Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Accusations fly

Accusations fly

Accusations fly

Philip Short accuses me of "unworthy tactics" (Phnom Penh Post, February 25 - March 10, 2005) because I expressed some criticism of his book about Pol Pot, although I had qualified it as "fascinating". I still do. It is a master-piece of journalism and so fascinating that it tends to overpower the reader's critical sense.

A basic criticism to apply to any work concerns the author's choice of sources. Mr. Short disqualifies Ieng Sary, Pol Pot and other leaders of Democratic Kampuchea as liars. Yet he often quotes them. Just one example. He writes that Ieng Sary told him that on April 17, 1975, Politburo member Le Duc Tho had asked for free passage through Cambodia for Vietnamese troops on their final offensive on Saigon (p. 4). But why should their armies make a detour into Cambodia, when they were already approaching Saigon? The roads lay open after they had taken Ban Me Thuot in March, and the Saigon army was on a panicky retreat. Mr. Short accepts Ieng Sary's statement unreflectingly. But it should invite reflections, as Democratic Kampuchea's leaders draw an important conclusion of their victory preceding that of the Vietnamese communists by 13 days: They were the first in the world to defeat U.S. imperialism, and they were a model for the world. This hubris became an important element in their thinking.

Mr. Short disqualifies me as unable to discuss Cambodia's history calmly and rationally. I am sorry, but I cannot see the rationality in explaining the atrocities of the Pol Pot regime by a Khmer "national character" and slumbering "savage forces and disconcerting cruelties which may blaze up in outbreaks of passionate brutality." Shall we tell the traumatized survivors of the "killing fields" that they are part of a culture of "appalling cruelties"?

Maud Sundqvist, Stockholm (Sweden)

MOST VIEWED

  • Angkor Wat named as the top landmark for the second year

    Travel website TripAdvisor has named Cambodia’s ancient wonder Angkor Wat as the top landmark in the world for the second year running in their Travelers’ Choice Award 2018, an achievement Cambodian tourism operators expect will attract more tourists to the Kingdom. The website uses traveller

  • Hun Sen detractors ‘will die’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Wednesday said those who curse or insult him would eventually die without a plot of land to bury their bodies after being killed by lightning, suffering the same fate as those who recently died in Thmar Baing district in Koh

  • Monks given ‘Samdech’ title for contributions

    Three senior monks on Thursday were given the highest-ranking title “samdech”, with Prime Minister Hun Sen saying that the promotions were due to their contributions to Buddhism. The three distinguished monks were promoted on Thursday morning at Botum Vatey pagoda in Phnom Penh, at a

  • Facing possible sanctions, PM criticises Washington’s rights record

    While United States congressmen are discussing the Cambodia Democracy Act and an amendment that could impose more sanctions against Cambodia’s government, Prime Minister Hun Sen on Tuesday counterattacked by questioning the respect of human rights and democracy under the US-backed Lon Nol regime, and