel film could not in all truth make that statement,” Iger later told the BBC.

Natalie Portman, who has appeared in several Marvel films and will star in the next Thor movie, told the Hollywood Reporter there was “not one way to make art.”

But those rebuttals were nothing compared to the fury from Marvel’s army of fans, who have taken to social media to vent their rage.

Countless tweets have painted Scorsese as elitist, with many pointing to box office figures showing nine Marvel films in the 25 top-grossing movies of all time.

Marvel lovers say that to fully enjoy all-time record holder Avengers: Endgame, you need to have seen the preceding 21 movies, due to their interconnected storylines and characters.

“What’s happened over time is there’s a knee-jerk reaction of the old guard in Hollywood,” said University of Southern California adjunct professor Gene Del Vecchio.

“Filmmakers today have changed the artistry – they’ve expanded the artistry.”

Del Vecchio believes audience tastes have broadened to accept genres like sci-fi and fantasy, while the establishment’s have shrunk.

“The artists of old aren’t accepting that because they are used to a much more narrow definition of art,” he said.

“They have been left behind as audiences and new filmmakers have gone forward.”

‘God of cinema?’

Fuelling the controversy is the release of The Irishman, Scorsese’s $160 million-budget crime epic, by streaming giant Netflix.

In his op-ed, Scorsese said the distinction between Marvel and “cinema” matters

because superhero sequels are crowding auteurs out of movie theatres – the place “where the filmmaker intended her or his picture to be seen.”

The Irishman is currently in theatres, but only for a relatively miniscule 26-day window before it shifts to Netflix’s small-screen streaming platform. Endgame, by comparison, was still showing in picture houses four months after its release.

Netflix “allowed us to make The Irishman the way we needed to,” wrote Scorsese.

“Would I like the picture to play on more big screens for longer periods of time? Of course I would,” he added.

But Nunan described Scorsese’s position as “hypocritical at minimum”.

“When did he become the god of cinema? He’s in business with the very company that many people accuse of destroying cinema.”


  • Rainsy stopped in Paris from boarding Thai flight

    Airline officials at Paris’ Charles de Gaulle airport on Thursday prevented Sam Rainsy from boarding his flight to Bangkok ahead of his announced return to Cambodia on Saturday. Prime Minister Hun Sen had earlier in the day assured Phnom Penh residents that there would be

  • Analyst: Rainsy blocked from boarding flight 'an excuse'

    THAI Airways not allowing Sam Rainsy on its route from Paris to Bangkok on Thursday is being used as an excuse to keep his standing among fellow coup plotters and his uninformed supporters as flights to non-Asean countries are available, an analyst said on Friday.

  • Rainsy lands in Malaysia

    Cambodian opposition figure Sam Rainsy arrived in Kuala Lumpur airport on Saturday afternoon after boarding a flight from Paris, where he has been living for more than four years. Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation spokesperson Koy Kuong said on Saturday that Cambodia respected

  • Touch: Rainsy will never return

    Sam Rainsy, the “acting president” of the Supreme Court-dissolved Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP), has claimed it has achieved 70 per cent of its struggle to find a solution to the current political situation in the Kingdom. Just before boarding a plane at Charles de Gaulle

  • Sokha continues call for dropping of charge after bail conditions reduced

    Not satisfied with having his bail conditions reduced, allowing him to travel freely in Cambodia, Kem Sokha says he wants his charge totally dropped. “As an innocent man who has been in detention for two years even without being found guilty, I continue to demand

  • MEPs' call for Rainsy's safety not European Parliament position

    The European Parliament said on Friday that a statement by 56 Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) calling for guarantees of Sam Rainsy’s freedom and safety should he return to Cambodia did not represent its position. Delphine Colard, the European Parliament’s press officer told